I just noticed that comments I delete from the 'comments' section on my accounts page are not being deleted from the actual hubs. One of my hubs gets spammed a lot by people posting links and email addresses for 'quack' healthcare. I have clicked the 'spam' button and then clicked 'delete,' etc., but just today I noticed they appeared to be published. I tried to delete again from the hub - hope it went through properly this time.
Any advice from the admins or tech support? Thanks!
Can you provide the title of the specific Hub and the comments that you marked as SPAM and deleted?
Here's the hub that's been spammed repeatedly:
FYI - Just before I posted this thread, I 'permanently deleted' a series of comments left over the past several months, but I had to do it from the actual hub; the 'spam' and 'delete' buttons on my accounts page did not delete them. We have heard we should handle our comments from the accounts page, but now I am worried that spam comments should be deleted directly from the hub rather than on the accounts page (the section where we can see our comments and reply).
The comments I deleted were spammy links with testimonials of people claiming to be 'cured' of HIV by 'miracle' healers of some sort. I had no idea those comments were not permanently deleted from the hub after I 'deleted' them from the accounts page; I had to go to the actual hub earlier today and that's when I noticed they were still there. I am sure you can still find the history of those comments on your backup server if you want to see them (sorry for deleting the 'evidence').
One concern is that if the mechanism for deleting spam on our accounts page isn't working right, Google will slam our site, big time. This is as bad as having spam links in the forum, or on the Q&A section. But, if we are not aware the spam wasn't deleted, those imbedding links in comments are still lingering on the site. I'm sure I am not the only person who has had to delete spammy comments with links. But I cannot remember all the various hubs on which those things have appeared.
I looked at your account and see that that Hub is only set to show comments you explicitly approve, so unless you are approving SPAM comments, there isn't a risk of the comment affecting your Hub.
If you choose to filter by SPAM, you can see the comments that you have marked as SPAM.
The comments that are marked as SPAM, but not deleted will not show on your Hubs.
So you can see them when you are logged in, but other users will not and if you log off you should no longer see the comment as well.
That being said, it sounds like you are saying the following.
1. You marked a comment as SPAM here with the "unmoderated" filter.
http://hubpages.com/my/hubs/comments?co … nmoderated
And it was still showing on your published Hub.
If you have this occur again, mark the comment as SPAM, but please do not permanently delete it. If you still see the comment you marked as SPAM on a Hub when logged out, please let us know and we can check out the specific comment to see if there is an issue with the system.
Thanks, Matthew - I am relieved that perhaps the spammy comments were not visible to readers. Since I get spam on this hub fairly often (at least once or twice a month), I will do as you suggest and let you know, so you can check it out.
FYI, Matthew, SPAM posts are back in the forums, 3 posts 2 minutes ago.
Have you tried just marking one message as 'spam' without deleting it to see what happens? That is how 'spam' gets marked in the email.
Update for Matthew:
Thanks for suggesting that I sign out & view my hubs without being logged onto the site. As you predicted, it appears the spam comments are not visible.
FYI - I have had repeat offenders on the HIV hub I posted here. I've also had a 'run' on other spam comments. If you have time (and if it would help prevent spammers from hitting us), please check the comments I marked as spam on my accounts page. In particular, the HIV spammers return time after time to 'promote' some sort of miracle cure person. They all appear to be from another country.
The other 'frequent-flyer' spammers are hitting a hub about spotting online dating scams (you can find an example of this on my accounts page 'comments' section, too). If there's a way to block these people, it sure would save some time for me and for other hubbers they're probably hitting.
Instead of logging off, try clicking on 'Preview' (upper left) when you are in edit. I found that it is usually the same unless you are going to wait for some time. If you are not, then you can use 'Preview' and click when you the 'x' in the upper right you are immediately back in edit. You can repeat this back and forth if you need to.
Keep labeling them as SPAM. The issue is that many of them are automated are not the same person coming from the same IP.
The more people can identify the SPAM the better our system can be in identifying SPAM before you see it (it can tell if it came from a spammy IP for example based on past reports).
I know that SPAM is annoying, but short of disabling comments entirely there is no practical way to eliminate it.
SPAM is such a widespread problem online, that Google has changed the YouTube commenting system and sites like Popular Science has disabled comments all together.
http://www.popsci.com/science/article/2 … r-comments
http://www.theverge.com/2013/9/24/47667 … -to-google
Thanks, Matthew - this suggests the system (here at HP) actually does do something with our spam reports? I always flag spam as such, but never knew what results came if it.
Just to check - can I 'delete forever' the examples I left in my comments records on the accounts page now? Wanted to make certain you've had a chance to review the info. Please, please, ban those IPs if at all possible. I recognize the repeat content.
Yes, we use SPAM reports to identify users, IPs, and other identifying aspects of SPAM reports and use that to determine and block future SPAM, so marking comments as SPAM helps prevent future such comments.
Yes, you can delete the comments forever.
by Deborah 4 years ago
Is it ever justified to delete reader comments?Do you ever delete comments on your Hubpages? Sometimes we get inappropriate or over promoting comments on our hubs, how do you handle the situation?
by Lela 3 years ago
Do you agree or disagree with the new suggestions for deleting and editing comments? Why or Why not?So now it turns out that we should have been deleting comments all along! Google drops our page rank because of bad comments - comments that do not ADD to the hub, Q&A, or Forum posts. Will...
by BobbiRant 7 years ago
Why would anyone delete a comment on their hub?If I deleted a comment on one of my hubs, I would figure I am not good at dealing with people who might disagree with me. People can agree or disagree, it's a free world. If the comment was mean or nasty, well I'm not the one looking bad,...
by Kenna McHugh 6 months ago
Some of us have mentioned deleting low-performing articles from your Hubs. I sense they do it because it increases views/impressions. How does that increase views/impressions?
by Chace 5 years ago
Some people say you should never, ever delete a hub...only edit it and such. What makes you just completely trash your own hubs?
by Catherine Giordano 4 years ago
If you deny someone's comment does it hurt their hubber score? Does it hurt you own hubber score if you deny the comments of others? Does it hurt the hub score if the hub has a denied comment?
Copyright © 2019 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|