jump to last post 1-7 of 7 discussions (7 posts)

can a manic depressive physically harm anyone?

  1. profile image48
    xkez1xposted 7 years ago

    can a manic depressive physically harm anyone?

    harm as in hurt another person close to them

  2. Tatjana-Mihaela profile image60
    Tatjana-Mihaelaposted 7 years ago

    Well, some manic depressive people  can physically harm the others, even the closest ones, but only certain percentage of them have such tendencies.
    The truth is also that many people who donĀ“t have any diagnosis can harm the members of their family, or the others, if they are aggressive, so we cannot generalize and look/judge people through the diagnosis.

    One person with the manic depression cannot be compared to the other, so majority of people with this diagnosis are bullying only themselves.

  3. internett1t3 profile image57
    internett1t3posted 7 years ago

    Unfortunately, yes. Manic Depression is now called Bi-Polar IIllness; this mental health condition is very serious and must be well-treated by a psychiatrist. As long as the patient is receiving appropriate medication he/she can live a normal life, and be a danger to no one.

  4. Wesman Todd Shaw profile image97
    Wesman Todd Shawposted 7 years ago

    Most adults, and a huge percentage of children of any mental state of being may physically harm anyone.

    Why don't you ask a question more reasonable, like either, "can armed, angry cops with an agenda do whatever they want to you?"

    Or how about this one, " can solders go around killing anyone they want overseas?"

  5. profile image0
    jasper420posted 7 years ago

    The illness itslef cant but it can cause one to harm themsleves or others

  6. christalluna1124 profile image73
    christalluna1124posted 7 years ago

    It is can harm the person with the illness unless they are diagnosed and put into treatment. My personal treatment includes both therapy and medication. before treatment I had 5 suicide attempts and numerous hospital interventions. Since my treatment I have 15 years without any attempts or hospitalizations. Also keep in mind that a person can become violent, hurting others or themselves. Right now i live a pretty stable and good life and have had no other problems. I stick to my med regime and am basically a high functioning person. I do still have periods of  severe depression especially during the winter months.
    Warmest regards,

  7. The Mad Aunt profile image55
    The Mad Auntposted 6 years ago

    Any person can physically harm someone, especially when they feel tired, irritable and frightened.  The mind can get overstretched when coping strategies break down.  It's up to the family and friends of a person who is at breaking point to act with sensitivity and calm.
    Do you know someone who has been labelled 'manic depressive'?  If so, I can see that you might be concerned. But most of what the media puts out about 'manic depression' or any other 'mental' challenge, is sensationalist and should be ignored. Get in touch with Sane, they will be able to reassure you.