I have a YouTube video at the bottom of a hub which used to be viewable, but now is not. However, the introductory still picture still shows up and it is very pertinent to the subject. It is of a piece of art that was auctioned at a record breaking price.
The question is: is it all right to leave the link even though it is broken? I think the still shot (which continues to be viewable) still adds a lot to the hub.
If I were you I'd try to find another still shot and replace it rather than leaving a broken link. It doesn't really reflect well on your work to have broken links.
I think it affects the user. They are clicking on something and ending up in a 404 error page is not good.
Hi Rochelle Frank,
It's definitely a good idea to remove broken links from your Hub, as they can get your Hub moderated for being substandard.
Thanks. I removed it. Normally I do it immediately. This one just seemed different.
What does one do with broken links that are labeled as such, but are not broken? I tested one for the second time in 2 weeks just now, and it took me directly to the linked article.
Here is the URL: http://watergeek.hubpages.com/hub/Contr … t-Services
That's a good question.
I have one that's marked copied--even though the copy has been taken down.
This probably means the link was fixed since the last time it was checked. If you've confirmed that the link still works, your account info should update soon.
Nope. I first checked it on 6/03, but it was ok. I went ahead and edited a couple other things. It was still showing broken yesterday, though, so I checked it again and it still works.
Which link are you having problems with on the Hub?
At the bottom under "For More Information" the first link is highlighted as potentially broken. It's entitled "Save Water and Money With a Landscape Survey."
Thanks for letting me know! I'll look into it and get back to you.
Our engineers are working on it. It should be fixed soon.
From the two answers so far, I'm thinking I should remove it, though I will need to do some textual revision also. I did find a still shot of the work online, but it is under copyright. I suppose if someone pays $17 million for a Picasso, they don't want everyone copying it.
Maybe you can write to the people who own the copyright and get permission to include it on your Hub in exchange for a link to their site. I've written to a few people for permission, and have had good luck.
That's a thought, but I doubt if Sothebys, the Guggenheim Museum, or the Estate of Pablo Picasso would be interested in a puny link.
I appreciate the advice, but I will probably work it out another way.
Try http://www.wikipaintings.org/ Images are normally copyrighted but they fall under Fair Use as being historically relevant, easily obtainable on the internet, and of low resolution which makes them unsuitable for commercial use.
I would definitely get rid of the broken video link, especially to a private video. Your viewers won't appreciate it. I try to get rid of broken links as soon as I'm aware of them. I periodically check my videos to make sure they're still linked ok.
How often do you think we should check the videos in our hubs, like weekly or monthly or something? Also, do you do this by trying to watch the video in your hubs or do you just use the "broken links" link in "my account"?
Whenever I use the "broken links" link, I always get "No broken links found at this time." so I guess that means my hubs have no broken links?
Apparently no broken links have been detected.
I don't think it's worth the time and effort to go check every one, if it hasn't been brought to your attention.
Mine (which I have now removed) was there for months and it seemed to have no adverse effect on the hubscore or number of views.
Okay thanks. Yeah, I guess it really would take much time and effort to go through each and every hub just to check for broken links especially for those writers who have written a lot of hubs already. So, is checking using the "broken links" link an effective method of checking if you really have broken links or not?
OK, thanks to you all-- I know you are probably right and I'll take care of it --as much as I hate to lose the image altogether.
i have a hub that has broken link. Haven't fix it yet. However, i did noticed that the hub was not featured when the broken link is unfixed. Is it true?
This particular one has a high hubscore -- about 86, is featured and gets a few views each day.
I'm still a little on the fence about changing it, but I probably will.
See if there's a duplicate video you can use. If it was removed, it might have been a copy of someones else video.
I agree that a broken link should be removed. I believe that is one of the quality assessment tools to id broken links, besides, wouldn't you rather offer a reader a full read instead of the potential frustration of not being able to view the video?
The reader would hold you, the author accountable for that.
I had the same problem with a video once. I really liked that video, but I replaced it rather than leave it as a broken link. That was a first for me. I never knew the reason.
I guess I assumed that if a video was on YouTube, it would be OK to use. Maybe mine had a copy write issue.
by jodijoyous 6 years ago
I had six hubs showing broken links yesterday. I corrected all of them, but two are still showing the broken link icon. And, the edit date hasn't updated. Anyone else seeing this?
by Steve Andrews 8 years ago
Today I have had several alerts for broken links in my hubs that turned out to be videos and all were actually working when I tried playing them,
by Mike Russo 2 years ago
Have you had this happen to you? I searched for the highlighted broken link but I could not find one. So how do you clear the notice?
by Sherri 9 years ago
This is a great feature HP has...flagging Hubs where links within those Hubs are broken.However, just in the last 20 minutes, four of my Hubs showed on My Account page as having broken links. Only one did. (As in, there was no yellow text when looking at those Hubs in edit mode, for three of...
by Paul Deeds 12 years ago
We just made a small update to the site. The biggest change is the addition of the broken link report. It will show you broken links in your text and link capsules.We'll be trying to test all links about once a week, and re-test broken links every 24 hours or so. A link could be...
by Kenna McHugh 23 months ago
It's not professional, and readers are getting a false impression. Has anyone heard why false YT broken links report this keep happening?
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|