Do you edit a hub while it is live or do you unpublish it first? Do the edits go live before an Editor has viewed it? I have thus far edited them live but feel it puts me under pressure if I have to complete it in on sitting. What does the effect of unpublishing it have on the status of the article?
Good questions Sallybea. I’ve done it both ways. I used to always work on active hubs. However, once I was working on major updates, an editor suddenly approved the updated hub even though I was not finished. So I suddenly realized they have no way of knowing if I’m finished. Since then, I decided to unpublish if I know it’s going to take time for me to complete the work.
I still do updates without unpublishing if I know it will only take me an hour or so.
To answer your last question, I don’t know for sure what the effect on the status is, but I would guess that if Google bots happen to catch it while it’s unpublished, they would check again before removing the index in the SERPs.
I never had trouble with that—even when I left a hub unpublished for two days due to massive work I was doing on it. I always do a Google search a week or two after updating and never saw a problem.
As for the status with HubPages, I didn’t see any negative effect whatsoever.
If the article is long say 2,000 words and the mechanical accuracy are many, it would take at most an hour to do the edit throughly. It is best you edit live and done edit same day, instead of unpublishing the article. Unless an article is deleted, no change in date of publication occured.
My solution would be to edit text off line in whatever word processing program you use. Then upload it when done, which would only take 10 minutes. There would be no need to unpublish.
I'm pretty sure you would lose your copywrite date. That might not be important. You would have to make sure there are no copies of your articles though, otherwise you will not be able to republish them.
I do what raggededge said, because it's easier for me personally. I also have several articles that are copied that I cannot seem to get the copied content removed so I need my copywrite date to make sure I can prove I'm the original content creator.
I never lost my copyright date when I unpublished and republished a hub. You would only lose it if you delete the hub and start fresh with her new URL.
That is a good point, I had forgotten about the copyright date, thank you.
Shesabutterfly, even unpublished articles that sit a long time keep their original publication date. This is also true if the copyright date wasn't originally selected by the author. To get a new publication date, the writer has to completely rewrite the article from scratch. I doubt this phenomenon will change with the new Discover HubPages, Computer programming systems have their limits.
I would not unpublish it because if you rely on search engine traffic this would be a bad server response (404 not found).
If I need to make major updates, I just create a new text capsule (or multiple), copy existing content, and edit in a capsule that is "hidden".
The other option for major changes is to do what Bev does.
Every module has this option. When you edit a capsule there is a box that says don't display this capsule.
Thank you lobobrandon, amazing how ones keeps on learning:)
I find the feature very useful, I once had hidden capsules for almost a year while the hub was being edited. I began and forgot about it before I got back to it.
I just checked it out, I had no idea that feature existed. Guess I had no reason before not to display a capsule. Thanks for that.
I have a non-visible "To Do" box at the top of each hub, It's handy for putting notes into and also for leaving messages for editors. They can see hidden capsules.
I hadn't thought about trying to edit with hidden capsules. Thank you for bringing this possibility to my attention.
Once you click "save" on a module, the live version updates, even if you don't click "done editing", which doesn't do anything. It's possible even that any changes are autosaved regularly and update the hub, even if "save" isn't clicked on a module. Normally I just check the "Don't display this capsule:" box in a module and click "save", then go back to editing the module. So it's not visible until I'm finished editing and uncheck the box.
Aah, you answered the question I posed above. I had not realised you could hide a capsule, that is very useful, thank you.
You do need to hit save, there is no autosave option. Each module is a separate entity making calls to the database. That's the reason a module save causes live changes on the hub.
My understanding is that the article stays live while you edit it. When you are done editing, it takes five minutes to update to the new one.
Thanks for the question, sallybea, very informative forum thread.
Good. Thank you we all need a little help sometimes:) Hope you are well janshares? Have not seen you for ages.
I'm doing well, still around after 8 years. Busier since the pandemic but I do check the forums and my account page regularly. Great to see you're still doing well.
by Lisa HW 7 years ago
(Maybe the answers to my questions is somewhere on HP; but even if any answers are out there on the site; so many changes have been made in seven-and-a-half years, I wanted to get the absolute latest with regard the questions below):1. If one unpublishes a Hub and just...
by Marc Hubs 9 years ago
Hubpages have developed a habit of keeping unpublishing my hubs for "linking to prohibited sites" - However, the particular hub in question which keeps repeatedly being unpublished does NOT contain any links whatsoever! It has been submitted, re-approved and then unpublished again...
by parentsreview 10 years ago
Why would you unpublish a hub?I have heard a lot about people unpublishing hubs, but I don't understand why a person would do it. What's the benefit? Thanks.
by Beth100 8 years ago
When you publish a hub, it is normally listed under hub activity and a notification is sent via email to all interested parties. Now, when you unpublish that hub, finish re-editing and then republish it (keeping the original title intact), will it appear in the hub activity? Also, will...
by Kristin Kaldahl 9 years ago
I have a quick question. If I unpublish a hub, does Google "see" that it's still sitting in my account and thus punish me for it, or should I be totally deleting hubs that I decide are not garnering enough traffic? Some of them I'd like to keep around until I get the time to...
by L C David 9 years ago
Question about unpublishing hubsOkay, let’s say you have hub titled: St. Patrick’s Day in New York 2013. You publish it and it gets hits but then fades away. Then as 2014 approaches you decide to publish a new hub called St. Patrick’s Day in New York 2014. If you unpublish the...
Copyright © 2022 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|