Do economic theories need empirical support?
Members of the Austrian School of Economics are known for devaluing empirical analysis, favoring an axiomatic approach instead. What is your perspective on this?
I agree with a more axiomatic approach. The whole debate over empirical analysis becomes confused however. I don't think taking an axiomatic approach to economics means that one discounts support for a theory. However, I don't believe that empiricism can, in-and-of-itself, prove or disprove theories. Typically with an empirical approach to anything, one has to asked what exactly is being measured. I'm a counselor, and this is also a debate in the counseling field. Can counseling theories be be proven or disproved by empirical analysis?
The need for empirical support is an interesting one. What does it mean for the empirical data to support a hypothesis? A good theory might not have empirical support if the data does not exist to test it. However, this question brings to mind a related topic.
Robert Lucas (University of Chicago) is famous for something called the Lucas Critique. Essentially, it is naive to try to predict the effects of a change in policy entirely on the basis of relationships observed in historical data.
A good example is the observation that, in American Football, there is too much kicking on 4th down. Thus, we should eliminate 4th down to reduce kicking.
In other words, empirical support needs economic theories.
by suzannegrace 7 years ago
Have you ever asked yourself where you were before? Do you remember or have re-occuring dreams? Have you asked your young child if they remember who they were when they were last here? I did this when my little girl was about 3 years old and in her little girl voice she shared with me her story. It...
by scnettles0629 7 years ago
which therapy approach contrasts with existential therapy?i am doing a paper for school and i need to contrast a theory aganst existential theory
|HubPages Device ID|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Google Analytics|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel|
|Google Hosted Libraries|
|Google AdSense Host API|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels|
|Author Google Analytics|
|Amazon Tracking Pixel|