Is the Google keyword tool wrong? Or is hubpages a scam. How in the world can my hub be #1 with the keyword, "how to doodle" with the average local volume at 1,8000,000 and my traffic is decreasing at 5 hits a day. Something is not right?
Something is not right for sure! I put specific keywords and phrases from google in a hub that HP keeps zapping. Metrics did not recognize any keywords before or after I put them in.
There's no point in researching keywords if google is still not going to recognize them! It's useless! (just my opinion)
I just checked my article "Researching Old Military Photos", and metrics still says there are no search terms. This is BS because the title is a high ranking search phrase!
Typing in "Researching Old Military Photos" places you seven in Google ranking - however Google Adwords show no traffic - this is probably because not many people are searching for that phrase. The phrase 'old military photos' does show some traffic so you should see some traffic over time - the problem you have is that you are not ranked top - so you will only get a minor part of the traffic!
Where are you getting the information that it's a highly searched term?
I just tried it in the Adwords keyword tool and it says there are precisely zero searches for that term.
Take out the word "researching" and there are 46 searches a month. Change "photos" to "pictures" and it's even worse - 28 searches. Globally.
Change the parameters to "Broad" instead of "Exact" and it improves to 390 searches, which is still not great.
"Military pictures" is a highly searched term, but that would cover modern as well as old images.
You are coming up seventh on google. 90% of views tend to go to the first five in search rankings. At seven you should get 2% views in theory - so that would still be 30000 a month or perhaps 1000 a day! of course this assumes that Google Adwords are accurate- and from my experience over the last few years - I always divide by at least ten if I am ranked in the top 3 and probably more below that!
I can attest that HP is definately not a scam - they have no control over views Google sends you - you can compare views on Google Analytics if you've signed up for them!
There's more to it than that, Simey. There are 6,120,000 searches for "how to doodle" and all similar phrases. I get the OP as #8 here for the phrase, but that does not mean that he will be #1 for all those other similar phrases.
On the other hand, there are just monthly 2400 searches for the exact phrase "how to doodle"; 2% of that is just 1 1/2 per day average.
To the OP: that your traffic for this hub is decreasing by 5 hits per day means exactly nothing, whether you are seeing 100 per day or 15. I have one hub that drops 100 per day (or more) every Friday, like clockwork. On Monday it goes back up that same 100 per day.
In any event, HP does not control your traffic; that perk belongs almost exclusively to you and google. Mostly google.
The wrong titles show up in google at #7.. Thats because HP keeps unpublishing it and google doesn't get a chance to even see that the title is a current search phrase. which is different.
It was searched 11 hours ago and no search terms were found.
Presumably you are meaning the "search terms" found in the hub metrics on the hub itself.
It will probably take HP a month of decent organic traffic to collect any terms - say a few hundred readers coming in via google.
Simey is right; there are about 45 searches per month for "old military photos" and none at all for your title. Searching for "old military photos" does not produce your hub anywhere in the top 50 results; you are thus extremely unlikely to get any traffic at all from that keyword.
Starting in 2011, Google started hiding the search term of referred traffic for people that were signed in to a Google account. As of November it was estimated that represented 39% of requests, and it's probably even higher now. So, while we may know that the traffic to a Hub came from search, we only get the terms some of the time. It's probably best to just consider the relative quantity of the different terms rather than looking at the absolute number.
Google hides the info in analytics, but do they also hide it in the keyword tool?
I can't find any info to say yay or nay on that.
Susana, I can't find the article, but I do remember reading that although they hide it from GA, they DO NOT hide in the keyword tool as they believe it's of benefit to advertisers. The article was talking about the hypocrisy of hiding one but not the other, and privacy concerns.
That makes much more sense to me. Advertisers DO need to know the actual traffic potential of phrases and how much they're likely to cost. If my budget was nearly 40% out I'd be pretty peeved!
I agree with you on the low searches for "old military photos'" but thats not my title! It's "old military pictures" and a couple others I put in.
I'd like to further add that the title that shows in HP when you hover over my hub title does not match the current title. Therefore it will never be right! The title that shows is one that was used a year ago!
Why does the title not change?
The title is what you see regardless of a hovering mouse.
The URL is what a hovering mouse will show, and is not changeable. Whatever you put in when you wrote it is what it will remain.
It's the URL that shows, which can't be changed. It's not that important so long as your actual title is correct.
Unfortunately, as I stated, your title keywords are not highly searched at all, so the whole thing is really irrelevant, I'm afraid.
As others have said, are you using "broad" or "exact" match when you check the number of searches? "Exact" is the only one that counts.
This what happens when you use "broad match" rather than "exact match" in the keyword tool - you'll get search volume results that are nowhere near a reflection of reality. We've all made the same mistake at some point it's just a case of learning from it and moving on
Also, I don't see your hub on the first page of Google search at all - for me your hub is at number 15 (so half way down page 2). What you're seeing are personalised results. You can turn that some of that off, but not all of it unfortunately. https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/54048?hl=en
Here are more tips on de-personalising Google search: http://howto.cnet.com/8301-11310_39-574 … h-results/
The good news is that if your newly published hub is on page 2, it can easily get to page 1 over time.
How do you know it's ranked #1? If you're searching for your Hub on Google on your own computer, you're seeing personalized results and that means nothing.
Do you have the Match Types set to "Broad" or "Exact"? "Broad" will give you a misleading result, because it includes that phrase and all other similar phrases.
Switch to "Exact" and you'll see that "How to Doodle" gets 2,400 searches a month - which is still worth going for, for a subject where isn't already a lot of competition from other sites.
Dude, would you mind posting a screenshot to substantiate your 'accidental' success?
Er, I mean, the No. 1 Hub in the World! How cute!!
This thread on The World Taxidermy Federation really should be reclassified on the topics page. HP is slipping...
by Jeff 7 years ago
17 Hubs published and I get about one view per day between all of them? I realize it takes a while to establish yourself but is that normal? Does it pick up over time? All my articles are well over length and get maximum hubber checkmarks? Now, granted, I don't...
by Whikat 12 years ago
I hope someone can help answer this question for me. I wrote a hub, I picked the keywords very carefully, I wrote my first paragraph very carefully to attract the audience I wanted. I wrote a full header description. I go to see where my hub ended up after a few days and instead of...
by OanaBoteanu 9 years ago
I am new to hubpages (about 2 weeks) and I have been educating myself in ways to drive traffic to my hubs. I would love to get some advice from existing hubbers and your knowledge in traffic.What are your top methods of driving traffic?What is time effective/what is not?Any advice is welcome and...
by Sophia Angelique 10 years ago
Well, I would have made it sooner if it hadn't been for stupid Panda. But after a year, I finally got to the place where I've achieved payout in one month! Now if I could actually get a payout every month from now on, I'd be happy! I think I quite like HP new advertising plan after all.
by Melanie Palen 11 years ago
What are some of the weirdest, strangest things that people have searched for to get to your hubs. Nope, I'm not looking for your keywords or anything... I'm talking about those things that people search that have made you go "wtf!"I got a funny one just the other day. I almost peed my...
by Anita Hasch 5 years ago
I hope somebody can help. I now have 49 hubs, and yet not one of them are seen by the search engines. When I click on their stats, it says under 'search phrases,' no search terms to add.(list of words that appear commonly in searches that bring visitors to your hub.)It seems that all my hubs need...
Copyright © 2022 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|