I think HP should put some sore of restriction on posting to the forums to keep people from joining just to post their spam.
New hubbers should have to at least publish One hub of original content before having access to the forums. I'm sure this will not eliminate all the spammers but it may slow them down a bit.
Just look at the posts of "desire500." This person signs up and within 40 minutes has posted the same spam to dozens of threads. This needs to be addressed!
I understand your frustration with the spammers. But sometimes people need help finishing their first hub and post questions. I'd hate to see them penalized because of the spammers.
This has been brought up before.
But as Nellie has pointed out, it causes problems for those who honestly need our help.
I think if HubPages HQ deputised trusted Hubbers (as volunteer moderators) in different timezones to combat the pure spam posts (and leave the flame wars and other ToS infringements to HubPage Staff) then we could see the crap deleted within moments of it hitting the forum.
I agree with that but then maybe brand new memebers should only be allowed to post in the two threads that are set up for them... the Need Help thread and the Knowledge Exchange thread.
Nothing is stopping them from searching the threads and reading all the help that is out there or by reading hubs that have been written on nearly every subject related to HP... They can also start with the FAQ
I'm all for helping legitimate hubbers as I have needed help when I first started here.
Have you seen the forum: What is your pets name? poster Desire5000........ I believe that is the spam you are talking about.
@ darkside thats a great idea, as these sites grow and there are more and more posts, you are going to need more eyes to spot them. Take trusted hubbers and give them the power too pot these spammers!
Personally I dislike the idea of 'trusted' hubbers or moderators outside of the HP staff team as I have seen this abused many times in other forums.
HP staff as moderators will only ban users or posts that could possibly have a detrimental effect on HPs financially or tarnish their image. Trusted hubbers would be those who have been around using the site for a long period of time and who have built up strong alliances, friendships and opinions of their own about how HPs should be run (not necessarily in keeping with HPs TOS).
* You argue with my good friend = you're banned.
* You're opinion differs from mine on this topic = you're banned.
These sort of actions may be a rarity but would still become more commonplace (in my opinion) than with only HP staff moderating, like it or not everybody is biased one way or another.
Did you read my suggestion?
It said that SPAM threads get deleted. And "leave the flame wars and other ToS infringements to HubPage Staff".
You're correct I didn't read it as thoroughly as I should have, was just against the general idea of 'trusted' hubbers, my bad, sorry.
But if you gave these trusted hubbers the power to delete spam, would they not also have the power to delete whatever they chose to? One mans rubbish is another mans treasure.
Perhaps a system where if a post was flagged/reported by say 10 individual Hubbers as spam it would automatically be removed could work.
This could be very dangerous as I could just get 10 friends and have the power to remove any Forum post I didn't like. Similarly, others could do the same and well ... the Forums would end up being a ghost town
They would have the power to do so.
But that's where the trust comes into it.
I'm sure there are numerous Hubbers who could be trusted to delete just the spam. To go outside those bounds would see them banned.
Keep in mind that this isn't about people with such a power moderating regular hubbers who are misbehaving, being overly promotional or being rude. It's about deleting clear cut spam that hits the forum from new registrations that are barely hours old, if not minutes old.
And if not delete it, then be able to move the spam into a hidden sub-forum.
I'm not in favor of "trusted" hubbers regulating other hubbers either. There really isn't much that happens in a forum that can't wait a few hours.
The Hubpages staff is qualified enough to catch and delete these threads. I'm sure they will do something about this latest abuser as well.
Sure the HubPages staff are qualified enough to catch and delete these threads, but you seem to have not grasped just how this site works. The staff (all four of them) only looks at things the community flags, AND the staff does not work on weekends. This has become apparent to the spammers who have begun a pattern of descending on the site starting Friday night.
I think that if they had some of their staff take off a few weekdays and work on weekends instead, or hire some weekend staff just to keep up with the stuff flagged by the community, this would resolve the issue.
I 2nd that e-motion, Relache! I noticed that pattern also and was my 1st thought these past 2 wkends, lol. Our HP team can maybe rotate on wkends to check for flags...wkends are almost a dread now to get hit with spam
The report link is only useful on the weekdays. As Relache stated the HP staffers don't work weekends.
What if you just ignore the spams...
Actually I consider threads started on ridiculous topics just as spammy.
by Lionrhod 5 years ago
There are a lot of us who haven't been feeling safe on the forums. They've felt stalked, harassed and browbeaten.Sadly, some folks go with the letter of the law, but not the spirit of it in their posts.For an excellent post on why we need Forum Moderators, check out what Makingamark says here...
by Kate Swanson 8 years ago
In the past many Hubbers, including myself, have seen the "Report a Problem" or "Need Help" threads as a way to either get a policy explained, or as a way to escalate an urgent problem when emails weren't eliciting a response. It is now obvious that is no longer the case,...
by Richard Bivins 9 years ago
I suggest that HP prevent any registered user from posting a new topic to the forums if they have no hubs. They can comment but not start new threads.Most forums that I use have this restriction in place.
by yoshi97 10 years ago
all the people I see spamming the forums are signing up long enough to post on the forum but aren't writing any hubs. So ... I was thinking. Why not require three hubs from a person before they can post in the forums? They would still be allowed to read to their heart's content, but they would need...
by Beth Eaglescliffe 34 minutes ago
For attn of HP staff.There are regular waves of spam in the forums from people who have little interest (or ability) in writing for HP. They post affiliate links and other rubbish. It is a major disincentive for established Hubbers to get involved in helping genuine newbies.It has been suggested...
by girly_girl09 10 years ago
I have been seeing a lot of forum spam lately. I think it could be *greatly* reduced by only allowing new sign-ups to post under the help section until they've published one hub. After they've published their first hub, then they could post anywhere. I think this would deter a lot of the people who...
Copyright © 2019 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|