Okay, I've taken plenty of philosophy and anthropology classes but I've come to believe that cultural relativism sounds nice but in many cases it is hogwash.
A Liberian family living in the US has now reportedly disowned their 8 year old daughter for bringing shame to her family by having the nerve to be gang raped by four "family friends."
In such an instance, is "cultural relativism" not just jargon to sugar-coat and justify (or at least justify ignoring) brainwashing, rape, and a whole host of other nasty things?
Poor, poor little girl. I just wish I could hug her.
This is like a nightmare. It is ridiculous when this type of sexism can be justified as "cultural".
I don't really understand the term 'cultural relativsm' but I would cut the throats of those four family 'friends' and beat the parents to within an inch of their lives. I also hope that this girl is getting plenty of hugs, and that somehow in time, she'll grow strong enough to put that all behind her and blossom.
Bad luck for girl that she born in such a so called pathetic liberian family. I cannot saw an inch of cultural move in this act.
This is so unbelivably pathetic. Still I am sure all Liberians are not like this. Its just a few sick people in every culture and society.
Of course I don't think that Liberian people are bad per se or any such nonsense (not thinking that was implied, just clarifying ). There was a man speaking on the news about the incident, who had emigrated to the states from Liberia in '93, helping to bridge the culture gap in the discussion of this incident. He had a great perspective, having grown up in that culture but also living here for several years. He mentioned that it was only VERY recently that rape was officially outlawed there. Scary! Children are indoctrinated with crap like this, so boys and girls grow into adults who continue the cycle. You can't really pinpoint one person or reason to blame but I hope that things are changing for the Liberian people.
Got your point. And I hope the man on tv was lieing about rape being outlawed very recently.
I wish he was lying, Ultimate!
http://www.irinnews.org/country.aspx?Co … ionCode=WA
In the "gender issues" section of this article it states that in Dec of '05, rape was officially outlawed by parliament.
What's cultural about abandoning your kid when she needs you? Nothing.
That's a tough question RooBee. While what happened is definitely not something I personally would approve of (providing the description is accurate - see a thread about drinking like a fish ), a lot of Western sex and kids related beliefs and practices look no less barbaric to me and IMO cause no less harm to people and society.
Yes, I am a cultural relativist And moral, too
Thanks everyone, for your comments. Misha, I usually agree and tend to have a way more open mind about pretty much everything than most of the people in my life. This one, however, just made me think about being that little girl - and she probably believes that she did do something wrong!!! I hope you are right, Mr. Voodoo, and she can rise above it. Yeah, cj, it's not a cultural thing but a human thing and there are many groups who have got the people they hold power over believing nonsense that results in much human suffering. (Insert comment about how that sentence could also apply to the US gov't).
by sarovai8 years ago
Country to country human rights laws are changing? or Common things are considered as human rights?
by Grace Marguerite Williams4 years ago
Millions of girls and women in the United States and throughout the world are raped. Oftentimes, the victim does not receive sympathy and is often thought as being somewhat the initiator. Girls and...
by Rafini6 years ago
What is a fundamental question? According to the dictionary, 'fundamental' means basic, or essential. I need to determine the fundamental question involved in an assignment in order to write an argumentative...
by Cindy Vine7 years ago
What would you do if you knew your estranged sister who had always been mean to you, was marrying a rapist?I'm busy doing some research for my next book, having finally completed the final proof edit of The Case of...
by arrowsparrow6 years ago
So, let's say culture A sees a tradition being practiced in culture B that in culture A would be deemed oppressive towards a certain gender group. Is it acceptable for culture A to persuade the government of culture B...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.