There has been a resolution (in progress) regarding my hub article on 'How to Run a Breakfast Program for the Needy." Turns out there were no intentional copyright violations, thievery, or "spun" text from another site on my part. The blog moderator for the neighborhood civic association (whom I know personally) posted the entire article instead of the link. He has now taken it down. According to an hp staffer, that will suffice so that when mine is republished, it will be original.
Many lessons were learned here for me:
1. It is very easy, as a new writer, to unknowingly fall into the internet phenomenon of "duplicate content." Even if I didn't commit the violation this time, I now know how to avoid it in the future.
2. I will never write about a fact-based topic (like a charity or organization) ever again. I've learned that it's too risky and can create the appearance of "spinning" if the organization appears on the web. If I do, it will be a subjective narrative regarding my thoughts about and experience with that organization.
3. When I email my friends and associates the links to my articles, I will cleary state, "post the link only."
4. When I need help, I won't hesitate to ask hubbers. They will promptly respond with specific solutions to what they perceive as the problem, based on what is presented to them. Hubber support is invaluable.
Thanks everybody for you help.
Thanks for sharing Jan. Useful information.
Just to clarify, your Hub was not moderated for a copyright violation, nor for spinning, but for being duplicate content.
And as far as:
"2. I will never write about a fact-based topic (like a charity or organization) ever again. I've learned that it's too risky and can create the appearance of "spinning" if the organization appears on the web. If I do, it will be a subjective narrative regarding my thoughts about and experience with that organization."
There is nothing about the topic of charities or organizations that specifically would make it appear to be spun.
I think your most affective tactic is step 3.
Thank you, Matthew for more clarification. Since I'm quite new to this, I did not understand exactly what "duplicate content" meant. So we were all speculating about what it could possibly be about and what causes duplicate content. All possibilities were presented by helpful hubbers trying to help me figure out how to proceed. #2 was based on my understanding of how the duplicate content "red light" could get tripped. Glad to know that isn't so. I totally agree that #3 will be most effective. I'm very grateful for your help. Aren't you glad this is over?
Tell your friends to take screenshots if they want to "archive" your articles, or better, just link to it. Do NOT copy your entire article, which is not cool in either case, even if he kept all the attributions (i.e. "authored by")
haha i liked the "thievery" use, Copyright violation would be serious stuff, its implying that your blog moderator for the neighborhood civic association wrote a DMCA takedown letter to hubpages. I'm sure he/she didn't do that, if itss a duplicate content warning that means the hubpages scanner found similiar text on the internet on another website, in this case your neighborhood civic association's site
A mini-rant for the heck of it...
If I video tape a neighborhood thief stealing my lawn chair, and call the cops, off to jail the thief goes.
If that same neighborhood thief and his website steals one of my articles that is earning me 10 lawn chairs a month, and I call the cops...
There will nary be a cop to be found.
Why is that? Just saying...
And if you friend borrows your lawn chair when you only offered them the cupholder....
no, I have no idea where this metaphor is going.
para and psycheskinner, y'all are too funny. Thanks for the laugh. I'm not as neurotic as this thread and the other one would imply; just clueless. Thanks guys for all your help
by GA Anderson 6 years ago
wanted to rant - but thought maybe I could br wrong, and some community feedback might show me the errors I am missingThe story:I had a hub unpublished as duplicateI did not think it was so I contacted HP teamfound out they considered the author's resource box as dupe - so I edited itresubmitted...
by Living Well Now 6 years ago
Should HubPages do more to check for copyright violations in hubs?Hub Hopping isn't the answer. Flagging violations may help increase a Hubber's score, which may, in turn, increase their visibility on HP, but this carrot will only go so far. Experienced hubbers and newbies alike use copyrighted...
by Liz Elias 3 years ago
I am writing a new hub, with an educational intent, and I would like to include, in its entirety, a very brief poem by Dorothy Parker.The latest copyright date by her is 1956. (She died in 1967.)The current copyright is Penguin Books, 2006.Can this poem be used in my article under the...
by Nicole A. Winter 9 years ago
One of my hubs, http://hubpages.com/hub/relationshipswork has been marked as a duplicate! This was advice given to me from my Aunt when my ex-husband and I first got married as well as common sense. I asked for it to be reviewed, but I am quite put out! I don't copy other people's...
by Lena Welch 5 years ago
How often does HubPages recheck copyright violations?I filed a DMCA request and one of the violators has been pulled down. I am STILL (ugh, it has been months) waiting on Google to pull down the Blog page with the other violation - they told me it would happen but I have yet to see it.I don't...
by Sanjay Sharma 4 years ago
Complete hub posted by someone on Facebook.
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|