Nobody has ever been able to give me an exact number, but I would really like to have one. All I hear is that the number is low...well, how low? Anybody know?
Unknown information - it has never been made public. The closes I've seen is a "handful" of (search engine) visits per month. I suppose keeping it secret prevents gaming the algorithm by getting friends to search and visit any hub that is known to be close to going unfeatured due to low traffic.
I checked my featured hubs. The lowest is having 5 views for 30 days.
See Simone's answer to a forum I posted on this topic a few months back. She said it was a few views over a two month period:
Janshares: This is really good info...thanks. I always have a number of hubs that score 5 or less per month and when I see numbers like that, I go in and try to rework the hub. I just wondered how low was really "low" and how long it had to remain low to become unfeatured. This gives a bit of a guide, so thank you.
All my hubs are featured and some of them have had very little 'engagement'.
Some, like a book review for example, has had very few visitors, yet still remains featured for some reason.
Sorry - this isn't really answering your question, I know. :-)
Mine are staying featured with at least 2 outside hits per 30 days. That seems to be sufficient.
psycheskinner: this is good to know. I rarely have hits that low, but when I do, I go in and rework the hub. It doesn't always help, and when it doesn't, I delete the hub. Sometimes there is just too much competition out there to make keeping the hub online a viable option. If only 2 people are reading it per month, there's no money or satisfaction in it for me!
Remember that "engagement" is not traffic, but instead refers to visitor behavior while on a page.
Engagement can be measured in various ways:
-- Time spent on the page
-- How much of the page did the visitor read?
-- How many links, ads, poll choices, slideshows, or other interactive features did the visitor click on?
-- Did the visitor comment?
-- Did the visitor share the page on any social media platforms via the social share buttons?
-- Did the visitor like the page enough to click on a link pointing to some other part of Hubpages?
These are all "visitor engagement" factors which various online writing, marketing and SEO experts routinely throw out when discussing "visitor engagement." I'm not sure which of these Hubpages' algorithm measures to arrive at our hubscore, but indirect evidence points to one in particular.
I've got an accolade for "writ[ing] particularly engaging hubs which visitors love to read from start to finish."
That suggests that the second factor I listed above is almost certainly a part of Hubpages' "engagement" score. It's measured by checking whether the visitor scrolled to the bottom of the page.
(Insert my usual riff about "traffic isn't everything, but everything flows from traffic -- you can't get visitor engagement without visitors, but it's possible that visitors and engagement are scored separately, so you might be able to get featured with fewer visitors if your engagement score is higher, or need more visitors to stay featured if your visitors tend to leave after the first screen!)
GreekGeek: I never thought of that, but you make a very important point. I have the same accolade as you despite the fact that I get very few comments. My very best hub traffic wise has not one comment on it! However, I think this is because comments do not come from outside readers as I do not believe there is a mechanism in place that allows this. So, if the majority of reads comes from search engines, it would stand to reason that the concept of how many comments one has would not play a huge part in determining engagement. Am I wrong about this?
In this context engagement does mean traffic though HP have said that in time they do want to incorporate actual engagement (as you've described) into the metric.
We have been told in previous threads that it means primarily visits from visitors entering via search engines per month. They should probably call it "traffic".
I think it was on a blog post that I read about dozen hits per month would keep a hub featured.
It must have been reduced since then. I have featured hubs that haven't had that much traffic in quite a few months.
Just my two cents worth. I logged in today, as I do several times a week (simply to unpublish and move material HP deems not good enough) and sure enough I had three more hubs "Not Featured - Engagement." I figure by the end of the year I will not be on HP because they continue to deem my content unworthy.
So far, now, I do believe they have killed close to 50 of my hubs that I have had to move elsewhere. It is amazing, however, that once moved, they move up in the searches and get plenty of views.
This leaves me to believe, as I have mentioned previously, something is not working right here on HP.... I could take several guesses but will leave that to the "experts" here on the forums, lol.
I do know that my material has not changed and does better elsewhere. I just do not get the revenue that I would get on HP if they would stop screwing around with all their so called tweaking and slapping the no-index tag on hubs that is a sure death if left here.
by Bill Yovino 10 years ago
This is not a complaint about a specific Hub, but the whole "Not Featured due to lack of engagement" thing. I will however, give a specific example.I have a recipe Hub for making Chicken Paprikash. This Hub has been de-indexed by HubPage as seen in this...
by Dan Harmon 8 years ago
Today I find two hubs have gone unfeatured for lack of engagement - the half circle symbol. This seems odd as the 30 day traffic is 78 and 89, they have 48 and 82 comments and score 83 and 100 respectively. Has there been a change I'm unaware of? Anyone else getting unexpected...
by Jemuel 10 years ago
What inspires you to write quality hubs when you know they can be unfeatured for low engagement?Making a quality content hub requires effort and dedication. With the update of Google Panda and low engagement of some hubs, which sometimes results to getting hubs unfeatured, what keeps you inspired...
by awordlover 10 years ago
Do you work on your "unfeatured" hubs to improve them? Or let them stay unfeatured?On your hub list, when you see the message "This hub is not featured because it doesn't receive sufficient engagement" next to one of your hubs, are you likely to revamp the hub to try to get it...
by Missing Link 5 years ago
I'm thinking the answer is probably yes?If you have hubs that have been deemed "not featured", for one reason or another, will that factor into lowering your overall score/rating as a HubPages member? Example--let's say your overall rating is 75. If 10 non featured hubs become...
by Faith Reaper 10 years ago
I am just curious, all 92 hubs of mine are featured. In your opinion, should one delete (although Featured) any hubs where the score on a particular hub has eventually dropped way down from when it was initially high at one point? Or would it be better to just unpublish and later...
Copyright © 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of The Arena Platform, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|