Just heard on the BBC that the prime minister has retained his seat.
English politics are interesting to me. I was pleased to know he is is still there. With a bigger majority according to the speech he gave. Mr. Brown, you are superman to pull this off!
I've always liked watching their parliament debate on topics, they actually have a sense of humor during it.
Political pundits are already saying that Brown will only last a few days before being forced to step down, and that the British public never liked him much. What do you think?
I don't know enough about English politics to predict anything, but according to the Economist he was picked based on the concept of cutting taxes and not cutting social programs. Then, the economy went in the toilet, and that isn't going to happen. Looks like the captain will go down with the ship.
BTW, I also love the whole Prime Minister being booed by the other party while participating in direct debate in the House of Lords. Can you imagine how this country would be different if the President had to actually stand in front of the Senate and debate?
He may not be gone yet, the Conservatives still haven't got enough seats for an overall majority. So unless it improves very quickly, if Gordon can strike a deal with the Liberal Democrats, he could stay for a while longer. Over here, if there is a hung parliament, it is the sitting government that gets the chance to strike a deal first even if the opposition has won the most seats. And to make it even more interesting, some seats are going to be challenged because people were turned away from the polling stations and not allowed to vote. The polling stations have to close at 10pm, and there were queues outside still waiting to vote, so they couldn't. The police were called in to some places because people got so angry. Not very british behaviour!!!
lol, you are probably right! I am too tired to think! I just heard one polling station just herded everyone outside inside the building before ten so they could all vote. Don't know why they all didn't do that. Probably some legal reason I don't know about.
You are both right I believe. The legal reason they allowed the vote was in having had the voting form before 10 pm they could be locked in. I don't know why the others did not do the same, maybe no space?
and I think the British conduct their elections with more dignity than we do in my country.Some restraint is shown, and it does impress.
I think it is fairly traditional that PMs retain their seat, normally they will have directed a great deal of money to their own area, same here in Ireland......however, I think the Tories will win the day and do a deal with Clegg or the devil or who ever gets them in to No 10
Its possible - but I think the country needs change - remember the jubilation in 97 - that bubble soon burst - I think nothing worse than someone just hannnggging on and on
I just woke up and came to HP first, before any news. Funny how HP keeps me up to date on current events!
As for who actually wins this one, does it really matter? They are all conservatives. People don't like to hear the painful truths so they all lie. Now if someone from the monster raving loony party had been in line for PM.....
The leaders of all three parties in the UK have very safe seats, and it would be unprecedented for one of them to be voted out.
In Northern Ireland - the three leaders of the Unionist Parties have failed to gain a seat - The DUP however will have 8 MPs, The non-sectarian Alliance will have 1 seat, Sinn Fein (abstentionist) will have 4 possibly 5 seats, Indepenedent 1 and the SDLP (nationalist) the rest......... DUP could be important to Tories depending on how hung the parliment is.....
Looks like there is going to be a hung parliament which hasn't happened since 1974.
Meanwhile, the pound is sinking like a stone against both the dollar and the euro....
So far, the Tories are the largest party but not by enough of a majority - they need 326 seats and have 291 (at the moment)with 34 seats still to be returned.
Labour has 247 at the moment,and Clegg of the Lib Dems said pre-election he will not form a coalition with Brown in charge.
I have just spoken to a friend in Northern Ireland who says the Democratic Unionist Party could give Cameron the majority he needs to form a Government.......however....they would also need others as the DUP have only 8 MPs thus far
I actually hope the Tories win this time. I can't stand their policies usually, but usually when the government gets changed during a bad market, the market picks up.
As an expat, I need the pound to get stronger. All the money I have just now comes from the UK - same as many of my pensioner neighbours who have seen a huge drop in their standard of living since the £ collapsed against the euro.
Tories at the final count could do business with the DUP.....although that would not be a strong Government
Question from across the pond -
What's the diff betw a "strong" and "weak" govt?
How do election results effect the UK economy?
How long does it take to sort things out and form a new leadership?
Thanks in advance. (It's been awhile since I've been in school).
Hello Will I'd like to have a stab at some of your questions;
1) The difference between a "Strong" and "Weak" government. British political parties have far more party discipline than is found in the USA. So members will vote the party line. If there are not enough members to form an overall majority the government has to rely on support from other parties and so cannot be certain that it's policies will be put in place. Therefore it is "Weak". If it had a secure majority it could gaurantee support and so be "Strong"
2) Economy; The market tends to react to the policies of government. What will they do for industry and are their plans likely to succeed? etc. A weak parliament cannot gaurantee stable policies and until one is formed domestic and foreign investors as well as the leaders of industry will be unsure how to proceed.
3) Leadership; Constitutionally the Prime Minister does not HAVE to resign. The party with the most votes chooses it's leader, the losing Prime Minister resigning is a convention, not a law. Of course it would not be feasible to be Prime Minister if your opposition can block every move, so government changes hands. In the meantime, if there is no clear majority, the sitting Prime Minister can seek avenues of support. Theoretically it can go on forever. Practically it is done quickly or there would be no real government.
Two things to bear in mind about UK politics; a) there is far more party discipline in the UK than here. Parliamentary members are expected to vote the party line.
b) The UK is far more polarized than the USA. I am from South Wales wher the Conservatives are jubilant at having won 3 seats in an area wher they generally come in third. Whereas in the South east of England the Labour party regularly comes in third place.
There's more of course but this would change from a post to a Hub if I carry on
Just put the news on, it's a hung parliment with conservatives on a slight majority. Looks like dave and nick will be working together, not sure for how long though, we dont have the best track record for shared power in this country.
Thanks iantoPF -
I learned a lot from your post. It sounds like nothing is easy in your system either.
Best of luck w/your new govt...whoever is running it.
Update - The figures kept on changing through the night. No one won the election but with regards to the Constitution, Brown will have to stay as Prime Minister for now.
It is yet to be decided who the Prime Minister will be.
We are still waiting...
With his wonderful sense of entitlement, Gordon Brown has more or less chained himself to the railings at Downing St. It will take nothing short of dynamite to shift him! Only 29% of the vote and he still thinks that he should be PM. But then what do you expect from a man who called an ordinary British woman, who has many of the same concerns as most of the British electorate, a bigot!
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/elect … given.html
I believe Brown will bow out if the others can form a strong allegiance.
Otherwise he will hang on biting ankles even as he hit's the floor.
He could still win
I believe that he will hang on if he can, but he won't have won. The British electorate decisively rejected him and the Tories got 2 million more votes than Labour.
The credit ratings agencies and markets are just waiting to see which way the wind blows, and if they perceive any weakness in the government that is formed it is sayonara for the British economy.
Brown has never been liked by the electorate has he? Do you think he has weight with his finance credentials?
I am wondering what the markets are looking for. If it is stability alone, England may be in for a rough ride.
Brown was never voted in as Prime Minister. He took over from Tony Blair who resigned the leadership mid-term. A good quizz question is - who was the last PM who never won an election?
The UK is in for a very rough ride - everyone agrees that there needs to be cuts in public spending, but not if it affects them! This will lead to strikes and protests, which will further damage the economy. Unfortunately, we will all have to learn to take some of the burn, or the country will go bankrupt.
Brown has no financial credibility - all he knows how to do is spend money he hasn't got and raid our pension schemes.
HE resigned as the Labour Party didn't win majority fo the seats!
I wonder how long before these two start eating each other alive.
The outcome was always going to be weird, but these guys as bed partners will be a riot!
Well well well...what an interesting change. A Lib-Tory Pact? Has there ever been one before? Cameron as PM. How do the markets react?
Sorry I've just learned about this - my mum phoned me a few hours ago saying that Brown was about to resign but hadn't done so at that point. I'd read online he was about to resign, but what I read suggested that a Lib-Lab pact was on the cards, the Libs having made it clear they did not want to work with Gordon Brown so any pact would be on the premise that he left office.
I thought Brown did the right thing. If labour was to have a chance of getting a Government together he had to go.
I can't see this current arrangement working myself.
I wish now I'd watched the election closer. I know the big stumbling block was that the Lib Dems wanted PR, and none of the main parties did. Is that going to happen now?
Btw, Scotland's 'parliament' has PR.
Very interesting times to come. England does not have a lot of time to start dealing with the economy, and I can't imagine these two doing so quickly.
The Scottish Parliament is about as useful as a plastic teapot, the real power lies at Westminster (or does it lie with the Bilderbergers?), so this election was all about the whole of the British Isles, but yes I take your point, the economy is the most important thing right now.
Firstly,I think this election was different because of the way the media covered it.
We had our first time ever three way TV debate between the party leaders. However I do not think that the standard - party political broadcast slots really addressed any of the issues that people on the doorstep, were asking the people who wanted their vote.
- To me there was a big disconnect between - what the media thought we needed to know and the questions people were asking in their own homes.
However - who ever took up residence in number 10 they knew they had a huge challenge in front of them in getting to grips with the countries budget.
Mr Cameron - had said he would address this straight away when he was asking people to vote for him.
Now we have the Liberals and Conservatives working together.
We have to have hope that they will put the future of the country before any differences between the parties. If we can go forward with the best of both - policies rather than having arguments then some good will come from the election result.
I have to say that if you saw the former PM on TV last night he acted with dignity and I hope he will enjoy the freedom/time he now has to be with his family more of the time.
I have to go now - busy day.
I am not really a political person - I wrote this as I saw Izzy's post.
I have to say that I never rated Gordon Brown as a PM, but he has always seemed to be a devoted husband and father.
I hope that he finds a niche where he can be happy working, get over this 'I am entitled to run this country' thing he has going on, and build a happy, secure life for his family
I agree CMHypno. I didn't wish Brown to continue as PM, but he seems like a decent guy overall, and I hope he can enjoy family life whilst pursuing some less stressful career.
As to the Con-Lib Dem alliance, I can see some very real potential here. It's easy to predict a disaster, but hopefully we'll look back in a year or two and see that it's actually been a success.
Gordon Brown....Good riddance.
i live a labour stronghold which as been such as long as i can remember.
Its not suprising since 30 years ago we had massive employment in mining and steel(traditional labour)only now Mr Brown et al replaced all the private employment with a massive public employment strategy.Turkey's tend not to vote for christmas.
This countries people have become fat and bloated and spoiled by a socialist theology that lost its way.
People have forgot about personal responsibility and expect to be looked after by the state.
Wake up UK.
by chigoiyke 13 years ago
....soonest it will be; why did they kick out the British PM - what's his name again? Gordon Brown. I have been following the British election with some amount of attention but I still don't get why a serving PM is about get kicked out through the votes (atleast with all indices, polls and...
by Credence2 3 years ago
I saw an article's recently about protesters bringing down the statue to Francis Scott Key in San Francisco.They said that he was a slave holder and a slavery advocate, but let's face it, everybody who was anybody during the late 18th and first half of the 19th centuries owned slaves.If this is the...
by Grace Marguerite Williams 2 weeks ago
Name the 10 main issues in American culture & society. How are such issues problematic & will cause eventual disrepair in American culture & society? How can these issues be solved, even eliminated? Your thoughts please?
by Ralph Schwartz 3 years ago
The government’s bill implementing the withdrawal deal has passed through both Houses of Parliament, meaning the UK will finally be leaving the EU on January 31st, 2020. For the duration of the debate, both sides have made bold predictions about the success of failure of the split. What...
by greencha 10 years ago
Any body seen Gordon Brown our ex Prime Minister?Anybody seen or heard whereabouts our ex-Prime Minister Gordon Brown..has he done a runner ?, he has not been seen in Parliament since he was Prime Minister. Yet he is still supposed to be an MP Perhaps he gone to live on an island in the...
by ga anderson 4 years ago
British comedy or real life?I am a huge fan of the series. It started as Yes Minister and graduated to Yes Prime Minister.Give it a look. Real politics through the prism of comedy.Warning: It is a rabbit hole - you may be drawn into hours of youtube viewing. ps. Be warned, the Cabinet Secretary...
Copyright © 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of The Arena Platform, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|