Is there a way to curb unscrupulous behavior in adults?
Legislation just doesn't do the trick, and (in my opinion) it's wrong to lock someone up for doing something immoral (that doesn't hurt anyone, at least.) It seems the only other option is education, but even then it's hit or miss.
I don't think so, unless you give them an incentive such as money to correct such behavior. By talking to the alone won;t quite work effectively, and especially those who are under the influence of some illegal drug or narcotic.
In my lifetime we've taught Americans not to litter, to wear seatbelts, to eat less red meat, not to hit their wives and children (at least in public). That last one is probably as close as we've come to changing moral behavior. Unxcrupulous implies theft, scams, con artists. I don't think we've made a dent.
There's a hubris about modern social philosophy that assumes people can be taught to behave better ("better" is as always primarily convention defined by whomever has authority at the moment, but never mind that), but hubris is all is. The reality is you can't change human nature. All that can be done with those lacking a good moral compass is to provide them with consequences when their conduct becomes too much to overlook.
You could shoot them but that is a little much. Cheaper than locking them up. Human nature is not going to change with legislation or education. There is a reason that prostitution is the oldest profession. It is the demand for the service.
According to the Bhagavad Gita, with Krishna speaking to Arjuna regarding the concepts of Atman and Brahman "I am all a man may desire without transgressing the law of his nature."
Everything that we do, depending on where we are in our lives, stems from "desire", more specifically unfulfilled desire for something...tangible or intangible.
I used to get really angry when confronted with lies and greed ...not so much "immorality" as you have implied..and until I have accepted them as part of my nature too..as a human being..
Morality is defined by society..for good reasons..it gives the appearance of order..but one's morality is defined by the individual alone..and in this, he has "free will " only to the extent he has worked on himself...
This has to come from within..for no one can really "teach" another or for that matter, force another to learn.
To want to learn, to go through the discipline required to learn something, that too is a choice but within a limited context.He has to go beyond norms and mores of the society he was brought up in. He has to go beyond religion, beyond the definitions of good and evil.
Choice is a privilege of the free, and in a free being there is no desire to impose his own values on another. He has no "desire", although he can create that desire, at will.
I guess it would like training an animal - like the dog whisperer - a short, sharp jab on the Mastoid process ....
Education and asking nicely can both be surprisingly effective. Shunning and ostracism have their adherents for dealing recalcitrants.
Failing that, if the 'unscrupulous' is also illegal, slapping them in jail is highly effective, though usually temporary. (So I suppose that I disagree somewhat with the statement that "Legislation just doesn't do the trick.")
If they are brought up properly then they already know the difference between right and wrong, how they should and should not behave etc. That's the job half done!!!
Yes, legislation rarely does any tricks, unless it is played on us. BUT, your question seems a bit nebulous...what exactly are you asking here? If a criminal only steals a few thousand dollars without harming another, is that justified? Or by "hurt" do you mean either/or financial, physical, emotional or psychological?
Both unscrupulous and Immoral can be interpreted so many ways. They are relatives without concrete base until defined.
Your question has heart...let's see if we can go somewhere with it.
Sort of draws up a question. What immoral behavior hurts noone? Also the word immoral is loaded with possible interpretations. To attempt an answer: It is only possible for some and it is either self management or fear.
I think the education part is difficult. People's personalities don't change, it develops then stops. I think that these people would have to be treated as if they were being raised all over again.
Nature you can't always change but Nurture you can. If there were counseling of such a kind; with "parents" that were attentive. And could recognize early warning signs; that could be taken care of sooner, it could help. Problem is, these people are not a clean slate like a child. During their development something went wrong.
Sometimes I think there is no answer and that we live in a world that is similar to a movie about good against bad. It is something, we, as a people, have to find better solutions too because it won't go away. As if life can not have good without bad. As long as we keep trying to find better ways to curb unscrupulous behavior, it can be something that can be achieved. I think as much as we want change we are still afraid of it in many aspects.
When everyone learn their religion well from the childhood then the unscrupulous behavior in adults will curb especially in Islam...! Learn it how islam curb this..!
Lobotomy? well I suppose that wouldn't be legal but not sure their is, they grew into what they are, they will change only if they really want to.
by LAURENS WRIGHT 5 years ago
Is there a right or wrong without religion ?Killing, stealing, cheating or dishonest acts are throughout the world. Without truth and justice, is there a right and wrong without a religion or supreme justice for a basis of thought? What has happened to the mentality of the people who...
by SocraticMethod 6 years ago
Many thinkers argue that psychology is not a science, in that the methodology and the reasoning used does not lead to nor provide a generalizable theory of human nature or behaviors. Yet, without a sound theory of human nature, there is still a widely held view that there is such a thing as mental...
by Kate McBride 4 years ago
Is human nature basically good or not?It is clear to me that there are good folk in the world but is it true as well that some people are just plain bad or else they are just indulging in bad behavior that has become a habit for them. Most of the time, this is an abuse of power but even some people...
by threekeys 12 months ago
What are the best parts of human nature? What are the worst parts of himan nature?
by Matthew P Holbert 4 years ago
As above so below.From this perspective, the world is a heaven or a hell depending on how you look at it, and more importantly the steps you take to change things. One of the first and best places to change is the Federal Reserve. Search The creature from Jekyll Island and Secrets of the Federal...
by Grace Marguerite Williams 5 years ago
Why are religious people so concerned about the atheist? Really, being an atheist is clearly NONE of their business. Why do so many religious people contend that the atheist is going down the wrong path. There are a myriad of beliefs in this world. None are superior to the...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|