jump to last post 1-2 of 2 discussions (8 posts)

I'd like feedback on my Hub: Dresses For Plus Size Women

  1. Princessa profile image86
    Princessaposted 2 years ago

    Hi Hubbers,

    I'd like some help with passing the Quality Assessment Process. Will you please give feedback on my Hub Dresses For Plus Size Women. What can I do to improve? Thanks!

    1. Fiction Teller profile image61
      Fiction Tellerposted 2 years agoin reply to this

      Hi Princessa,

      I looked at your hub. The sense I've gotten from exchanging emails with the team at HubPages is that with the current standards:

      1) Even though there's a 100-words-of-text-to-product limit ratio, this is not so much what's allowed, as the maximum of what's allowed. I'm not sure why they mention the 100-words-to-product thing anymore, because it's superseded by a idea that any more than a few (read, 2-3)  product links in most hubs (including those 2000-3000 words) appear to be rejected, due to seeming spammy to the quality moderators.

      2) For every single product promoted, you need to demonstrate your personal experience with it. Any grandfathered hubs designed to focus on products you haven't actually used will be unfeatured.

      3) The accessories section is probably considered tangential to the hub now. Whereas years ago, they encouraged in-depth hubs that were kind of substitutes for whole websites and included such tangential topics, now they want deeply focused stuff. And whereas before they discouraged too-blatantly-personal-bloglike posts, now they want us to carefully, oh-so-carefully walk that delicate line between personal experience and authority, with a weight on personal experience.

      Also, this is just my guess, but it could be that photos featuring some media personalities might not be considered okay to use anymore by HubPages, not because of copyright but because of moral rights. Not sure if they've gone that far, though.

      Hope that helps. I'm guessing this won't pass to be featured until it's significantly culled.

      Good luck.

      1. Princessa profile image86
        Princessaposted 2 years agoin reply to this

        Thanks a lot for your feedback.  I have been away for a while from the site and it seems like a completely new place now.  There are so many new rules that I find difficult to keep up with all the changes. 

        I'll take your comments into account and see if I can change the slant of the page to something more "hubpages suitable".  It looks like a lot of work though, I wonder if it wouldn't be easier to start from scratch...

        1. Marisa Wright profile image98
          Marisa Wrightposted 2 years agoin reply to this

          Princessa, a lot has changed since you've been away!   Your Hub is a perfect example of the style of Sales Hub which used to make big money on HP - and possibly still could on your own blog - but is now deeply frowned upon here.

          You do have some useful information to offer on this topic, but that's not obvious at a cursory glance.  The early part of the Hub looks like you've grabbed a few celebrity shots and you're retreadng some well-worn advice from the women's magazines.   So I think you need to reorganise the content

          - your opening shot is just a photo of a celebrity with no meaningful comment, which doesn't give the reader confidence you're going to offer solid information.  If you're going to open with an image, I think it needs to be a comparison shot or a before/after. 

          - make better use of sub-headings to organise your content into different kinds of advice.

          - for every Amazon dress you're recommending, write a description to explain WHY you're recommending it.

          1. Princessa profile image86
            Princessaposted 2 years agoin reply to this

            Thank you Marisa.  It looks like a lot of work.  I wonder if it is really worth it...

            It is amazing how much the site has changed.  I hope that  in the end it is for the best.

            1. Marisa Wright profile image98
              Marisa Wrightposted 2 years agoin reply to this

              Yes, I wonder if it's worth it, too!   

              HubPages has changed because Google has changed its algorithm, and all website owners are making changes accordingly.   I'm not convinced that HubPages has made the RIGHT changes, but it's their site so it's their privilege!   

              I took a look at your EscapeArtist blog - are you still actively maintaining it?  Looks interesting but it has a few issues.

              If you want to debate further you can PM me.

              1. Princessa profile image86
                Princessaposted 2 years agoin reply to this

                Actually, I had completely forgotten about that site.  I haven't been in it for a long time now and  I wasn't aware that it was still marked in my HP profile.  I'll better take it away.  Thanks

  2. Fiction Teller profile image61
    Fiction Tellerposted 2 years ago

    Oh, and overall, you'd need to change the slant of the page. Right now it says "sales page." Though you and I both remember when sales pages were a legitimate format here, and your targeted readers like them when they're not deceptive, now they're now lumped together with spam pages.