Unbelievable that this call happens with one out to go in what would have been a perfect game.
Here's the video of the call. Clearly out.
I saw the replay, that poor pitcher was robbed. MLB should include more replay. Heck, replay was good for the Game 3 of the Stanley Cup Finals and they were correct on those calls.
They an amendment that there putting in place to reverse the call. Jim Joyce the umpire apologised to Galaraga after he saw the replay, this is something that never happens. So they were both good sports about it and I have a greater respect for both!!!
That was a surprise honestly. I thought Donald was out and Detroit had a perfect game. At least the umpire did admit he was wrong unlike other ones. They probably wouldn't admit no matter how many times they saw it.
Yes, the call was blown. But that is the nature of the game if not all of sports. Is it fair? Of course not. But human failings are part of competing. This would be a great hub: "The impact of blown calls on sports." Olympic runners have fallen, passes are dropped, skiiers fall at the finish only to lose. This is sports.
But this is also the Era of the Bailout. Let's see, who has been bailed out in the past 16 months? Banks, Wall Street, big business, homeowners, even entire countries (Greece). And now, it appears, baseball pitchers. The call should stand and be accepted as the nature of the game. We all know it was a bad call. Only the record books and succeeding generations of fans won't know.
So here's what we do. Put an asterisk after the record book entry indicating it could have been a perfect game but for human error. We've all made them. Except for me.
It's the human element of the game.
This is why I didn't get my contest hub published, by the way. I couldn't turn off the game.
Here in Detroit, the consensus is to let the call stand. It shouldn't be overturned. (and it won't be).
Armando and Joyce both showed much class that I think this result actually turned out more positive than if the call was made correctly.
I don't see where the national media picked this up, but in a post game interview locally, Joyce was absolutely in tears. As was Jim Leyland. I've never see grown men cry like this
And Armando took it all in stride. He's a great guy.
GM has given him a spanking new Camaro to soften the blow.
Also, I don't know if anybody saw this nationally, but before today's game, Armando and Joyce met at home plate and shook hands. It was pretty neat.
all's well that ends well.
I don't really know the importance of a perfect game in baseball. Does it give you more points or something?
Whatever, he will be in the sports history books.
I felt really bad for the umpire when I saw him crying the next day. The pitcher was a really good sport about it.
He will be more well known for this non perfect game than if he actually got the perfect game.
Young players can learn from this pitcher on the way he acted (class act) to the situation. That is how I will remember him by.
yep, Corvette. I was listening to a call-in sports talk show when I heard Camaro.
It's time for instant replay in baseball.
Terrible calls like that could be avoided, too bad a perfect game went down the drain...............
My article was made for this topic! Check it out http://hubpages.com/hub/Why-Major-Leagu … ant-Replay
I was watching the game and jumped for joy when the ball was hit and knew it was a sure out to preserve the perfect game,-- then fell back into my seat in utter disbelief at the umps call.
Unbelievable umpires this season. Phil Cuzzi blew a call last month too.
by kathrynheath0707 10 years ago
So look, I am playing Final Fantasy 8 and want a perfect game memory card. Where do I save?Do I save at EVERY SINGLE save point because that would take 10 cards or at every major part of the game before I complete it or after???
by pendell2 12 years ago
Does baseball need an NFL-style replay, or is bad officiating still OK in 2009?
by Peter V 9 years ago
Are there any sports that don't have instant replay, but need it?American Football relies heavily on instant replay for the refs to make the right calls. Are there other sports that need to have instant replays for the refs to make the right decisions?
by Billy Petty 8 years ago
How extensive should replay be in Major League Baseball?
by madeline Oscar 11 years ago
Is this Game the perfect competitor for Call of Duty Series Games?Battlefield Badcompany 2 releasing this March 2010. There has been words coming out that this will be the perfect competitor for Call of Duty Games. Please share your suggestions whether to play this game or not.
by elisabeth reid 13 years ago
What do you think? Personally, I think its time has come but I don't think the timing is right. Something like that shouldn't be introduced at this point in the season. Either start it during the playoffs, when everyone goes back to 0-0, or wait until Spring Training.But...my...
|HubPages Device ID|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Google Analytics|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel|
|Google Hosted Libraries|
|Google AdSense Host API|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels|
|Author Google Analytics|
|Amazon Tracking Pixel|