I view the forums in Chronological mode and always import and edit the quote I'm replying to. Because I do that, I didn't think it was necessary to mention the name of the person I'm responding to. However recently, I've had a couple of misunderstandings where people thought I was responding to someone else, or where they seem to miss the point.
It's only just occurred to me to check the Threaded mode and discover that even if I take the trouble to import and edit a quote, it doesn't show up in Threaded mode. That's annoying, because often someone has written a long complicated post and I'm highlighting one particular point - if that isn't quoted, my comment doesn't make a lot of sense.
With the way our comments look when they're threaded, it's clear (based on a post's vertical positioning) whether a post is in response to another comment. Would it not be redundant to include those quotes?
Are those instances in which you've been misunderstood instances in which your response was not posted as a direct response to those posts?
No, I always use the "Reply" button and "import and edit quote", so clearly my response is always directly to the post in question.
Here's the most recent example:
http://hubpages.com/forum/topic/107453? … ost2290653
Besides as I said, it doesn't cover the situation where I want to make it clear I'm responding to one particular section of a long post.
Looking at that thread, every post of yours clearly indicates what post you are replying to in both threaded and chronological mode. Threaded mode does not, of course, indicate which part of a particular post you refer to, just the post itself.
Might you have a browser problem somehow?
I don't have a problem, it's the other people I'm conversing with!
Several times now, I've replied to a post, quoting part of the content, and either someone else thought I was replying to them, or the OP wasn't sure if I was replying to her.
At least one of them was a newbie who possibly didn't understand what the indent meant. But that's still a problem because a lot of newbies are in the forums.
Gotcha. Yes, I can where newbies might not get it right off, but it really shouldn't take long to figure it out.
I always use the threaded view, though, and it can be hard to understand which section of a post is being replied to.
Exactly. Just recently I replied to a newbie and I broke down her post into several sections, addressing each one separately so she could follow it. It never occurred to me that my breaks would be invisible - and without the individual quotes, my post is a lot harder to follow.
Like WriteAngled, I'm going to have to give up importing and editing and resort to copying and pasting.
Here's an example of me quoting one sentence from a longer post. If the OP can't see what I've quoted, he doesn't know what I'm saying "yes" to:
http://hubpages.com/forum/topic/106909? … ost2279069
I've been trying to find an example of where I've split a post up into sections and replied to each one individually, but I can't find the last time I did it.
When I import a quote and edit it to show a phrase/sentence, I do this for a very good reason. I am amazed to find out from this thread that this does not show up in some forum views. From now on, I will manually copy and paste rather than importing and preface what I have pasted with "xxx wrote:"
IMHO the quote should show in both views. It seems efficient to a forum engineer, but to normal users always inserting the quote is clearest.
It's like the sign in my building lobby that says: doctors office: Room 300. Whoever wrote that signs thinks it is 100% clear. But I have people asking every single day where the doctors office is (answer, the third floor).
"It's like the sign in my building lobby that says: doctors office: Room 300. Whoever wrote that signs thinks it is 100% clear. But I have people asking every single day where the doctors office is (answer, the third floor)."
It isn't clear at all, unless there is a further sign saying that the first digit of the room number indicates the floor. After all, there might always be 350 rooms on the ground floor.
As a UK resident, I would count Ground Floor, First Floor, Second Floor, Third Floor and get it wrong anyway
Here's another example of a forum poster thinking I replied to her post when I actually quoted and replied to someone else entirely:
Clearly, she doesn't understand how the indents work.
I think she clearly wanted to know which part you were referring to since timetraveler was referring to her previous post. She wanted to understand which part you meant.
I usually copy and paste what I want to quote. Sometimes I use import and export. I don't use the threaded view, it's confusing to read.
by Marisa Wright3 years ago
I've only just discovered that quoted sections do not show up in "Threaded" view. If someone posts a long list of questions, I'll often manually quote the different sections so I can reply to them...
by simeonvisser6 years ago
HubPages does not use a flat forum structure but replies are placed underneath the post to which they reply. This means that when a thread becomes huge people can still place posts in the middle of the thread. In other...
by sunforged7 years ago
With some users using the threaded view and others using chrono some threads are becoming intelligible Ex)http://hubpages.com/forum/topic/34590#post769233You'll see in chrono view that one hubber responds in a...
by FloraBreenRobison5 years ago
Once again, I have found a person responding to my original post starting a forum thread instead of replying to a comment that was a reply to mine.I was talking about photograph citation including , among other things,...
by Person of Interest6 years ago
What a poster set to Chrono posts is not always what a reader set to Threaded sees. And vice-versa for all I know. In other words, I'll bet there have been lots of miscommunications where both sides end up being...
by Sherri7 years ago
I'm sure there are many reasons for and against responding to comments left by your readers. What do you think?
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.