jump to last post 1-7 of 7 discussions (15 posts)

Why were women given the right to vote?

  1. mintinfo profile image75
    mintinfoposted 4 years ago

    Why were women given the right to vote?

    Why did men find it necessary to exclude women from politics in the first place? Was it social or religious ideology?

    https://usercontent1.hubstatic.com/7759818_f260.jpg

  2. phillippeengel profile image79
    phillippeengelposted 4 years ago

    At the end of the day, people realize that in order to have a just, compassionate, righteous and fair society, the government must be responsible, rational and committed to put power, wealth and opportunity in the hands of many, rather than the elite. A diverse, plural political system that accommodates the various views of different interest groups will be a good starting point for peace, political stability and economic prosperity for the country.

  3. My Esoteric profile image92
    My Esotericposted 4 years ago

    Yes.  Keep in mind a woman's social position throughout most of recorded history has been just above that of a slave; whether one in anchient Greece, where most slaves were more or less cuacasion, to the late 1800s in America.  In many cases, it was religeous, remember you gave us poor, unsuspecting men a bite of the Apple.  In monotheism, women are punished for instigating the fall of man, men are punished because we are, well pick one, 1) stupid, 2) wooses, 3) .... whipped, or some combination of the three.

    In places like Greece in the 500 B.C.E.s, well, you were simply ovens and maids.  There were very few societies, or men in any society, between then and the 1900s where women, as a group, were given their due.

    At the time the 55 white, wealthy men got together in Philadelphia in 1787, it was hard to tell the difference between societal views on women then and 2000 years earlier.  What changed, of course, a new way of viewing society, Liberalism, and its enstanciation in our Constitution.  After that, it only took 150 more years for 1/2 the world's population "to be granted" (not that women didn't fight very hard for that benevolence) not quite equal status with men.

    Also, besides not thinking women were intelligent enough to vote, we were probably scared to death what might become of us once you did.

    1. mintinfo profile image75
      mintinfoposted 4 years agoin reply to this

      My intention of asking the question was to try and understand the grand stalwart of exclsion, the Catholic church. It seems that either god is a discriminator or men simply do not understand his gospel.

    2. My Esoteric profile image92
      My Esotericposted 4 years agoin reply to this

      While the Catholic church is certainly guilty of such sins, it is quite liberal today when compared to many Protestant faiths.  Regardless, the church is only one of the sources of such discrimination.

  4. xstatic profile image61
    xstaticposted 4 years ago

    Women were considered  chattels practically. It was thought that they did not have the mental make-up that men were given to make the careful decisions  reqiured of an electorate. They eventurally got the vote, because as citizens of this nation, they were entitled to it. (Short answer to a complex process).

  5. SidKemp profile image95
    SidKempposted 4 years ago

    You are really asking two questions. First, why were women excluded from the political process in the first place. Second, why did women eventually get the right to vote (thousands of years after the first known voting happened).

    Your phrase "Why did men find it necessary . . ." conveys a few assumptions which, I think, are anachronistic. That is, they don't take into account the fact that, in different historical times and cultures, people thought differently.

    Several people mention a general tendency to stop treating women (or other sub-groups, such as racial sub-groups) as property, or as less than human, or as less than men. But it's complicated. For example, women were more equal in Jewish society than in Greek society, and had more rights. But voting never happened in Jewish society. When the Israelite people had a nation of their own, it was a monarchy.

    So we have to look at each culture in history separately & address three issues: Did voting happen at all? What was the status of women? What was the perceived role of women?

    Voting existed in ancient Athens. Only owners of property (land, real estate) could vote & only men could own property. So you might say that the problem started there. From then on, voting was a very spotty phenomenon. Rome was a republic for a brief period. Most of the time, most of the world has been monarchies, despotism, or war and anarchy, where voting wasn't happening at all.

    Politics and power have always been hierarchical. Only the few at the top had a vote. A big change was started in the Magna Carta in England in 1215, which began to address the rights of the people. Lord Denning described it as "the greatest constitutional document of all times - the foundation of the freedom of the individual against the arbitrary authority of the despot. It planted the idea that all men or all people ought to have equal rights and equal protections under the law.

    But there is a root problem in the English language. Does "all men" mean all people (men and women) or all men (males only)? So when the Declaration of Independence says "all men are created equal," are women included? The language brought forth ideas that were ahead of their time.

    Over decades, the broadest ideas are slowing growing forward. All men are equal, no matter the color of their skin. Women are equal to men. Children also have rights. Non-citizens and felons have rights. Slowly, through the activitsm of the oppressed and their allies, we move forward.

    1. mintinfo profile image75
      mintinfoposted 4 years agoin reply to this

      My intention is to highlight the state of insanity that supported and in some cases still support the ideology of the ruling class. It is by no means limited to race as all cultures are patriarchal. If the pursuit of man is civility why hold on to th

    2. SidKemp profile image95
      SidKempposted 4 years agoin reply to this

      "If the pursuit of man is civility." . . . "man, or humanity." And I see civility - even civilization - as a mere stage in human development. Civilization brings war and tyranny. I hope we people outgrow it soon, and move on to better things.

    3. My Esoteric profile image92
      My Esotericposted 4 years agoin reply to this

      Men have been civil, Man will never be because it is not in our nature to be entirely so.  Just look how hard one side of our political spectrum is pushing to take us back to a society based on the social and economic standards of the 1800s.

    4. SidKemp profile image95
      SidKempposted 4 years agoin reply to this

      I think we agree overall, but I use a different language. I hear MintInfo and My Esoteric using the language of society, rights, and politics. I use the language of the collective unconscious and the evolution of consciousness.

    5. mintinfo profile image75
      mintinfoposted 4 years agoin reply to this

      I use a language that pple with a spacific ideology might undrstnd bcause  they think that they r at the pinnacle of human dvlopment. I will bear witness that there is a religuous institution in every community but it's only so through indoctrination

  6. cebutouristspot profile image74
    cebutouristspotposted 4 years ago

    Back then society made it that way. Ancient Greeks, who invented democracy, did not allow women to vote and only free male citizens are allowed to vote.

    1. mintinfo profile image75
      mintinfoposted 4 years agoin reply to this

      Back then? Women in the US were given the right to vote in general elections in 1920. Hardly ancient times.

  7. kikibruce profile image87
    kikibruceposted 4 years ago

    Because the state of Wyoming was trying attract women to the state and by giving them the right to vote, it happened.

 
working