Recently, I've learned that "The Big G" considers comments as content, this being the reason HP is going in to edit comments for proper spelling & grammar.
Also, along these lines, I've seen it said in these forum posts, that because it's content, comments that are very short don't help, and may hurt.
So--is that saying that people who just stop by and leave 2 to 5 word comments are not helping the article? I'm torn as to whether to approve or deny such comments as "Nice piece" or "Very informative article." I don't like to hurt people's feelings, (by not approving their comments), but neither do I wish to hurt my traffic chances from G.
My opinion is all comments are good except for spam. The fact that someone read an article and is moved to comment or react, positive or negative is a good thing. I read recently, many news sites have decided to scrap the comment section because they were too toxic and full of trolls...
It is up the author to add a comment module or not.
The fact is, if you don't delete those comments, HubPages will - that would count as a "low quality" comment and they periodically cull those.
Comments like "Nice piece" or "Very informative article" will not be removed by Moderators. We are mainly focused on removing spam and comments that are difficult to read and understand.
That's interesting, because when the feature was first introduced, the discussion suggested very short comments would be caught in the filter.
I personally do not remember it saying anything about very short comments. Just spammy comments. This is done through people working at mturk and it's not a script that's controlling this stuff, is it?
This is what the HubPages Newsletter said regarding the types of comments that are typically denied.
"Comments that are admin denied will be deleted (only spam or extremely low quality comments are typically denied this way)."
Comments that have not received a decision by the author within 7 days will be reviewed by a Moderator.
But, what about previous (old) hubs? Should we go through all of them and remove those short low quality comments?
It's usually your followers who leave such comments. What I personally do is approve them (if they are not culled, as Marisa has pointed out). I even go ahead and reply to them. I wait 2 - 3 days, give the commenter time to read my reply and then delete both, the comment and my reply.
As I edit old hubs I also go through the comments and delete any old comments that fall in this category and my replies too.
Do you guys think Google likes to see the author replying to comments on articles interacting with readers? Just a thought. Probably does not matter.
Jesse, I disagree. If someone asks you a question about the best sites in Cape Cod, and you provide more details than is available in your hub, your hub might show up if a specific question is asked related to your answer.
Have you ever done a search for something and found that the answer is in the comment section, and not in the body of the article? I have. Can I give you an idea on how important it is or how often this happens? No, not at all.
Which is why I explained that answers need to contain information. If someone asks a question and your reply "yes" or "no" I doubt Google cares.
You stated that there is no scheme being used to allow Google to know you are replying. Do you know this for sure? Are you privy to the information that Google uses to rank its pages?
I think what Jesse was getting at was, maybe the mere fact of interaction is important - and in that case, keeping meaningless comments and replying to them might count for something. Lobobrandon was saying no, it doesn't.
If you've got meaningful questions and useful answers in your comments then of course that has value because it's good content. The fact of who is asking and who is answering - Google can't tell.
by Randi Benlulu 8 years ago
Do you feel that people should respond to comments that are left for them on their hubs?i personally enjoy the feedbak left to me, as well as the opportunity to get to know my fellow "Hubbers" but I have noticed that there are many hub authors who do not respond at all or only selectively.
by Liz Elias 4 years ago
So, I've always thought it was the polite thing to do to reply to commenters, and thank them for their time and input, and I've made an effort to do so consistently.However, I'm wondering if this is now being discouraged by HP, as there is no available comment box for replies on hubs that have been...
by Audrey Hunt 8 years ago
Is there any point in replying to a comment on a hub left by a guest?I usually reply to comments left by a "guest" just in case they return again. But now I'm wondering if it's a waste of time. Do they ever see a reply?
by imatellmuva 10 years ago
Is it only me, or are there others who think that it should be a common courtesy to reply to comments made to a hub. I always reply to comments made by my followers and others, and people who I follow do the same. I have noticed however, that some hubbers have comments left on their page, and they...
by Lesleysherwood 8 years ago
Do you find that leaving comments and replying to them increases your stats, or does it take you away (time wise) from writing hubs?
by Liz Elias 9 years ago
Here's an annoying glitch:Someone leaves a well-thought-out comment, and you wish to offer an in-kind reply. However, after a few sentences, once the original visible space in the comment box is filled, all of a sudden further typing becomes very problematic, with the text jumping about like...
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|