As a lifelong Giants fan, I'm not surprised. This has been coming for some time. I picked them to finish last in the division and it appears I was right. Eli caught lightening in a bottle twice in his career. Got lucky. That won't happen anymore. The defense is not the same anymore with Osi Umenyoira gone. Victor Cruz is another very overrated receiver. Why pay a receiver big money? Try free agency. And finally, the O Line is getting old. So it's time to rebuild. New coach, new attitude, new players. Maybe a new QB?
They have never even made the playoffs the year after they've been in the Super Bowl (in team history). And remember in 2007 and 2010, they were a road wildcard team. They were lucky to make it. Granted, they won. But lots of underperforming QBs and team have won a ring. I have to stop ranting...sorry. Another great question.