If I did not choose to exist how can I have a free will?
How is there such a thing as free will if I did not choose to come into existence? I did not choose my parents, birth time, location of birth, my physical appearance etc. Even all the choices that I think I make are all based on available resources and information at a given time.
Even religion appears predestined, based on time, place and circumstance. So could someone please explain what it means to have a free will.
Free will just means being able to say "yes" or "no" during the day.
Whenever an opportunity comes up for you to do anything you have the power to choose. Having said that: Life is a (personal) journey.
Not everyone is going to be presenting with the same opportunities!
I suppose the ultimate free will is to choose whether or not to take our lives. Most of us (choose) to see what the new day will bring.
Its the ability to choose your own path in life.
What confuses me though is how you retain that ability if one is required to follow the tenets dictated by their god. Its not really freely choosing at that point since the alternative to following them it is eternal damnation.
There's also the fact that if everything happens for a reason and god knows all...whaterever path that is being chosen was already predetermined, voiding free will.
Lots of conflictions that most of faith don't bother with considering it requires them to use reason.
Just because God knows what you're going to do doesn't make predetermined for you. He just knows which "choices" you're going to make.
As the Christians love to point out you have the choice to follow God or go to hell. It's still a choice!
If God already knows what I will do, God is the all-powerful creator, God would have created the situation and already know the results of everything. to do. This looks more like the illusion of free will.
Have you observed someone driving in the lane next to you going really fast and you can see they'll hit the car ahead of them at that pace. You (know) they're going cut into your lane & they do. As the observer/God did you alter their free will?
Hi Dashing Scorpio,
Thanks for the response. No I cannot alter anyone's will. I have am not all powerful, "all knowing" and "all present". My thoughts are All means All. If God is All-powerful, then the game is over. What God wants to happen will.
Darrell, According to religious teachings God only gets involved if we (ask) him to. Otherwise he's more like an "observer" as described in the car analogy. I've been told we have to ask God for his help or guidance! Some people pray everyday.
by DeanMcDonnell 7 years ago
Does free will exist?In the Christian story of Adam and Eve, they were put into the garden of Eden and instructed NOT to eat from the apple.. Surely, if God knows all, he/she would have for-saw this happening right? Why put the tree in the garden? or better still, why draw attention to it?
by Comrade Joe 6 years ago
If the bible is the word of God, and God is all powerful why did he choose such a bonkers way to produce it? It seems odd that an all powerful entity would choose to possess the minds of multiple men, over multiple generations. These men would record their visions or accounts, some...
by amine sehibi 3 years ago
can anyone, show me the evidence that enables the modern science to disprove the existence of God.Of course if the modern science is able to disprove his existences .
by twingwiri 8 years ago
As a fellow human being,i want to ask if we could exist without a belief of something o one greater than ourselves.I believe if there was no God we'd have to invent Him.
by Troy Wilkerson 7 years ago
Why is it that the creator of heaven and earth would allow himself and those who believe in him to be ridiculed and persecuted. Why he would not only let them exsist but allow them to thrive while here on earth. I asked my Son and he said "free will." That's true but I feel it goes deeper...
by Henry Wordsworth 3 years ago
Does free will exist?
|HubPages Device ID|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Google Analytics|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel|
|Google Hosted Libraries|
|Google AdSense Host API|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels|
|Author Google Analytics|
|Amazon Tracking Pixel|