They've replaced the name 'HubPages' with 'Storyteller' on every page.
Edit, I've emailed the team, but I would suggest that you post again in the Technical Questions forum as staff are unlikely to see this under Help for New Hubbers.
Yep. They scraped HubPages and made their own site. Hopefully the content there is penalized, instead of the original on HubPages.
Search engines know your content was published on HubPages first. The scraped content on StoryTeller is considered duplicate content and is penalized. If your content has been copied I suggest filing a DMCA complaint with Google to get the scraped content removed from search results. If you have any questions please email firstname.lastname@example.org.
Why haven't hubpages done anything about this site? It's been there for years.
You own the material; you must take the action. HP cannot as they don't own the hub.
I actually don't care that much about my work being copied. Every now and then, I will sit down and go through my hubs and take action.
However this has nothing to do with my hubs. The entire hubpage site is copied, including every single one of your hubs.
They are using HP material as well. It's the whole site, the structure, the links (some of them anyway), everything. So they've probably copied the source code.
I agree that when individual hubs are stolen, the writer needs to act, but when it is the whole site, then the site owners should do something about it. It's a threat to their livelihoods.
HubPages does not take any action on plagiarism. They have stated many times that removing plagiarized work is the responsibility of the content owner.
The reason is that legally, only the copyright owner has a legal right to file a complaint, and HubPages is not the copyright owner.
It's the entire hubpages site that has been duplicated. Read the earlier posts. Hubpages can't do anything about it, because it's Russian.
@Matt Wells, the website is not penalized and is well-indexed in Google search engines. No matter how much you file DMCA, if that website is hosted from a company that ignores DMCA, nothing you can do. And, no matter how you shout out loud about "copyrights infringement", the truth of the matter is, this is internet. Anything you publish in the open is at risk of it. And Copyrights law is nothing if you file against a country who doesn't have a law for that, so much more if the hosting company is a ghost.
Hello Julie Nou,
Yes, there is nothing much we can do for a scraper site based in Russia that ignores DMCA complaints. However, you can file a DMCA complaint with Google to have your stolen content removed from search results. Also, keep in mind that your content was published first so anything StoryTeller copies is considered duplicate content by search engines.
This one even has the Hubpages logo in it, too!!! https://mcenter.spb[dot]ru/
I question the 'legal' aspect of HP filing DMCAs on our behalf, which is why I created this new thread ...
https://hubpages.com/community/forum/14 … -our-dmcas
Seems to me, if they can change the rules to 'edit' our articles, they can figure out a way to legally help 'protect' our articles. Anyway, have a look and see if you agree with me or not.
Everyone should stop posting links to those sites. You're just giving them more inbound links which increases their ranking.
To show us the URL's without helping the scrapers, leave spaces in the URL.
People aren't posting links to that site. It has been there at least six years that I know of.
Tess, you did post several links to that site, in your first post. Glenn is pointing out that posting hyperlinks to a site enhances its reputation with Google (Google's monitoring system does not understand context, so it assumes that every link is a recommendation). Therefore it is never a good idea to do it.
My mistake. However if I hadn't posted them, how would you know what site I am talking about? Also, nobody else is posting links to it, and I am pretty sure that if one posts just one link, google ignores it.
No, Google does not ignore a single link.
You can post the link with spaces so it doesn't create a live hyperlink.
To my mind, that is pointless. Everybody still has to put it together and click on it to go to the site. So maybe 20 people here click on it. It's not even remotely enough to get it to feature. Certainly, 20 clicks on any one of my hubs doesn't make it go up in the SERPS. Why would it do so for this website? Sorry, I don't buy it.
I think you'd know by now that the decisions Google makes are not always logical in our eyes. It has nothing to do with whether people click on it.
At its most basic level, Google judges the reputation of a site by the number of other sites which display links to it. That was the method Google originally used to rank sites and although they have added a huge number of other refinements since then, that measure is still part of the algorithm. As Marketing Merit says, links lend credibility.
Tess, why do you insist on continuing to remain in denial. You are hurting yourself and you are hurting all of us by posting links to these sites.
Management edited your first post, and the other Hubber's post as well, to make the links inoperative. Marisa and I suggested adding spaces to show us the URL, but you can also format it using [dot] in place of the “.” as you can see now in your edited first post.
I am not in denial. It is plain common sense. If 20 people click on a link that I posted in facebook, it doesn't even remotely push my hub up the SERPs.
It is bullarkey to suggest otherwise.
Please note I won't do it again. Next time I just won't bother to post.
I disagree with management. authority, and others often. It is called being an independent thinker.
The entire notion is so ridiculous, I don't have time or energy to explain it to you.
You’re missing the point. Or you’re not reading Marisa's explanations. Google does not rank much based on the click itself. It ranks on the fact that the link exists. A link from a high ranking site like HubPages has much more merit than a link from Facebook. That’s why your links from Facebook don’t do much to push you up in the SERPs. I'm ending this discussion. I don’t have time for this either. We both told you everything you need to know. Your refusal to accept it is your business.
How so? I said I wouldn't do it again. I just don't accept the explanation. I don't believe it. It doesn't mean I don't respect the fact that I have been asked not to do it - not that I go around posting links on the hubpages forum. It's not as if I do this every day of my life. The problem was already corrected. I truly don't see why it's so important for me to agree with you.
Tess, I explained to you why it matters. It has nothing whatsoever to do with you posting links on Facebook (which is a social network and counted differently anyway). Google doesn't even care whether anyone clicks on the links - it's the location and number of links that counts. The more links from reputable sites, the higher a site will rank.
You may think posting just one link hardly matters - but remember, you are one of millions of people on the internet and you don't know how many other people are linking to it as well. Why would you risk adding to their reputation? It's so easy to avoid.
This article explains in detail exactly how it works.
It may sound illogical to you, but the fact is, it's how Google works and you thinking it's illogical won't change that.
Glenn is referring to the links you included in your opening post, I believe Tess. Backlinks from a relatively high page ranking site, such as HP, only serves to lend credibility to the scraped content. That is why links should always be cloaked in some way.
I think Google/Yahoo can do its part by having some system to quickly remove these copycats from their listing. Criminals do this for quick profit. When there's little to gain, the scums would move on to other things.
Speaking of "ru", I bet every website owner here gets visits from them daily; I've gotten over a 100 hits in less than a minute from them on occasion. Scary actually. Bot hack attempts? Thefts? Who knows? Extremely depressing, but not a thing we can do about it.
Also, please note. The question was answered. It is someone in Russia copying the entire site. There is nothing hubpages can do because Russia does not respect the laws of other countries. Aldo, it is inconceivable hubpages didn't know about this.
Next, I don't have the time to go and complete a form for every article of mine that is stolen. To me. the few extra pennies I might earn doesn't compensate for the time lost. And I have never seen an increase in earnings when something was removed from the web.
The argument is rather like the one that people with no money will suddenly start paying for very expensive software if all the pirated software were suddenly removed.
No, they wouldn't start buying it because they still wouldn't have the money to buy it.
Removing pirated articles from the web does not automatically increase views on hubpages. For a start, the browsers in different countries send local content first and doesn't send international content at all if the particular website hasn't set it up that way.
The internet is different in every country. Everytime, I switch countries, I lose half my search capacity from the previous country. Fortunately, I know how to change that, but most people don't.
It might make you happy to know that the site loads terribly in the US and most of the hyperlinks don't even show up on the screen - it's close to being worthless (at least that's what I see)
So, I just found this thread by Google search. And because we are not talking about individual stolen hubs, but the entirety of Hubpages itself, I just do not buy the concept that HP cannot do anything about it. This Russian site has stolen branding and images that belong to Hubpages. That in itself is worth a fight, regardless of the country. A good international law legal team can look into this .... has that happened?
And I have filed a complaint with Google, but my experience with Google is ... they don't give a rat's ass. IF they respond at all. Ah, well. I love the part in the stolen Storyteller's TOS about how they respect copyright and intellectual property. Yup.
Teri, do you understand what Google does when you report stolen content? Google doesn't have the power to actually remove the article. All Google can do is hide it from its search algorithm, so it won't rank when people search for that topic. You can still see the article if you go to the site. The only people who can physically remove the article are either the website owner or the host.
You also have to be sure to use the right form to report stolen content to Google. They don't make the process obvious, I must say.
Yes, I know Google cannot remove the article, I have had some luck in the past with contacting offending sites to remove scraped contact. In this case, I was (am) dismayed that when I did a search, the fake site popped up on the first page, with my title. So ... I'm trying an experiment, The article is called Life After Ringling, When the Circus Closes Down. I have asked my circus friends and "audience" in my circus social media groups to search for and share the article over the next few days to get it active on the HubPages/Hobbylark site-- to overpower anything that the thief site is doing. I don't know if it will help, of course, but I want to see our site come up first in Google, at least.
"lille fete du cirque alexander lacey."
Alex is an animal trainer -- he was with Ringling, this was the show in France he's been with for a few weeks (although he'll be somewhere else, soon). Alex is included in this piece that features a number of Ringing circus players. The Russian link comes up fourth from the top. It was a surprise to see it under this fake site and I am guessing more searches may turn this, or any other article, up like this. I have two published articles here, written about Alexander Lacey (I work with him on a number of other things, too). It's one thing to have my stuff stolen; that's happened before. But this is a HP fight and I hope they are taking it seriously.
It also comes up with Weinachts Circus Alexander Lacey (he'll be there for the holidays).
For both those searches, and for "Life After Ringling", your Hub is high on the front page and the Russian site is nowhere to be seen.
Have you asked your friends to see what they see?
As you know, searches are individual and I'm wondering if, since you probably went and checked out the Russian site, Google is now including it for you (since Google knows you already consulted it).
I suppose that is possible that Google thinks I want to access it. How ironic! I know it will take a lot of time for Google to review the complaint-- I am scheduled for back surgery next week so I probably won't delve into all of this much more for now.
There is no DMCA for a .de DMCA for for The United States. Germany might have ways for you to complain, but it could be ignored. Many countries from china to pakistan, from russia to india..... don't really care about ripping the US off via the internet.
I've found most European hosting companies are very reasonable and will do the right thing. While it's not called DMCA in those countries, they still have strict copyright laws and if you use the same format as a DMCA, you'll likely fulfil the requirements of those laws.
The best thing is always to look and see if they have their own form for you to fill in.
Oh, and I sent an email to the ripoff site's "team" address listed on their page. Email is undeliverable. Gee, what a surprise!
Matt from HP tells me to file a complaint with google (which i've already done). But I have asked if HP is fighting against this site that has stolen its branding and content. I think it is important for us to know what is being done for our protection, because we all depend on HP's ability to keep its walls strong. I don't really expect anyone from Team HubPages to answer this (publicly) but I do hope we hear from Robin, or Paul, or Christy on this.
There are a few reasons we don't take action when scraper sites pop up. The first is that they are usually located in countries like Russia where copyright law is not respected or enforced, so taking the time to file a bunch of documents that will not do any good anyway would not be a good use of our company's resources and wouldn't benefit us or authors.
The second is that scraper sites often don't exist very long before they are either dropped from Google's index completely or banned by the hosting company, or both. (Filing complaints with Google as Matt recommends can help speed up this process.)
The third is that the existence these sites does not significantly harm us or authors. Articles that are scraped show up with a duplicate content penalty and almost never rank higher in search results than the original articles. Spending money and resources to remove sites that don't represent any significant loss of earnings to us wouldn't be a good way for us to best serve the needs of authors.
Stealing is still morally abhorrent, of course, and we do understand it's very frustrating. But there's just not really anything we could realistically do that would make any kind of significant dent in online content theft in a meaningful or lasting way.
Thanks, Christy, I think this is info we all need to know about. I appreciate your keeping us in the loop.
Just to follow up, I get notification that the URL link of the offending site is not bringing up the story; and when I checked it, it brought me to some other site selling McDonalds, and then Pizza or something. Also, my email to the "team" has bounced back as undeliverable. Yet, when you Google it, it still comes up with their info on it. Sigh, what can ya do.
Thanks for the info, Christy.
by Eric Dockett 9 years ago
This is long, so here's the bottom line: Basically, my problem is I want to build a site around the same topics and keywords I've done well with here on HP, but I don't want to do anything that would damage the work I've already posted here.I have a couple of niche HubPages accounts that do okay....
by john.maco 12 years ago
I joined Hubpages a few weeks back and I find it useful to share information with users from all over the world.But I do not understand why a user cannot promote his or her hub?What is the issue if I am bringing traffic to my hub from third party sources?You cannot write about this topic, you...
by Lela Cargill 10 years ago
"Writers write - Sites that want to exploit writers need to do the marketing and promotions, as well as PAY the writers for their product."From WillStarr:Bingo!It would benefit both parties if each did what they do best...writers should write, and the internet gurus (at HP) should then...
by AshleyRB 11 years ago
Is it a good idea to back up my hubs?I have heard stories where people were banned from hubpages for no reason? So it is a good idea to keep copies of my old hubs on my computer or do I have nothing to worry about? I haven't break any rules or anything to my knowledge.
by Ann Leung 11 years ago
That is another copying site which has been stealing our hubs from Hubbers at Hubpages. My hub How to Cure Vitiligo Naturally was copied and pasted onto this website: <link snipped> under the name "Zimmer". This bad guy changed the pictures but didn't event bother to...
by Jessica 10 years ago
I found out this morning that this site had stolen at least 2 of my hubs. The more I looked, the more I noticed that it appears every single post on the site is a stolen hub, completely copied in most cases (including the authors' names and copyright notes, ironically). I see lots of names of...
Copyright © 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of The Arena Platform, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|