jump to last post 1-6 of 6 discussions (6 posts)

How Can You Tell If A Judge Is Racist?

  1. Menjia_Rose profile image61
    Menjia_Roseposted 6 years ago

    How Can You Tell If A Judge Is Racist?

    You can't tell if an individual is racist just by looking at them...So How Would You Know For Sure If An Individual Is Racist?

  2. profile image0
    Gusserposted 6 years ago

    Throwing the word racist around is getting old. Why does it bother you?

  3. duffsmom profile image60
    duffsmomposted 6 years ago

    What concerns you about a judge being racist.  Are you considering making that charge in order to get a new judge.  Be careful - it might backfire.

    A lot of research would have to be done.  You would have to research all of his past cases and decisions and see if they seem racial motivated.  A long shot.

  4. Catzgendron profile image74
    Catzgendronposted 6 years ago

    If you think a judge may be racist contact a lawyer and see if you can review cases the judge in question has overseen, if there a patten?  has he given harsher sentences to one ethnic groups vs another?

  5. T. R. Brown profile image77
    T. R. Brownposted 6 years ago

    Short of a racist statement you probably can't tell if someone is racist (judge or not).  Mitigating factors of each of his or her past cases would make proof very difficult unless there that particular judge's ruling were well outside standard deviations  as compared to the rulings of all local judges in the area for similar cases.  This data would be extraordinarily difficult to compile, and most attorneys who would potentially argue in front of the judge would never want to make that charge.

    That said, it is highly likely that the judge is not racists.  To be clear, his or her experience may bias their decision making to some degree, but if you stand before the court, you should be able to easily move things in your favor.  Dress well, speak well, be respectful, and be restrained in your speech and demeanor, and you will be fine.

  6. Bills Place profile image84
    Bills Placeposted 6 years ago

    I agree with Catz, this would take a bunch of research of past cases and seeing if a pattern shows up. You might be able to notice a certain ethnic group gets a harsher sentence than another. However, that alone would not be enough to prove racism unless you either have several where the crime is very similar but the sentencing is so far apart from each other it's obvious.

    Example would be several records from different ethnic groups where they failed to show up for court or non-payment, is the judge giving them all the same sentence or are certain ethnic groups being sentenced to the fullest extinct while others are always on the lower end?

    Simply, unless you have hard evidence it's usually very hard if not impossible to target anyone in a city counsel position and that's how come there are so many crooked ones out there. Then those ones give the rest a bad reputation because it makes people wonder who's good and who's a crook...