jump to last post 1-13 of 13 discussions (19 posts)

Did MTV Destroy The Music Industry

  1. thaivalentine profile image58
    thaivalentineposted 6 years ago

    When I was growing up the public's attachment or appreciation for a musician was based what we heard when we pressed "play" on our stereos.  Then MTV came along and it was all about the image.  Suddenly, record companies focused on finding the "face", rather than the "voice".  Recording studios and Sound Engineers can take a wailing cat and make it a Grammy award winner.

    Hardly anyone sings genuinely live today -the days of plugging in a guitar and mic to the amplifier and just performing are gone.  Now record companies have backing tracks, auto-tune, soundboards, etc. to commit fraud when people state they are performing live.  Hearing Taylor Swift and Katy Perry sing live makes my ears bleed.  It's so sad what happened to the music industry.  Concerts were a chance to hear live music, now its a "production" or "performance".

    1. profile image0
      Textured Ideasposted 6 years agoin reply to this

      Good question! I agree but I don't think it's exclusively MTV's fault, there are other factors like instant fame talent shows that changed the music industry for the worst. It's changed so drastically even over the last five or six years.

      Katy Perry, Rihanna and the like also make my ears bleed. I hate the whole pop music scene at the moment. I too miss seeing the bands on TV who would just play the music and had immense stage presence without silly costumes, overdone video effects and different 'personas'. But that's just my opinion smile

      Luckily there is still great music out there and great musicians and singers, but they just aren't as famous or as recognised. And things change every few years anyway so this scene won't last forever - luckily!

    2. Shinkicker profile image97
      Shinkickerposted 6 years agoin reply to this

      I think video destroys music in general. For me about 99% of music videos are worthless. A disastrous art form that detracts from the music, which should be enjoyed by the ears not the eyes. But I wouldn't blame MTV especially. The pursuit of profit of whatever description kills real music.

    3. Obscure_Treasures profile image53
      Obscure_Treasuresposted 6 years agoin reply to this

      In a way, yes, But its not the only reason music is destroyed.
      The main reason music is destroyed is because everyone now depends on technology to make their music and voices sound "good", which is a load of crap. Artists these days dont have true talent, and their only in it for the money. Back in the day, artists didnt let money stand in their way, they always delivered 110%, and actually cared about their music and their fans. Nowadays artists just make songs, depend on their way too sexual videos and music to attract people, make a buck and call it a day. God I miss the old days...

      Back in the day, music not only had quantitiy, but it also came with quality. Nowadays, it's neither and it makes me sick.

      1. .josh. profile image61
        .josh.posted 6 years agoin reply to this

        Does this really apply to all music?

        Sure, the stuff you hear on MTV is absolutely guilty of what you're saying, but there are plenty of artists who sound just as good -- if not better -- live.

        This idea that music is destroyed is rubbish, people just need to stop relying on MTV to tell them what they should be listening to.

  2. Jonathan Janco profile image67
    Jonathan Jancoposted 6 years ago

    I don't think it was mtv that destroyed the music industry, but they sure tried damn hard. I think its the record companies themselves. When file sharing started the labels panicked and started suing everyone. After they cooled, they decided to concentrate all too heavily on pop music acts that get supported by extranneous merchandise. After all, you cant download a Britney Spears doll, right?

    1. optimus grimlock profile image61
      optimus grimlockposted 6 years ago

      no but i do think they shot it a few times smile

    2. Uninvited Writer profile image83
      Uninvited Writerposted 6 years ago

      There are still "real" performers out there. Have you head Adele? She is great.

    3. rebekahELLE profile image87
      rebekahELLEposted 6 years ago

      I don't think the music industry is destroyed, it's only changed.

      There is still great music being written and performed. As far as live performances, well, yes, that's been an issue for a long time, especially considering the tour schedules most performers keep. With the technology constantly advancing, music production can make anyone sound amazing. As long as the music sounds good, people are going to follow the performer.

      Some of these performers would never survive without the producers. But I think most people who follow music recognize true talent. It is what it is.

    4. Stacie L profile image87
      Stacie Lposted 6 years ago

      the music "Industry" destroyed it. the corporation mentality to make a buck over the pure enjoyment and artistic freedom of the performer was destroyed.
      There are millions of undiscovered real musicians who don't have women gyrating on the stage and lip syncing to sexy lyrics.
      The moguls want to  turn young girls into street hookers.
      I'm not happy with video music.arg!

    5. knolyourself profile image62
      knolyourselfposted 6 years ago

      Have to agree. The corporate hamburger stands opens everyday on time and gets the product to the consumer consistently, but their philosophy of life is nothing more than that and that only, and thus they kill spontaneity wherever it can be found.

    6. profile image0
      AlienWednesdayposted 6 years ago

      I don't think MTV killed it. I think they gave a voice to the music that was not there. Then corporations came in and frankly society. Society as a whole, wants what they want, and they want it now. People have learned or adapted to not appreciating a good voice. They have learned, to take what they can get now. Instant gratification is what to me has really killed the music industry.

    7. Mikeydoes profile image76
      Mikeydoesposted 6 years ago

      They changed it and made music videos famous. Lack of great music is due to Lil Wayne throwing out 50 songs a year. How long did it take Led Zeppelin to throw a song together?

      If Lil Wayne took those 50 songs and condensed them in to a 10-12 song album.. Who knows it might actually be really good.

      Just using Lil Wayne as an example, throw most people in that same spot and it will sound similar.

      1. Cagsil profile image59
        Cagsilposted 6 years ago

        Did MTV Destroy The Music Industry? Nope.

        The dumbing down of America has destroyed the Music Industry and corporate(and individual) greed(misunderstood) helped.

        1. Freegoldman profile image35
          Freegoldmanposted 6 years agoin reply to this

          I dnt think so becz it reinvented by intrducing a lot of rock culture.

          1. Cagsil profile image59
            Cagsilposted 6 years agoin reply to this

            Question- Are you older than me? If not, then I would say that you haven't lived long enough to notice when the "dumbing down" of America began or just not wise enough to understand.

            If you are older than me, then you're just blind to what has happened in America. lol

      2. ahorseback profile image61
        ahorsebackposted 6 years ago

        Excellent Question , the music industry has geared itself to selling to those who actually buy the most, teenagers or those with a teenage appreciation for music. Countries Taylor Swift , is the prime example of this, she has no voice , I won't even get into where mo -town went! Its All about consumerism again.

      3. .josh. profile image61
        .josh.posted 6 years ago

        I do agree that mainstream music has gone downhill thanks to the likes of MTV (though they didn't do it on their own), but I completely disagree that the music industry is 'destroyed.' Not even close.

        I think you need to broaden your horizons and seek out some music away from the mainstream - you might be pleasantly surprised. I know we're not allowed to link to our hubs, but it is a topic I like to discuss, and if you let me know your tastes, I'd be happy to offer some suggestions on here.

        Music is nowhere near dead, valentine, though it's certainly possible that a lot of ears are. Absolutely mind-boggling that a band like the Black Eyed Peas can actually win AWARDS for their music.

      4. cooldad profile image59
        cooldadposted 6 years ago

        Good question.  I think MTV did what most corporations do; follow the money.  The music industry has changed so much since MTV began.  It's now about casting certain images to fill a band.  The days of Nirvana, Pearl Jam, RATM, Soundgarden, Radiohead are just about over.  Everything is about marketing, not about soul or music.  But that's the world now.  MTV is just another corporation who will do whatever it takes to make money.  Like putting pregnant teenagers on television.