I have no idea it would work, but would it be possible to put a 24 hour forum hold on new accounts? They can read the forums and have full functionality of hubs and such, but they aren't able to post for 24 hours after account creation?
Just get a bunch of Hobbits (or Gandalf) to turn them into stone!
I think I've seen this suggestion before, and the answer is that it would discourage genuine Hubbers from participating as most people would be too impatient to wait for that period of time.
The other suggestion, which I think is much better, is that new Hubbers should only be able to post in the Hub-related threads. They have to have at least one Hub published before they can post in the general topic-related forums.
That way, new Hubbers could still seek help to get started, but trolls would be discouraged because they would have to have one genuine Hub.
So, you'd like to prevent new valid users from getting help and just delay trolls from doing their thing?
I don't see how this is actually going to be helpful or actually prevent forum misuse.
*smiles* You're a few posts too late, I've already been shown the error of my ways.
We've been down that road before and the suggestion was to let them post in "Need Help" and "Extreme Hub Makeover".
It could work. My bet is that HP *like*s these trolls as they generate activity in the forums.
I guess then he'll create bunch of accounts so that they pass 24 or more hours limit and then he'll use it again for the same trolling.
I think the probationary period should be longer-maybe 30 days.
Yes, I know I'd be hurting myself, but it really would cut down, wouldn't it?
50 years. They say some of your best work comes toward the end of your life.
Let's take a minute to consider the word "control." The prefix "con" means "against." The base word "trol" is the Old English spelling for the modern word "troll," meaning a nasty little creature that lives under a bridge and steals goats. Hence, the word "control" literally means "against trolls."
Only you Habee would bring that to attention.
Goes with the English teacher thingie. ("Thingie" here is a very technical and academic term, BTW.)
And here I was thinking that it came for arrogance?
Actually, you have the origin wrong. The word "Cont" (edited for family friendliness) and roll combined means that we should roll the little conts off a cliff...
But seriously: yes, we have asked for this before. HP seems uninterested.
I think the best way to control trolls is to completely ignore them. If they receive no attention whatsoever, and they do like attention, posting becomes worthless and unrewarding to them. They'll move on.
I have no patience for the trolls who join HubPages, then post in the Forum with questions about their failing love life. This recent girl posted in three different Forum places, but I'm glad I haven't seen more from her. Of course she didn't get the answers she wanted. The ones who make the rudest comments don't even have one Hub published. If it's someone who wants advice for romance or a failed relationship, what would her one Hub be about? Her "love" problem! Enough, already! Leave the clown!
A posting hold would be a bit of a cold welcome to the new members who are mostly not trolls. I remember a writer's group I went to where you weren't allowed to talk for your first meeting--I never went back.
If you are serious about writing and putting your work out there, a posting hold would not stop you from waiting it out, then publishing your work. Writers are an odd lot. I dumped my writers' group months ago. Some people can't write their way out of a paper bag, and there are the wannabes who have money to throw around to attend conferences. Of course, that makes them writers. If you are serious about the craft, you'll do whatever it takes to get published or find work. Including writing for HubPages. You can't control these trolls, so instead of extending the attention to their behavior, either flag their work or let it go. That was one long thread devoted to the last Dude. I would not analyze why he behaves this way or why he behaves the way he does. I'm not being paid to be his psychiatrist or his therapist. Flag him and set him free.
I don't know about you, but I am not really serious about writing Hubs--I do it for fun. One of the reasons I stayed and wrote so many was because I enjoyed the forum.
Trolls are like bears, they find a way into places where there is food. If people don't feed them, they go away.
You guys are probably right. It was just a random idea I had. I was thinking about the "lewie vatton" spam monsters too.
I like Marisa's idea, but then again I can see the hub threads pounded by spam and some really low quality "write something quick so I can post" hubs.
*shrugs* I'm still working on the invention that lets you punch people in the face over the internet... when I get that done I promise hub forums will be a much nice place
I know! How about a giant electric fence to keep them out!
Oh wait, this isn't the political forum, is it?
Hubpages is not serious about website abuse (by the way, no one is abusing them right away ).
If they are really serious, then implement these-
1) Make it mandatory for everyone to have published at least 10 'quality' hubs, to participate in these forums. Will hubpages do that? Why will they? Most people come here for fun; they will not disappoint them with a task of 10 hubs.
2) Make it strictly compulsory to have SMS-verification completed, for anyone willing to join these forum. It's just what Google does before you can create a GMAIL account. Implementing this will totally eradicate all abusers. Will hubpages implement this one. To begin with, they perhaps lack funds to make it a reality. .
HubPages will always have.
by Lela 5 years ago
Wow! I got my first threat by a stalker/troll named "Wild Bill". He has a anonymous account that he hides behind. He stated that he won't quit harassing me until I "quit HubPages". Since I can't even figure out who this person is, I can only report his anon account and what he...
by recommend1 10 years ago
This is cut from a Sky news report -"Some call themselves "trolls" and have attacked a site dedicated to a teenager who hanged himself after being bullied over the web."It's organised, they target recent memorial pages and it's mostly the young where they can cause the most...
by Misha 13 years ago
I am not sure it is possible with our forums software, but if possible it would be great I think.I mean we got so many spammers and trolls on forums lately, it's really annoying. Until newbies meet both time registered and number of hubs requirement, let them post in one special forum only, and not...
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|