I just modified the two recipe hubs I had to include the new recipe capsules, hoping they would look like all the other recipes that pop up in results, and maybe I have to wait a little bit of time, but...
It only seems to show your picture in the search results if you have the image right at the top of your hub.
It doesn't show the (star) rating in the search results.
It doesn't show how long it takes to make the recipe in the search results.
But it does show how many calories it is?
I dunno, it's nice that it can show the image, which will probably get it more clicks, but it's really lacking when it comes to showing the information that other recipe results show.
Oh, and the big one...
My recipes don't show up in the recipe results, if you click "Recipes" on the left on Google... to tell it that you're actually looking for a recipe.
So, I'm not sure if it's going to take time to have it indexed in the recipe results as well... and maybe it will take time to show the other information too?
Either way, it looks like it needs some tweaking - that is if you want more than just a picture and the calories in the search results.
I have three recipe hubs up, and the Google search results are not like they are supposed to be. No photos show up in any of the three listings, and I do have the photo near the top, with the rating above it. Now I have seen others like mine, with the rating on top then the big photo, show up in Google searches with the photo. Why mine are not showing up? I have no idea.
As for the ratings, I have two that show the star ratings and one shows nothing. All three hubs are laid out the same way.
Mine also do not show up when you click the "recipe" link on the side of the search page.
I am envious of those whose recipes are showing up with the photos and ratings, however, I can not figure out what may be the problem with mine.
These hubs are days old so they should be showing up properly.
Yeah, perhaps HubPages will modify things a bit and eventually we'll be on par with other recipe sites...
For the one hub of mine that is showing the image, I have the image up top and the rating right below it - both of those capsules are moved to the right and aren't full width.
Just started playing with the recipe capsules and not sure whether any benefits will outweigh the hassles. I wite my recipes before writing the hub, so i already have a list of ingredients, and it's painful [literally, for those of us who have trouble typing] to have to re-enter all that information, since it akes 2-3 separate boxes for each ingredient
also, when retrofitting published recipes, everything gets thrown at tthe bottom of the hub when we add new capsules, then each separate capsule has to be [again, painfully] poked up to its correct position in the hub -- why not have these work like all the other capsules where we can specifiy where to insert them?
Just throwing my tuppenny worth in, I have recipes that require several lists of ingredients for different parts of the dish, yet you can only put one ingredients list in the hub, and one method capsule?
I've had to split those recipes into separate hubs to use the recipe format.
I raised this issue several days ago as well, as the first recipe I was going to publish consisted of the filling and the sauce. I simply did not publish it with the new format.
Would I be right in thinking that adding the 'stars' capsule would optimise the hub for the search engines anyway?
Well I am not sure. My three are not showing up properly as it is, Izzy. Two have the star rating in the searches, one does not, and none of the three show a photo or show in the recipe category when clicked on the left side of the Google search page.
You can manually add new capsules and it will work. You just have to add numbers and bullets. I left a suggestion in another thread requesting they give us the option of adding ingredients and instructions capsules. I uploaded a pie recipe that was two parts: crust and filling.
I bet they'll add this since so many have had this issue.
from the google rich snippets page
http://support.google.com/webmasters/bi … wer=173379
rich snippets are currently only shown for recipes that provide at least two of the following:
•prepTime, cookTime, totalTime, or ingredients
so, rating and photo should be enough
2 other properties that google supports are:
recipeType (tag) The type of dish: for example, appetizer, entree, dessert ...
summary - A short summary describing the dish.
I have ratings, photo and ingredients, so that should certainly be enough as well, cascoly.
in google searches, some of my recipe hubs have the new stuff, most do not - it may be that it takes awhile for the google cache to change - i've got several recipes that have appeared on the first search page, but dp not show the new features yet
I have two with partial features, the rating, and one that does not show anything. None of the three show photos, and none of the three show up when you click the recipe link on the left of the search page. It seems that if Google picked up "part" of the settings, such as the rating on the two, it would also grab the photo at the same time.
It's funny that one of my other hubs, that doesn't even include a recipe, shows up in the recipe results...
All that hub is is a collection of 3 of my favorite recipes for that month, but it doesn't have the recipe info on that page... it links to the recipes on other sites.
Kind of weird... I mean, it doesn't have any of the recipe capsules on it either. Just a little paragraph saying why I made it, a couple tips, a video of me making it and then a link to the actual recipe on a different domain.
Google doesn't know what's up haha.
i have several hubs with no recipe snippets that show up in recipes on google, also
i've add recipe snippets to 24 of my 44 recipe hubs over the last 9 days and have seen ZERO additional traffic. and,, when hubs show up in the google recipes searches, they dont show pictures or ratings. almost all my recipe hubs show up on the first page of aa google search, even without the new stuff
what's been others' experience with these new features? are they getting recognized by google?
the HP recipe ingredients capsule seems to be hurting google search placement
when i do a search for 'honey almond chicken recipe', i'm listed second on googles search results. when i look under google's recipes, i'm farther down, but still on the first page. but if i click on 'includes almonds' which reads the ingredients snippet, i'm dropped from the results! so the HP capsules dont seem to be doing their job - i get better results by NOT using the recipe stuff in searches
just confirmed that google is NOT picking up any of the hubpages new recipe capsules when they are added to pre-existing hubs - NONE of the hubs i've modified show ratings in google searches. but my new recipe hubs DO show the ratings, though not the images in google searches - so something about the HP implementation just isnt working
also, in the rich snippets test page, new & old recipe hubs are displayed ok, but NONE show images, even though i have images placed at the top for all my recipe hubs
How does HP define the name of a recipe when it sets up the rich snippets parameters for google? google requires that 'name' be provided. if HP isnt using exactly the format google requests this may explain why there are so many reports of problems getting ggoogle to recognize hpS RECIPE CAPSULES
Eg, while many of my recipe results show up on the first page of google searches, they dont show up AT ALL under googles recipes searches, even though they have the HP capsules
also, there's no way to indicate the name of the reviewer and yet Google says it needs this for single reviews
I can not speak for Google and what they decide to show or how.
For sure, we have seen inconsistent handling of HubPages recipes in search results as you all have pointed out. For sure, you need at least two capsules as cascoly pointed out. Personally, I almost all of my Hubs are recipes and some show up with photo and ratings, and some do not.
To the best of our knowledge, we have implemented the recipe micro-formats to the specifications of Google. As for the seemingly inconsistent treatment, only Google knows. Rest assured that this is an issue that we monitor and pay attention to daily.
by Simone Haruko Smith 6 years ago
Happy Friday, Hubbers!I am happy to announce that the new Special Layout Options for recipes and reviews that we introduced on our blog earlier this week are now live. Head over to the HubTool and have a look!In addition to making new Hubs using these Special Layout Options, you can update your...
by Melanie Palen 6 years ago
When I did a Google search for one of my hubs, a different hubber's authorship is showing up attached to my hubs.I know this same thing is happening to another hubber as well... the same hubber's authorship (Marcy) is showing up in Google search for the authorship.Here's a pic of the...
by Carolee Samuda 6 years ago
I know it's the recipe that counts but we eat with our eyes. When we see photos of great food we want to create and eat them.I always wonder how people react to recipes without photos as I am seeing quite a number of them. Even a photo of the main or one of the ingredients would be fine. You don't...
by Catherine Giordano 4 years ago
I'm completing my second recipe hub. Why can't we use more than one recipe capsule per hub? I could have used three. One for the pie rust, one for the cranberry-cherry filling, and one for the walnut crunch topping.
by Susana Serer 7 years ago
There have been several theories about what content Google is penalising and rewarding in the search results but at the moment it does seem a bit random (from my end). Let's compare notes and hopefully we can see some common threads in there. What content of yours is holding on to its ranking and...
by Brittany Kennedy 6 years ago
Since I added the new capsules to a couple of my recipe hubs, I have seen their daily traffic double almost immediately! Thanks to the HP staff for working so hard to make this happen. (I think it is because the first image shows up on Google search pages!) What a wonderful...
Copyright © 2019 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|