I am interested in people's response to the following question;
If you have ever encountered someone who held any kind of supernatural belief, be it religious or any other, who justified their belief by citing some kind of 'personal experience', or if you yourself hold any such beliefs which you justify by citing personal experience, is it fair to say that their/your justification is circular because you are using the vividness of an experience to valid the experience itself as "true".
Clarification: I am not talking about people who fallaciously credit their experience to a specific agency, eg. I felt a presence, therefore that presence was god. I'm more talking about people who would say for example they saw an angel, or they heard god talking to them, or something like that.
With out a doubt in my mind. comes in dream state prepairing me for calamaties in my life. Advanced warnings of every family menbers death that has occured. Advanced warnings as to mistakes that I was about to make in life. Did some of them any way. "You are not the boss of me" mentality has played havock in my life. I knew beter but I did it any way.
Any one out there know what I'm talking about???
Remove the question mark from your question and you have my answer
What's circular about seeing an angel or talking to some God ?
I think what the OP means is that if someone experiences an event that makes them believe in the event because of how the event seemed, that would make it circular logic.
Although after reading the question again I'm not sure that's circular...
Well I'm wondering if you would consider it circular if someone used the following justification:
A - I believe in X because I had a personal experience of X
B - How do you know you really experienced X
A - Because X verified itself to me during the experience
A - Because it just really really really seemed like X
I understand better now I wouldn't call that circular logic. I'd say that they haven't used proper reasoning to believe in the incident perhaps, but I wouldn't call the logic circular. It's like someone kicking you in the nuts. You go up to someone and say OW I was kicked in the nuts, that hurts! And they say 'How do you know it hurts' and you say 'Because it felt painful!'
It's similar(ish) to that Although seeing can be fooled much more than a physical contact
No I didn't understand.. can ya tell me about X again??
I didn't explain it to you in the first place. Maybe you should try the person who posted the thread. I was just laughing at something someone else said.
Ok, the whole point of X was to say that by experiencing something you cannot verify the thing you experienced as true BECAUSE you experienced it right? Now, what I said, in a slightly strange roundabout way was that you can know something happens from an experience, but the problem comes when the senses are fooled into making a mistake. By this reasoning, the logic isn't circular, but can be unfounded.
Is that better?
Horribly low quality though
I was just messin with ya . Ya don't have to be a 8th grade graduate to understand that circular means that it goes in circles. If ya caint catch it this time around just wait righ there and it will "circle" back around and we can catch it on to ta next go round; maybe??
In the end, all any of us have is our own experience of this crazy ride. If you outsource the quality of your truth to the experience of authorities, then it's on your own head. What we know now about "reality" will seem like monkeys to those in the 30th century. Like someone once said, our wildest fictions are probably closer to the truth than our most "objective" truths. But I paraphrase. But the point is, reality is stranger than you can imagine, and your only experience of whatever there IS is through your own lens. Not your "sources."
That's absolutely true.
There's a mistake in placing emphasis on a single personal experience that contradicts the rest of what you know, but if a burning angel keeps appears to you and telling you stuff, that is a good reason to believe in it.
I mean, you're could be insane, but if you can't trust your own senses what are you gonna do about it?
We have to rely on experience to verify that we actually exist.
by atomswifey 9 years ago
My personal experiences came at many times and intervals of my life. When I first accepted Christ, I was young and didn't quite understand as I really didn't "feel" any different. What I mean by that is, I saw people all around me really feeling the presence of the Lord in them, through...
by Elizabeth 5 years ago
This Forum is primarily for a discussion between myself and Chris Neal (and anyone else who wants to join) about the nature of his personal experiences with what he claims to be god - and how those experiences relate to proof. For a critical (not criticizing) examination, discussion and...
by marinealways24 8 years ago
Is your belief based on faith, logic, or both?Can a person be logical if they have an illogical belief or faith?
by richtan 6 years ago
what is a succubus? based on the info from my relationship with one over a year. they are neither angel or demon. nor human. but a little bit of both.they are neither good nor evil. but are like us; have both natures. they are found in every mythology. and in every religion. either as peris,...
by hubby7 9 years ago
It is said that "All knowledge comes from experience". If that is true, can it be argued that we can only know those things that we experiece? If so, can it be argued that our experience limit what we can know? If so, since we don't share all our experiences in common, it follows--does...
by Jason Menayan 10 years ago
Hi all,Just a short note that hopefully doesn't run afoul of AdSense's rules on telling your earnings.I will say that it took 8-9 months to get my first check from AdSense. My next check should be ready in about a week, and it's only taken 3 months this time.I've tried with various types of Hub...
|HubPages Device ID|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Google Analytics|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel|
|Google Hosted Libraries|
|Google AdSense Host API|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels|
|Author Google Analytics|
|Amazon Tracking Pixel|