Eli or Peyton?

  1. samtenabray profile image59
    samtenabrayposted 6 years ago

    Eli or Peyton?

  2. Less Of A Caveman profile image61
    Less Of A Cavemanposted 6 years ago

    If you are talking one season (and assuming Peyton is healthy) it still has to be older brother. If you are building a franchise around one right now for next 5-10 years, it has to be Eli. If it is one game for my life, I dont even consider Peyton.

  3. cprice75 profile image91
    cprice75posted 6 years ago

    Eli.  He is much younger than Peyton, and he doesn't have a bad neck that cost him a season.  He's also coming off a very good year.  Peyton did not take a snap.  He's been in the NFL since 1998, so he's long in the tooth for a pro football player (although he didn't take many hits for many of those years).  He's got a better body of work, although Eli could bypass him in SB wins this year.