First of all, the referred three, belong to a category, called, the hardened.
But if had no other Choices ...
I would prefer the "moderate" among these three, to be my employee ... one, who can do the job ... and that's it.
Because, every good hiring decision, is based in the demand/s and Nature, of the job ... not history ... though that's important.
Because, Dedication, is indicative of the fact, that in greater probability, he or she can .. and will Deliver ... meaning, Complete the assigned job.