My opinion is that it works for me because 1) I have a really high amount of traffic here, 2) I have a referral with a lot of hubs and page views who uses it too and 3) i've also got it running on my own website. So really, i think it works because I've got multiple traffic streams running into it.
As you only have 21 Hubs, I don't think it will wind up earning much of anything for you. I usually recommend to people not to bother with it unless they have more than 100,000 page views per month.
Thank you, relache. I suspect that you have saved me some aggravation.
I do not use it. I've not bothered with it. I'd rather have highlighted links on my pages, going where I want people to go.
Yeah, I’ve been doing that (linking) a lot lately. It really do work!
I'm with ryankett regarding Kontera.
It took my AdSense earnings and stats about a month to recover after shutting Kontera back off. My July AdSense earnings have almost doubled June earnings.
If it was not an instantaneous recovery in earnings then Kontera was not the factor in your Adsense earnings drop, you have to remember there is a near infinity number of factors affecting earnings, but one of the greatest is the time of year, overall weather, and even distribution of birthdays.
If you disabled Kontera and it took a month for earnings to recover then it suggests that some seasonal or market driven effect was affecting your earnings.
If you disabled Kontera and only Adsense remained your visitors would immediately be affected by this change.
To the OP, Kontera earns me anything from 30 cents to five dollars a day. It is not a huge amount but it all goes in to my pot and does not take up any advertising space.
My own tests have revealed next to no change in earnings from Kontera, and though it is not a big earner, it is merely another way of turning potential earnings in to actual earnings from your visitors.
To me the assertion that Kontera is not worthwhile for lower traffic publishers is not true, since even if they earn a low value, it will eventually build up to the payment threshold, in the same way that many people do not reach an adsense payout for several months, or even years.
Thank you very much for your comment oli. I’ve asked ryankett to look at my stats once July is over.
Is it not possible that AdSense ‘downgrades’ ads when Kontera is detected?
My stats are pretty compelling. Everything (page impressions, total clicks, eCPM, etc) was climbing until I enabled Kontera. My earnings dropped by 40+% at 30 days. No one else reported seasonal or other fluctuations in pg impressions, clicks or earnings for May and June. My portfolio is pretty diverse.
Kontera was on for 1/3 of my hubs 15 April-27 May. May and June earnings were both less than April. Jul is double May and June, and 40% more than April.
While it is possible that kontera did affect your earnings during the time that it was implemented, the fact that it took a month to recover suggests that it was a seasonal effect.
Basically if someone visited your site two days after you disabled Kontera they would not know that you had even activated kontera for a test prior to their visit.
While there might be a small discrepency for repeat visitors, the majority of traffic would not be aware that you had recently tested Kontera and had jsut disabled it.
for this reason if Kontera had been the cause of your adsense earnings drop you should have noticed a near immediate reversal to your previous earnings IF kontera had been the cause.
One thing I noticed around may time was those damn Groupon advertisements on Google. Those dropped my click through rate and earnings dramatically.
See the thread
My earnings increased after I removed those compeltely untargetted advertisements to allow for more targetted adverts to be placed there.
Hi Rose Mary, Oli -
This is Jonathan from Kontera. In terms of AdSense ‘downgrading’ Kontera ads, years ago AdSense had actually banned their publishers from using In-Text ads at the same. However, after they had a chance to study the issue, they decided that In-Text wasn't affecting their revenue and lifted the ban.
I really don't think AdSense would penalize publishers under the table because they're Google and if they didn't want publishers using In-Text ads again, they would just ban them again.
Actually, in our experience we've found that many of our over 15,000 Kontera publishers use both Kontera and AdSense on their sites, and because Kontera ads are displayed in a completely different area of a webpage, they're not competing for clicks, and Kontera acts as a completely new revenue stream.
Rose Mary, I'm really sure what was effecting your AdSense revenue but if you e-mail me at email@example.com I'll happily look over your account from our end and see if there's anything I can figure out.
- Jonathan Cohen
Kontera Community Manager
I wouldn't care how much money it made for me. I won't read a page that has that and I would never subject my readers to it. I really, really dislike it.
My experiments with kontera have been pretty disastrous. A ~$.01 per click average and my adsense earnings were cut in half. They did jump back to normal once my hubs normalized after I took them off (when I turned them off plus 24 hours).
I did have a higher click through but the earnings were just depressing. I'm not beyond trying it again, especially if I ever find the time to learn about optimizing for kontera instead of amazon or adsense or whatever.
My value for Kontera clicks is less than adsense, but not by much. Generally it is around $0.30 (Though there are still days when it drops to a cent a click).
I don't see Kontera as competition with Google, rather just another opportunity to catch the readers attention and secure a click.
Maybe it's time I did another test before the xmas season kicks off!
Actually, thinking about it I might disable Kontera for the Christmas period since that is when I make a huge sum from affiliate sales. If I had the choiceright then it might also be an ideal time to replace my adsense advertisements with Amazon and ebay.
I'm not sure December would be a good to experiment with disabling your Kontera ads. Christmas season is actually our peak in terms of when we have the most, highest CPC ad campaigns running on the network at the same time.
While it might be the best time to be in Kontera, I don't think any PPC campaign can compete with a Pay Per Sale advertising technique. Since Christmas is a stime where potential sale percentages increase by a huge amount, it makes sense to increase an advertising campaign which focuses directly on selling products during this time.
I bet you would do real well replacing ads with Amazon and Ebay. Let us know how that works for you.
I don't use Kontera at all, because I find it annoying. I hate when those little windows open and disturb me while I'm reading. I don't want my readers to be disturbed, so I never use it on my hubs.
I totally respect your view in terms of your personal preference, but your readers might not necessarily feel the same way. A recent study by comScore, the leading internet marketing research firm found that Kontera In-Text ads are actually among the "least intrusive" ad types according to users: http://www.kontera.com/advertisers/research-results
- Jonathan Cohen
Kontera Community Manager
I created a method to using Kontera. I use Kontera on all my Hubs now and doing pretty good with it. When I first started to use Adsense I only earned pennies per day and over time started to earn dollars per day.
With Kontera the same thing is now happening to me. At first I only earned pennies but now earning dollars.
Just for the record I decided to only use Kontera on my Hubs and on my blogger blogs I use Infolinks with Adsense.
A few months ago I decided to use Kontera with Adsense on my Hubs and Infolinks with Adsense on my blogs. It's working for me and I do earn more than just pennies.
I tried Kontera for a couple of months on some of my Hubs and another site I run. Unfortunately I only saw poor quality ads. Like for example "net framework" was underlined but it was a link to a search engine for "net framework".
I've now taken it off as there's no point getting 1 cent clicks in premium topics like the ones I write about.
Konter reporting sucks. I mean they don't have total money earned count? Whats the use of quarterly reports?
Kontera Ads are annoying and low paying.
by John Coviello 4 years ago
Twice this week, I checked AdSense, and saw some nice earnings in the 30 to 50 cents range, due to ad clicks (I assume). Both times, these earnings disappeared when I checked back again a few hours later. I understand that earnings are not final until final, but the most recent case was...
by Doctor J 10 years ago
How long does it take to make money with hubpages? After 160 views on 10 hubs they tell me I have 0 clicks. Is something wrong?
by Natalie Frank 3 months ago
I know I asked something similar before but I am a bit confused about Adsense earnings. I don't know how on earth anyone ever gets a payout at least from the way I'm going. My Adsense earnings have always been between 0 - 2cents a day with maybe a few days (and I mean a few over about...
by ryankett 8 years ago
Now that I achieve about 12000 page views per day, I felt it a good idea to give Kontera a whirl to see how I got on. Afterall, I have heard that people can achieve $5+ per 10000 page views.It was a complete failure, although my primary concern was the effect on my AdSense income. I enabled Kontera...
by CapriCookie 2 years ago
First, please forgive me if this has been asked a hundred times already. I've tried searching through the forums, but without a better search feature, it's difficult to find out if someone has already asked about the same problem I'm having. The only thing that came close was "KNOWN ISSUE:...
by chigoiyke 8 years ago
Sometime ago on this forum, people were commenting to a post about kontera and it's new payout limit and in that post some hubbers (many people on that post actually) were saying that they never approve kontera for their hubs as it minimizes their adsense earnings through space or whatever and I...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|