Do you think children learn Grammar naturally?
Children are unable to differentiate between "me have" and "i have" at an early age. They learn to speak by imitating sounds but do they learn grammar naturally or is correcting them a successful method of teaching?
Children like to be right, they should always be corrected, they learn the grammar of their parents by constantly listening and being corrected, and fine tuning their own understanding of how to communicate and get what they want.
I think children do learn the basics of grammar naturally, but correcting them would probably prove to be a successful method of teaching.
I do not believe that grammer is natural. They can learn the basics from people around them but if a child is on their own, not paying attention to those around them, they will never learn grammer.
Kids learn basic grammar on their own, but the finer points do usually need to be taught. A child who reads widely will generally have better grammar than one who doesn't, because he or she has good models to imitate. Children who learn primarily through watching TV may not have as good a grasp of grammar, because as a society our spoken grammar tends to be much more casual (and "incorrect") than formal written grammar.
I correct my children about 90% of the time when they make a verbal mistake and 100% of the time when they make a written mistake, but I tell them very clearly that being corrected is not punishment, and making a mistake does not mean they are dumb. I want them to learn, not to feel bad about not being perfect.
They learn the basics but need to be taught some of the finer points.
@ Mary - True, they do need some guidance along the way but i find that children seem to pick up the basics naturally.
@ Brainy Bunny - I agree that children learn basic grammar on their own and I strongly agree with them learning from TV and radio! My nephew is a prime example of that scenario. If he hears it, he will repeat it. Correcting is part of the learning.
@ Iburmaster - I would have to say i do find children do learn basic grammar on their own as they learn to speak properly. They must be actively involved in conversation with those who will give proper correction when necessary and if possible, in a fun way that the child might remember.
@ Ironman1992 - Agreed!
@ MickS - I would say you are spot on except that you cannot correct the child EVERY time! I would drive both of you mad with a talkative 2 year old i would think!
Thank you all for commenting
Grammar is not a natural anamalistic instinct, and therefore has to taught in a rigid form.
by the pink umbrella2 years ago
"one should always aim at being interesting rather than exact" -VOLTAIREYes, i know that checking your spelling and grammer make for a better hub score, but is anyone else sick of other hubbers who you arent...
by FreezeFrame345 years ago
How have you corrected another person's child in a public place?I tend to interject in situations in public places when other parents are not watching their kids. I look like the bad guy, but I want my child to learn...
by Virginia Kearney2 years ago
I just emailed a comment to HubPages staff but thought I'd also ask the forum group. I have a lot of errors in the comments posted on my Hubs because I write Hubs read by students and by people who are not native...
by Sondra Rochelle4 days ago
Just checked and it appears things are getting back to normal with Adsense earnings. Happy to see this but am wondering why the down time happened.
by Anahi Pari-di-Monriva6 years ago
What is Hub-etiquette for correcting grammar/spelling in published Hubs?What is the Hub-etiquette for helping fellow Hubbers who have great content but are weak in grammar and/or spelling in their published Hubs? I have...
by ravenlt045 years ago
How do you find a balance when it comes to correcting your children vs. their self expression?Some days when my patience is running low I feel like all I'm doing is fussing. "Stop smacking." "Again, sit...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.