Is a Robin Hood tax viable?
I've heard a lot about the Robin Hood tax, which is a less than 1% tax on financial transactions. It is meant to raise revenue and to discourage unnecessarily risky trading.
However, I've also had my attention drawn to the failed financial transaction tax in Sweden which makes me wonder if it is viable.
Would it need to be international in character to work?
Funny that it would even be called a Robin Hood Tax since Robin Hood was an anti government rebel. Seems like the last thing he would like to do is funnel another income stream to govt bureaucrats. And no it is not a good idea. It would be a great disincentive to capital formation. The cost would effect negatively pension funds, 401k's via mutual fund transactions and other forms of retirement savings. And at the same time accomplish nothing but reducing capital investment. Investors already pay 1% or more for professional money management and financial planning services. The last thing they need to do is pay another 1% of their retirement savings to a bunch of incompetent politicians.
I can't imagine it working. If it would penalize small investors, then it would damage the flow of financial trade. If it would penalize large investors (tax the rich, and hope government gives it to the poor), then the rich would never let the law come into being, or, if it did, find ways to circumvent it.
Face it: The rich want to keep their money, and they're smart enough and powerful enough to find a way to make that happen. That's how they got rich, and how they stay rich.
Any taxation or regulation designed to change that is like a concrete sidewalk trying to stop grass from growing. Living things - and people - always find or make cracks and find ways to keep doing what they want to do.
by Ken R. Abell7 years ago
Are you looking forward to the new Ridley Scott movie Robin Hood?
by Evan G Rogers7 years ago
Man, I just watched the new Robin Hood movie and left a bit confused.First, the movie. It was IMHO a pretty decent movie; better than Iron Man 2. I'd say it was a cut below Bravehart, but good nonetheless.I was confused...
by sunforged7 years ago
One of my techniques for finding new keyword strings and niches involves noticing obvious SPAM when I travel through the internet.This started by getting annoyed with all the Akismet notifications in the my email...
by Credence22 years ago
From an article taken from Salon Magazine, focus on the 8 minute video from the Senate chambers as Senator Warren spars with the Bankster President of Primerica Bank, during a committee hearing. On Tuesday, Senate...
by Tony Lawrence6 years ago
Something like this has been proposed in the U.S., but choosing this name in Britain was brilliant.I particularly like the first video..http://robinhoodtax.org/I wish we were half so good at selling this idea here!
by ashley_deza8 years ago
this movie is set in Robin Hood timesthere is a father who tells his King that his daughter can spin straw into gold. So the king puts her in a cell and gives her a pile of straw and tells her to spin it, but she...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.