I doubt the links in the forum posts carry much weightage in anyway. Therefore, I suggest that all links here be no-followed.
Other than normal chit chat one of the main posts include those of content thieves. People don't break up the links so as to prevent them from forming and why should they when they can all be no follow instead?
There are thousands of links by now and I'm sure the reputation of the site would be damaged at least a bit (After all the forums are not on their own subdomain now). It's on the hubpages domain. Possiblty the Editors Choice hubs could be affected because of these crazy links too. You never know what kind of penalties are around the corner.
We already set users with a HubberScore below a threshold so all their links are nofollow in the forums and Hubs.
I can bring up the idea of nofollow for all links in the forum in our next community meeting.
Hmm, I receive traffic from my forum posts. Always have. Making the forum "nofollow" would definitely remove any benefits to participating in the conversations.
Think about this before making a decision!
Why? Anyone clicking the link will still go through, google's bots simply won't follow it. You would lose any link juice, but that's all. Traffic should remain.
You're not going to lose any traffic. It's just as wilderness stated.
That's true Matthew and it's great that it works that way. But, people posting links of scrapers are usually people who are involved on the site and hence have a higher score (So their links are followed). Probably if you'll could work on a way wherein the links posted in the body of the posts (Not the users subdomain) are no-followed that would make everyone happy. Still, according to me the links don't do much, but why take a risk?
I think the entire forum should be off-limit to search engines. There's nothing of value here to anyone outside of the HubPages community and offering these pages to Google diminishes the overall quality of the HP website. These are not quality pages.
Writer Fox: I have felt this way for some time. When the forums get ugly, as they often do, I do not think it's good PR let alone good for HP.
That's an even better suggestion than what I've said
Except that Google and Matt Cutts talk about rewarding sites that provide service, interactivity, and engagement to users. A lot of the recent guidelines have been about, "what do you give your visitors?"
Google's algorithm is intelligent enough to understand the difference between forum content and regular site content.
I think it would be counter-productive to conceal a useful part of the site when there is absolutely no indication that Google penalizes sites with forums. If members had spammy signature links, that might be a problem, but our no-signature forums are actually less spammy than most sites.
I am extremely dubious about nofollowing the forums, but whatever. But if you start talking about telling Google not to look at a piece of the site that's useful... and it makes it harder for members to search for and find help on Hubpages because that resource has disappeared from the Google index... no. Just no. You'd better be 110% sure that it's what's causing your traffic woes before you start flailing like that.
These forums have no benefit to anyone outside of the HubPages community. They are not for the engagement of visitors to the site. Some Web forums are about subjects people do search for and they belong in the index. Blocking HP forums from search engines increases the crawl priority to Hubs. Yes, Google can 'see' what is on here: useless information for its index published on the HP site. HubPages removed some older posts from search engine access for this reason. It should remove the rest as well. HubPages traffic isn't flailing; it's rapidly falling. You have said that your income here has fallen, too. (My traffic is good.)
''Blocking HP forums from search engines increases the crawl priority to Hubs'
Is Google search engine power especially pitiful at present?
Auntie Em, I wouldn't be comparing your earnings to GG's.
I don't know why I am taking this seriously, but then it is monsoon season...
site:hubpages.com/forum About 21,400 results
site:hubpages.com About 576,000 results
So the forum is about 3 or 4 per cent of the site as a whole (roughly).
Lets hope those forum posts are not too tiring....
WriterFox, you don't have to block something entirely from Google's index; you can specify crawl priority in the sitemap. Or at least, I learned how to do so when I set one up ten years ago — lately I've been lazy-ass and trusting WP software to auto-generate sitemaps — but I assume that functionality hasn't been removed from sitemaps. Or has it?
My Hub traffic and income aren't particulary relevant here, since they're content pages, not forum pages, and they're off in their own subdomains. Google can certainly tell the difference betwen them and forums. So I'm not sure why you're bringing up my income. But if you want to use that as some kind of evidence (!?)... er... feel free? Here's the main account's analytics dump.
Income is in lockstep with traffic, fluctuations with a modest gain over the past year, so, make of it what you will.
Where are people getting this idea that Google wants forums noindexed? Can you point to something in webmaster guidelines I missed? It's not something I've seen any major website do, so I am extremely puzzled.
by Artin2010 8 years ago
I've come to the conclusion that in order to get people to even look at your hubs, you must post in these forums. It may help get a few more fans, but if it doesn't, what have you lost. I've come here to hubber's hangout to see if anybody will become curious about my writing. I'm guessing I'm not...
by Peg Cole 5 years ago
Is there a way to get rid of unwanted traffic sites that attach a link to our hubs without our knowledge? I try to individually monitor my hubs for suspicious traffic and have written two letters to the offender who has sent me 8 visits on one hub this week. Now HubPages has marked my hub with a...
by Hugh Williamson 14 months ago
Paid forum posting is a business that's growing rapidly because of the glut of money in politics and the desire of commercial interests to promote their products and to blunt criticism.Should paid forum posters be forced to acknowledge that they are being paid? Should they be banned from posting...
by Ben Guinter 6 years ago
I'm curious to hear if there are any hubbers, who saw a big drop in traffic after the most recent Google Panda and Penguin updates, have fixed their issues and are getting good traffic again yet?I think it would be good for us all to know what changes brought about your renewal of traffic, since...
by Dorian Bodnariuc 17 months ago
"Paranoia" must think some of you, and honestly, I used to think the same. I didn't even believe that this was possible, even though Google mentioned that they have ways to detect link spamming. But the reality proved me I was wrong. My Traffic Is Constantly Going DownI did complain a...
by Steve Andrews 5 years ago
When it was first introduced I was annoyed by it but made an effort to tweak my hubs to get them out of Idle status. Now, a whole load have got zzs against them again and many of them are hubs that at one point were very successful and even now still have scores above 70 or higher.One of the hubs...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|