Have you ever answered a question with a post or a hub and then had your content and ideas in those answers and hubs lifted by the person who posted the question to write their own hub? If so, how did you handle it? I think it is unethical at best, illegal at worst. It should be against HubPages rules.
That's actually why I avoid giving long detailed responses to any questions here. It's just too easy for someone to use my answer to draft an outline for their own hub. If I have the urge to give a really thorough answer, I prefer to write my own hub in response. It's nice because it gives you a link back to your hub.
I agree that it is a dodgy thing to do, but how unethical it is depends on how original your answer was. Were you including your own original research in your response, or giving out advice that was given to you from another source. It's hard to assign ownership to ideas. If you were passing along information that can be found elsewhere, I don't think it will do a lot of good to report it since you can't really prove that the other person stole the idea from you. They could always claim that they did their own independent research. (Which who knows, maybe they did.)
Their research consisted of reading and responding to my hubs until they were halfway convinced that what I had to say might carry some validity. They even copied one of my public domain photos and my layout. The ideas were gleaned from my answers and hubs. My ideas come from my work as a full time credentialed professional in the field and the hubs were a blend of current research, my own research, expert consensus and my own extrapolations and ideas on the subject.
You should definitely report the person if they're doing it so blatantly. While it's not against the rules for people to write on the same topics, it seems the other person is just piggybacking off of your articles. Not cool.
I agree and I did report it. We'll see if HP sees it the same way I do. Quite rude and unethical in my opinion.
Dubu, I think the following post from a long-ago thread may help answer your question:
Incidentally, this (current) thread of yours seems to provide more details about the problem than the other one does. Here, IMO, there's a stronger indication of why the "copying" is a problem.
Ideas are not copyright.
This article provides an interesting insight into copyright and what you can do.
http://www.allamericanblogger.com/21327 … zed-video/
The ideas are not. But there is also a standard of "substantial similarity" or "probative similarity" which may apply in this case. Check the post I linked, and follow the other links as you come to them. In my opinion, Dubuque-- has a genuine cause for concern.
Ecclesiastes 1:9. New International Version (NIV). 9 What has been will be again, what has been done will be done again; there is nothing new under the sun.
If you publish an idea, and the sun shines on it, anyone can use it.
Just Google the Internet.
You can't patent an idea either.
Addendum: your link is very helpful and informative, janderson. It draws an important distinction between copyright violation and plagiarism of other types.
In Dubuque's case, the offending Hub may not actually violate copyright laws, but it does appear definitely to violate HubPages' terms of service.
You are welcome. I do hope you get it sorted out. I know you've said that you've contacted the staff -- have you also flagged the offending Hub(s)? I think those methods of communication (e-mail contact and flagging) follow different paths, and I don't know which would be more effective. In flagging, it may help to provide a link to the Hub or Answer that has been plagiarized, and it may (underscore may) also help to use the exact expression "substantial similarity" when you report it.
Hopefully the person who has been using your hubs for "inspiration" will see this thread and cool their heels. If HP staff doesn't view the other person's activity as a violation, you could just start publishing dog training and health articles under another account. I also hope you get it all sorted out.
by sid_candid6 years ago
I was just thinking what is the best approach for success with Adsense. Before you say the same old things about SEO and keywords Here are the two approaches:Person A publishes 800-1000 hubs in a year with little...
by Rachael O'Halloran2 years ago
Inspired by WryLit's offer to help HubPages Community:I will answer your questions about copyright issues. If I don't know, I will research to find an answer for you. I write on quite a few copyright topics. I'm not an...
by Anthony Goodley7 years ago
Edweirdo asked me a question, a request to make a hub about a service I use in conjunction with HubPages. He wanted me to explain how it is setup and used since he could neither locate anything good on HubPages, through...
by lee3 years ago
I have not used hubpages for around a year and have recently started to get back into it, I must admit that in the beginning I was a little Naive and posted images into my hubs willy nilly without thought of where they...
by Susan Keeping8 years ago
There is a great discussion going on here about copyright:http://zenhabits.net/2008/01/open-sourc … y-content/The owner of this blog has made all of his work available for anyone to use anyway they wish.What do...
by WriteAngled5 years ago
I'm wondering if anyone can enlighten me on copyright and attribution issues with respect to products sold on Amazon. If I write a hub that focuses specifically on one or more Amazon products, where do I stand with...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.