jump to last post 1-4 of 4 discussions (9 posts)

Does Fair Use Protect Bloggers?

  1. cryptid profile image97
    cryptidposted 5 years ago

    One of my Hubs has been copied word-for-word on somebody's blog.  On the blog they also have a notice saying they know all of their content is under someone else's copyright, but they claim fair use for educational purposes.

    They were kind enough to link back to my Hub, at least. 

    Surely if I protest they will hide behind their flimsy legal stance.  Does fair use really protect them in this case or can I file a complaint?

    1. Uninvited Writer profile image85
      Uninvited Writerposted 5 years agoin reply to this

      They obviously do not understand the concept of fair use. I would definitely challenge it.

      1. WriteAngled profile image84
        WriteAngledposted 5 years agoin reply to this

        Agreed. Fair use covers the reproduction of a small percentage of an original work for the purposes of discussion, exemplification or criticism.

        A legal sounding letter will probably work wonders if you do not want to go to the expense of getting a letter sent from a lawyer, provided you can present it in a way that makes it appear to come from a company or partnership rather than from an individual.

    2. Dale Hyde profile image84
      Dale Hydeposted 5 years agoin reply to this

      Fair Use had been highly contested in various legal jurisdictions. It is a toss up on what is "actual" fair use...there are varying opinions. However, a copy/paste of an article will not fall under any type of fair use clause. The DMCA is the best choice if they refuse to unpublish the material themselves. I contact the owner or poster first, give up to a week, then file away myself. Overall, I have had some fantastic results from filing the DMCAs... Google does not tolerate the copy/paste sites at all. I have had numerous pages pulled from search.

  2. psycheskinner profile image82
    psycheskinnerposted 5 years ago

    They don't understand fair use.  Send the DMCA take down to them and then to their internet host.

    1. relache profile image89
      relacheposted 5 years agoin reply to this


  3. cryptid profile image97
    cryptidposted 5 years ago

    Thanks for the advice everyone.  Does the amount of text used matter in regard to fair use?  They had copied about 80% of my original article (I thought they scraped the whole thing at first but apparently they left out a paragraph or two) but yesterday I went in and added about 300 words of original text.  This is how I found the copy on their website.  This edit makes their copy about 40% of my present version of the Hub.

    I see no way to contact these clowns via email.  I may skip straight to the DMCA.

    1. Dale Hyde profile image84
      Dale Hydeposted 5 years agoin reply to this

      There is no requirement that you contact anyone prior to filing a DMCA. I usually look and attempt to find someone to contact, but if I can't, or I do and they fail to respond, I simply go with the DMCA.

  4. Greekgeek profile image96
    Greekgeekposted 5 years ago

    Skip straight to the DMCA.

    Here's a good primer on the FOUR factors of Fair Use from Stanford. All four factors must be satisfied, in order to qualify as fair use.

    ONE of the four factors is the amount that was taken. They should be excerpting; a complete or large part of the orignal is not fair use.

    Another is the impact it has on the original. In this case, it can knock your hub out of search results, or even get your hub locked as duplicate content, resulting in lost income.

    And "educational purposes" generally means classroom purposes, not uploading it onto the web. If they think it's useful for their students in its entirety, they can bally well link to the original, not copy it.