Do you think restricting gun purchases of people on the No-fly list is a good idea as proposed?
In his speech last night from the Oval office, President Obama called for Congress to pass a law restricting gun purchases by people who appears on the No-fly list? Do you think that is a good idea and Constitutional?
Honestly, it's really a moot question. The Congress is controlled by Republicans...the only things they will control are women's bodies, and people's access to vote. Guns and Viagra are safe with them. So no...nothing at all will be done about guns with Republicans in charge....except maybe forcing us all to own one.
You might have miss understood my question. Is the idea a good one and is it Constitutional? Please reply based on those two points. I have an opinion but was curious on how others think on this topic.
Yes it's a good idea, and the constitution died with Patriot Act. Too late to revive it. People just pretend it matters when it affects them. Privacy is gone. Really, what else matters?
Lovemychris, I hope you are being satirical. The Constitution is still important in many ways. This current President have abused his power and shredding it for his political advantage. For most of us, the law and the Constitution still matters.
Riiiiiiiiight. He invaded country, tortured, and shredded constitution. That was Bush. Can't pick and choose demons!
You might not agree with Bush's policies but he did not abuse his power. He got Congress to vote and supported the war in Iraq. Unlike the current President who has issued executive actions to change our immigration laws...
OK, now you see, we are in TOTALLY different universes. This is why we do need to split the country....you will never take responsibility for what went on prior to, and other than Obama. It's no use even discussing, there is NO common ground. Unreal!
How do you see that happen? Are you pushing for another civil war? I think there are common grounds and common sense solutions. We need to understand who is behind the curtain causing divisiveness. Don't fall for their ploy.
According to you, it's Obama.THAT'S the ploy!
My point in the question is explore whether this law if passed will be Constitutional and secondly if it will be effective.
And I have answered....after Patriot Act, constitution means nothing! You guys only throw it around to keep your guns. You could care less about women's rights under the constitution. It's a farce!
I'm not sure that being on the no-fly list is an adequate reason to restrict someone's constitutional rights. If there is evidence of wrong-doing, charges should be filed and due process should be followed. Jumping right to a punishment without charges, a trial, and a chance to defend oneself should be something that we all guard against.
I think the same is true of the no-fly list itself. Anyone on the list should be able to find out why they're listed and have some legal means to contest it. Without that, they're being secretly accused, assumed guilty, and punished without recourse. That's not what "the land of the free" is supposed to be about.
That is problematic. The no-fly list is mysterious and by many accounts easy to get on by the flimsiest of evidence. I had a professor on it, of architecture, not even politics, or some other field that might be contentious. He wouldn't have stepped on a bug.
Even if it weren't problematic, it is a bandaid solution that ignores the real problems: poverty, inequality, racism, drugs, crime, the overabundance of guns, the ridiculous Second Amendment, the even more ridiculous gun mythologies that so many Americans worship, the ease of acquiring guns, etc.
Is it Constitutional? maybe. We don't now allow complete and unfettered access to firearms, which has passed constitutional tests, so it is possible, but I'm certainly not qualified to answer that. My suspicion is that the courts would have a hard time with it, because of the complete lack of transparency of getting on the list and the inability to do anything about it. Fundamentally that violate due process.
If people want gun control then they should actually enact gun control.
I don't think you understand the 2nd Amendment. If you did, you would't think it is rediculous. It has kept our country from a military coup as happened in many other nations. I do agree with you on the due process of no-fly lists.
The government can take anything of yours that they want via a dude in an air conditioned office pushing a button. Your gun is a paperweight.
What country are you living in? Have you heard about the Bill of Rights?
by Don W4 years ago
I get the feeling the nightmare scenario for Republicans would be that Obamacare turns out to be a raging success, and goes down as one of the most courageous, enlightened pieces of legislation in the country's...
by Longhunter6 years ago
"I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will faithfully execute the office of President of the United States, and will to the best of my ability, preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United...
by Jack Lee6 months ago
It has been almost a year since he left office. Though he seems to stick around DC and make his comments occasionally about policies...The question I have for all is this - what is your opinion of this President in his...
by Joanna Chandler3 years ago
Do you seriously have ISSUES with Obama's Presidency or does it go beyond ? His Skin ?.......maybhave seen questions that aims fiery targets at Obama. My thing is we all know he is not a saint the man got faults and...
by Stacie L2 years ago
According to a Mic analysis of political spending data collected by the Center for Responsive Politics, the NRA, —often cited as the most influential lobbying organization in the country — has spent a total of...
by Susan Reid6 years ago
Every day we hear from hubbers about how Obama is out to destroy the Constitution. Across this great nation there is a movement of very vocal, very serious "pro-contitutionalists."The Constitution is suddenly...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.