Carson Supporters, does today's revelation -- Dr. Ben Carson lied about West Point, matter to you?
A CNN report accused Dr. Ben Carson of lying about key details about his life in his autobiography, “Gifted Hands: The Ben Carson Story.” His campaign admitted to Politico’s Kyle Cheney that he lied about another key detail in his autobiography — his application and acceptance to West Point.
In “Gifted Hands,” Carson claimed that when he was 17 years old, he met with General William Westmoreland, and was offered a “full scholarship” to the military academy. There’s no record of such an offer, or of Carson having applied, and there’s no such thing as a “full scholarship” to West Point.
ABSOLUTELY NOT a Carson Supporter here, but whether true or not, it's no BIG revelation to myself and others who follow politics ~ I've always understood the fact that the "Good Doctor" appears to be prone to "Delusional Tendencies", which is actually more of a CONCERN than his apparent Lies ~
Perhaps we are wise to watch. If the "tendencies" seem to continue to manifest, then there is a real disqualification.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts Alternative. I try to keep up with what's happening and I have noticed Carson makes some odd statements for sure.
Not at all, Rubio and/or Cruz will be the main front runner. The fact that you have to get the Hispanic vote for any chance for the republicans to win the presidency it absolutely why they will not put Trump or Carson in the ballot. When you have Bernie Sanders basically picking up all the Black votes with his socialist agenda and Carson seeming more like an, I don't want to sound racist but I don't now another way, Uncle Tom to the black voters then No it doesn't matter. Jeb had his chance, the powers to be are pushing for Rubio, that's it. What I want to know is who are the powers to be. I would like to see transparency in presidential campaign fund raising. That will never happen though because Dems and GOP is all against that. Good read Congress: the Electoral Connection.
If Carson did in fact fabricate this claim or any other for that matter, it would matter to me if I had been leaning toward supporting him. However, this is not the case. I would hope that any and ALL fabrications or lies spoken by candidates would be of concern to the voters as they determine who they ultimately want in the White House.
We can easily assure ourselves that Politician =Liar = Politician, but to be faced with blatant and/or proven untruths at this stage of the game, should not be brushed aside. If it matters enough to someone, I would suggest they investigate thoroughly.
Myself? I am quite focused on 2 particular candidates. While I try to keep up with as much as possible "in general," suffice it to say I have put much effort into these 2 candidates. By this I mean I am listening to their every word, checking up on their records/history (politically) and basically feel I'm doing due diligence ( my homework, as they say?)
At this point and time of America's numerous woes & apparent insurmountable ISSUES, Au fait, between you and me, I've had to struggle to maintain my pride & patriotism against such high frustration. I do not want to succumb to giving up entirely on my privilege & responsibility to vote. I also need to know I'm making an educated decision. Apparently we have more than enough individuals in the great USA, who go to the voting booths to play "eenie, meenie, mynie moe!"
Paula, thank you for sharing your thoughts on this important issue. Dr. Carson was on TV defending himself las' night & of course his supporters were doing same. So many strange things coming out about this man that it's hard to know what to beli
I saw some of that. It's the closest to angry/hyper he's displayed ever. How can we possibly know who or what to believe? There are specific people who should remain within the realm of their forte. For Dr. Ben this would be the pediatric OR.
Paula, I agree. Carson should stick to what he knows. He doesn't seem to know beans about politics. I guess he didn't pay attention before to the way the media digs everything up on pres. candidates, cuz he's whining about it as if surprised.
LOL! I know, au fait. I saw his rant & whine. I used to laugh at my late husband for "talking" to the TV.....but there I was saying aloud, "SERIOUSLY Dude? Looks like U spent way too much time in the O.R.! U didn't KNOW this about our media?"..
Best to check the so-called news story. Carson is clear that he never applied. Spokespersons point out that the Politico story is an outright lie, but that's not news. Perhaps the worst that can be said is that Carson's original wording was not the best choice, even though it was most certainly understandable in context, which is not lying.
Thank you for taking time to respond to this issue RTalloni. I think there may be enough misunderstanding to go around. Even so, Carson has made a lot of strange statements that make people wonder where he's coming from.
His response to media was admirable, as are his responses to many other issues, but concern re him on the TPP (treaty) reflects an ignorance of what it actually is, the ruthless partners it will subject American workers to, and its entire substance.
There are a couple of "tells" in this account. First, nobody gets a scholarship to West Point. You get a nomination after you go through an intense application process that is more involved than filling out a standard college application. And a nomination has to be granted by an elected official, i.e., a congressman, a senator, or the president - not an Army officer, even a general. No one pays to go the West Point, in fact, cadets receive a salary (1/2 a second lieutenant's pay) plus all almost all expenses are paid.
There may be explanations for these discrepancies. Other candidates have had to explain some of their circumstances. The fact that he did not go to West Point might be enough of an explanation for making misstatements about his experience.
I wouldn't support Carson for a variety of other reasons, but this incident would not be a deciding factor by itself.
Dude's a Froot Loop. He thinks the Great Pyramids were grain silos too.
Yes, the lies matter to me. Mr. Carson said that he did not say that, but it is my understanding that it is written in his book. Did he write the book or is it ghost written. If the latter is the cast, did he read his own book. If he did not write his book then that is two lies, if he had a ghost writer, that means he lied to the ghost.
Any way you scare it up, Ben Carson lied.
I am not supporting anyone right now. But when I read the question, I thought about the Obama citizenship, and school grades issues that went on forever.
Citizenship matters because it is a requirement for the presidency.
But, school stuff shouldn't be important. Experience is the better education, because it is real and not academic.
The Pathetic Charade about President Obama's Citizenship was just that, a CHARADE ~ In the REAL World here on Planet EARTH, there was NEVER any question as to where he was born ~
Citizenship of all presidential candidates should be vetted in the same manner as the government vets to people that want top secret clearance. It is a valid question, and Obama was the one that prolonged it. But that is not the point of this ?
Obama's place of birth was only ever in question to racist lunatics who live in an alternate reality.
Cruz was actually born in Canada & McCain was born overseas too. Only nationalistic nativists see conspiracy in any one of these.
One more time, the citizenship of the presidential candidates is always valid, and I don't think the government vets out these candidates sufficiently. Period.
by ga anderson 3 years ago
I was not a Ben Carson cheerleader. I liked what I saw, but things were just starting.Now, I think his recent revelations about his violent actions when he was a kid have doomed him. Not necessarily because of the actions he discussed, (at least for me), but because it appears obvious that it is...
by Susie Lehto 2 years ago
IT WAS OBAMA who on ABC News referenced - "My Muslim faith."IT WAS OBAMA who gave $100 million in U.S. taxpayer funds to re-build foreign mosques.IT WAS OBAMA who wrote that in the event of a conflict -"I will stand with the Muslims."IT WAS OBAMA who assured the Egyptian Foreign...
by Alternative Prime 2 years ago
Can you imagine Doctor Carson up against demonstrably assertive Putin? Or other intimidating dictators? I sure can’t ~ He’s a timid, introverted, and very strange medical man who exhibits bizarre habits and traits ~ He’s definitely NOT the guy to follow a Strong, Confident, Assertive,...
by Kenna McHugh 13 days ago
"We've been conditioned to think that only politicians can solve our problems. But at some point, maybe we will wake up and recognize that it was politicians who created the problems."-- Ben CarsonPhoto: Gage Skidmore
by ga anderson 3 years ago
The Spinmeisters are tumbling over each other trying to get to the front of the mob. The PC crowd is aghast and enthusiastically pushing on the Spinmeisters backs as they surge for the microphones. And for the opposing politicians... oh my, a red meat dinner.Republican Presidential candidate Ben...
by IslandBites 2 years ago
Newsmax: On your support, I know you explained why you're supporting him, but it was a 180 degree turnaround, for the most part. I mean, he said some nasty things about you. How do you reconcile that?"Ben Carson: Ah... Politics. You know, the politics of personal destruction. You know, that's...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|