Usually I find a couple pieces of stolen article copy on different sites. Today, it's more than enough to make me comment here. HP notifies us, adds the complaint link, and the complaint file cut-paste copy but little else to build a brick wall against content thieves. For every click some other site gets with our copy, it's money stolen from writers and Maven. It's time to take this more serviously and for the company to be more involved in, not only protecting itself, but protecting the hands that feed it. Writers can only do so much, it's the publisher with the real clout. Please, HP, help us protect what's ours so we can help you, too.
+1. Especially when entire niche sites are being copied!
There needs to be a better solution from HubPages.
I get what you're saying but picture HP staff trying to chase down every plagiarist and cheater and copyright thief they come across! Impossible job. Just can't be done. Thankfully most of the stolen stuff in my experience ends up on junky sites which means original material isn't affected. If I find copied versions of my work I sometimes end up filing a DMCA. Makes me feel better knowing I've at least tried to do my bit.
This link might help:
https://www.google.com/webmasters/tools … B&rd=1
I understand the frustration. HubPages cannot file a DMCA complaint on your behalf. It's your content so you will have to file the complaint. If the site that copied your content does not respond you can file a DMCA complaint with Google. If the content is indexed it will be removed. Please visit the FAQ for instructions: https://hubpages.com/faq/#copiedhub
Matt, it's good to see you chime in. I have a question: Is there any way on HubPages end that can block or prevent others from stealing?
Unfortunately, there isn't anything we can do to prevent your content from being copied. Do keep in mind that search engines know your article was published first and that the sites that are copying HubPages content are generally not indexed or will eventually be removed from search results.
There isn't really because even if Hubpages disables highlighting and the right click context menu for copying or the hot key, ctrl-c, thieves can still view the HTML source and copy from that. If pages are rendered as images, OCR software can be used to convert images to text.
I agree. It takes ages to file a complaint and most of the time there's no address. I've spent hours chasing website owners to take articles down. One time someone had copied my article about hamsters, and the owner got offended saying her writer would never copy. I had to provide proof I wrote the content first, and it was a very painful process. In the meantime my articles were stolen ten more times and it's too much to keep up with. I'd also love a better solution.
I have more or less accepted that this copying business is inevitable.
There will always be scums who thinks stealing content will make them the next billionaires. There will also always be the clueless who think copying text and stealing images is perfectly fine; we get these here all the time.
As much as I’m reluctant to, I have to agree that such theft seldom adversely affects my traffic.
The whole question of what HP can do is also an endless debate. I’m sure there are ways to restrict copy-pasting on our pages, etc. But how long would these work and would they have any impact on SEO?
It’s also a waste of time to confront web hosts or talk to thieves. Outside of countries that don’t give a hoot about copyright, most hosts are reluctant to antagonize their paying clients. It’s far more efficient to just file a Google/Bing DMCA; it takes but a minute once you’re familiar with the process. Sure, it doesn’t erase anything but the penalty sometimes scare the copycats into removing the page. This is especially so if they have AdSense enabled.
As for HP doing these filings on our behalf, I’m sure it’s possible with some sort of authorization. But with so many of us, how long would it take? I rather HP staff focus on improving the sites and approving articles/submissions. Again, it but takes a minute to do a Google DMCA strike.
That’s what I do.
If they have Adsense ads on their site, I simply file a Google DMCA. It works most of the time.
I agree that it seldom affects traffic except when it comes to Youtube.When the thief steals one of my articles there, and I am able to find it, I find that they may end up having 5 or 6 times as many view as my original. Google ranks stolen articles very low, except when it comes to Youtube, which they own. They will put the stolen article above my own original.
I agree with Yong. I understand the emotions, but pragmatism is the order of the day for me.
1. What are HP supposed to do? They can't police the world? They can make it easier to fill out a DMCA, but they can't force a shady person in Bulgaria to behave differently. They're not going to start hiring lawyers for hubbers.
2. The articles belong to us, this is just a platform. In copyright law, it's the owners' responsibility ultimately.
3. I've been here 11 years and I've not seen a pirated article beat mine in the Google rankings for a long long time, so what do I care. Those stolen articles get very little traffic in most instances.
4.Yes, stealing is morally wrong and generally they're breaking laws, but a degree of pragmatism is surely in order. Maybe one day the internet will become less of a free-for-all but it's always had a chaotic nature so far.
5. Google and other search engines take the stealing thing into account when they put together the rankings. That's how it's fought. It's a far from perfect system but that's how it is.
6. Any changes won't come via HP, a single, private, medium-sized company in California. People also steal articles from blogs and other sites, it's an international internet problem.
People can do what they want, I'm just giving an opinion. In some instances it might be the right thing to chase offenders. But generally, I don't think it's a good use of my time to spend hours/days going after people, so I normally don't.
Hubpages could use an automated DMCA tool like MUSO where all you have to do is enter the url of the content. When I was a more active author I used it, but these days I don't want to cover the cost. It was effective most of the time.
HP make it easy enough to file DMCAs, I think. But what was notable was that it didn't seem to have a big impact on the people getting upset about theft when they introduced the current system.
My impression is that the thing that upsets people most (apart from being generally upset about just the idea of being stolen from) is when the DMCA is ignored. While it happens in a minority of cases, it's a common enough occurrence.
Making DMCA filing even easier might make a difference, but my feeling is that people will continue to be upset.
I almost feel that HP shot themselves in the foot by introducing the copied content warning symbol and the DMCA help, although I understand that they were under tremendous pressure at the time to do so.
The copied content warning prompts people to think that there's a serious problem that has to be fixed, when that's not necessarily the case.
The current DMCA filing help is useful, and I've used it myself, but might lead some people to think that HP has some direct responsibility or involvement with copyright issues.
Copying is endemic on the internet. But it's difficult and sometimes impossible to prevent by traditional means.
I doubt such systems would work for most situations. I’ve encountered web hosts who make it excessively painful to file a DMCA. Some outright state they will only review the request if you use their designated forms. Others demand all sorts of proof of identity, with the statement that they will only respond to actual copyright holders.
It’s like, I’ve ever been asked to send an image of my passport. As if I would give that to some East European host whose address I can’t even find online.
To be fair, I understand the reluctance of web hosts to antagonize paying customers; any removal will result in loud protest. It’s also a sad fact that many trolls file fake DMCAs just for the kick of it.
In comparison, the Google DMCA system is much simpler and I’m also always successful. The downside is that the offending page isn’t removed, of course. But in a world where SEO is the king and the queen, it seems the best compromise.
I have had one whole article stolen by one person, and bits from my article on bougainvillea stolen by several people. When I click on the link to file a DMCA complaint, this is what I get: "Unfortunately, we do not yet have DMCA information stored for showcompassion.org. If you are able to locate a DMCA instructions URL or an email contact for that site please let us know, we will add them to our database. You may be able to find the right contact in the U.S. Copyright Office list of registered agents, or for small or less reputable sites you may find useful contact information in the whois record or by tracking down the hosting company. If all else fails and the site has advertising you can try filing a complaint with the advertiser, for instance Google AdSense."
Why is HP not helping us to be able to file those complaints?
Maria, they give us the verbiage for filing and a link to the offending article. It's up to us to dig deeper and file the actual DMCA.
Go to Whois.com to find out who the host is of the site in question. You'll send your DMCA to that address. If you get no results, file a DMCA with Google.
We can help you find the DMCA information. Please email email@example.com with a link to your article.
I never put anything on the Internet that I'm precious about; the Internet is full of spammers and scammers and they WILL steal every piece of content they can. Nothing can stop them doing that, and it's a futile task trying to track them all down. I had one article copied over 400 times.
Personally, I don't stress about copied content UNLESS it's outranking me in Google. 90% of stolen content is posted on low quality spam sites, which Google eventually deranks, or get taken down.
It's not just Hubpages either; I have quite a few of my own websites, and they also have content stolen regularly. I've had my content copied off Facebook, Twitter, and a dozen other places.
by Ann Carr 6 months ago
Why can't hubpages do something about our articles stolen by the likes of Apceo? It seems they take just about everything but HP does nothing! HP will lose out too because authors will start removing their pieces.
by Sally Gulbrandsen 8 years ago
I have just discovered that someone who is a google member has stolen the content of my Bird Pod Tutorial. I don't know how to contact him to ask him to remove it, could someone assist me please. I don't want to add a link to his work.ThanksSally
by Audrey Selig 11 years ago
There is so much of this going on that it may not be worthwhile to mention. Since I know that this site is not cooperative, I sent my DMCA complaint to Google. My hub is copied word for word with all the lovely photographs and even a link to another similar hub. It probably is my best hub with lots...
by Rupert Taylor 5 years ago
HP tells me my article Guns for Children has been stolen by a website called Brutalist Press. The offending website says it is "copied" by someone called Helga Dagmar. HP offers advice on what to do but most of it is quite beyond my technology skills, and some of the links admin offers go...
by Ann Leung 10 years ago
That is another copying site which has been stealing our hubs from Hubbers at Hubpages. My hub How to Cure Vitiligo Naturally was copied and pasted onto this website: <link snipped> under the name "Zimmer". This bad guy changed the pictures but didn't event bother to...
by Peg Cole 8 years ago
Hooray! For months now I've been trying to figure out who to report the "alleged" infringement on one of my hubs where 9 links to ads have been placed. Whenever I would click the link it would take me to an advertisement that required 3 attempts to leave the page without buying the...
Copyright © 2022 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|