Hi fellow hubbers!
I have started writing an article based on crime and I have got a warning message in the top right of the screen saying 'WARNING: Advertising has been disabled on this Hub based on automatic content filters'.
There are no lurid details of any crimes, it's more a historical look at things. Does this mean ads won't be displayed on the hub if I complete it? I understand that advertisers wouldn't want to be associated with the more lurid details of murders and the like, but this article is't that sort of thing.
I guess what I'm asking is, should I bother completing the article, or scrap it?
Kind of hard to gauge that without a link I think.
Yes I guess it is. It's about the history of serial killers.
Obviously I don't want to go to great lengths to do a polished article if it isn't going to be featured though.
Perhaps the best route would be to submit a rough draft to HP admin and ask them directly? It is ultimately their decision as to what gets ads and what doesn't. They could guide you better than fellow Hubbers.
If HP decides that they will not place ads on your article, it could still be featured if it passes the quality assessment -- it just wouldn't have ads on it. If the message of your article is something you want to put out regardless, it might be worth it to you to have it published without ads. If your main reason for publishing it is advertising royalties, you may want to publish it elsewhere if HP decides they do not want to place ads on it.
I may be very wrong about this, but I seem to remember that years ago if you wanted to talk about crime and you used the word 'rape' in a page where such a thing would logically be discussed, that merely the use of the word shut down advertising. I may be remembering this wrong, it's been a while, and things may have changed regardless.
Which I completely understand. Who wants to advertise their product next to such a topic? Unless of course you are selling personal alarms for women I guess. Nevertheless I don't see why a subject should be off limits as long as it isn't being glorified in some way. I am treating the subject in a historical sense.
The thing you have to remember is that HubPages relies on Adsense for a huge part of its income. Even the HP Ads program has a large component of Adsense. If HP lost their Adsense account, they would have to close down because the business would no longer be viable. Don't think that can't happen - I know of one site that lost its account, and another that came very close!
So it's not surprising that HubPages interprets the Adsense rules very strictly, because they can't afford to make a mistake. Their automated filters are based on the Adsense rules.
Save it first before you delete it. I deleted some of my hubs but I copy-pasted them first to my gmail. It could be useful for other purposes. (ex: use it as sample if you're offering ghostwriting services or you might want to create a website soon.
Hi Maribel, thanks for the advice.
I have saved a copy of all my hubs so far. I think it's only prudent to do so, given that websites come and go. Whilst HP has been around for some time and hopefully will stick around for a long time to come, you just never know. I'd hate to lose all that work put into research and writing.
Just to update those kind enough to give me advice. I have published the hub as normal. Once the moderators have decided if it meets the required standards to feature it or not, I will update you again on whether adverts are allowed or not. I will decide what to do with it once tht stage is reached.
Again, thanks for the advice!
I think a good tact to follow is to keep as G-rated as possible. That's what I do anyway. But, with your subject matter that can be tough, I just wouldn't be gratuitous about descriptions of violence, things of that nature. Good luck!
Feel free to take a look if you like Jesse. An opinion is always welcomed.
https://hubpages.com/politics/The-Histo … ial-Killer
Ads were disabled on a hub of mine about a site review, and the hub is not describing any prohibited or sensitive subject! I think HubPages need to fine-tune their automated filters to make them catch only hubs with sensitive/prohibited content.
As I explained in my previous post, I can understand why HubPages wants to set its automated filters to be extra-cautious. They're protecting their livelihood (and ours) after all. You can appeal (email the team@ hubpages) - plenty of people have had their ads reinstated after a review by a moderator. The only snag is that the ads will get disabled again every time you edit the Hub.
At the moment, I'm more concerned about building my number of articles, than worrying about ads. I'm trying to build up a sound base to access a Google Adsense account, so quality of article and a decent portfolio seems to be the way to go in order to achieve this. If the ads are disabled on that particular hub, then so be it. I am confident that nothing in that article can be considered to breach any rules of any kind.
I had this same warning on mine and my article is only about Suicide Prevention because I am an advocate of The American Foundation of Suicide Prevention. I read everything and had nothing in the article that was against policy, maybe it was just the word "Suicide" I submitted anyway after I did a check on any material that was prohibited and the search came up 0. So I submitted for a review! Does anyone have anything they would like to read on, interested in?
You guess right.
Like I said, HubPages must apply the rules set by Adsense, because it relies on Adsense for its income. Advocating suicide is one of its "prohibited" subjects.
Obviously, Adsense appears on so many thousands of sites, it's impossible for them to use humans to police them all, so they use automated filters (we call them robots). The robots are too dumb to read context, all they can do is find words, so that's what they do - look for words.
The result, of course, is that the Adsense robots see a helpful article about sex therapy the same as a pornographic article, because they're using the same "prohibited" words. HubPages automated filters are set up the same way, so they have the same issue.
That's crazy that advocating for suicide prevention would be prohibited. You would think they would want this world to lower the rates! I am also an official advocate for the American Foundation of Suicide Prevention. That's crazy! I could see if you were for suicide, or for killing someone that sort of thing. I looked at my violations and have 0 violations. Just does not make since.
Um - no it's not crazy. I explained why it happens. The sheer volume of articles being published online (thousands every day) means that it's impossible for them to be monitored by humans, and the robots can only look at words. If you can think of a way around that, then good for you!
The thing is, there are plenty of opportunities for you to write about the subject if your goal is to raise awareness and help others. HubPages will happily publish the article and so will many other sites. You just can't earn money from it through Adsense.
by Dorsi Diaz 9 years ago
Something just occured to me, not only are we writers here but we are ALSO CONSUMERS. I see nothing wrong with clicking on a fellow hubbers google ad if it's something we are interested in. I am getting the feeling that some people are afraid to do this for fear of reprisal for being click happy...
by Yaseen Essack 16 hours ago
Hi AllI was wondering if anyone could help me. When I login to AdSense I am getting this error. "Earnings at risk – You need to fix some ads.txt file issues to avoid severe impact to your revenue." I have read on the forum different people talking about the same issue but I have not been...
by radiantwriting 6 years ago
I have a hub about Suicide on the Golden Gate Bridge that was published in 2009 and has been read more than 71,000 times and another on the status of the Golden Gate Suicide Barrier that was published in 2011. Ads on both of these hubs were just disabled today (05-19-13), can anyone tell me why?...
by GwennyOh 7 years ago
i had the ads disabled on one article. This has left me with questions.There was a warning i read that if it happens a number of times that I publish content that can't host ads, that my account may be suspended. Does this also include when I publish an article such as it was - an important and...
by Aya Katz 9 years ago
My new hub has had advertising automatically disabled. As far as I can tell, it does not violate Adsense policy. Who should I contact? Is it Maddie?
by Steve Andrews 7 years ago
I have a hub about homosexuality in monarch butterflies with ads for books on Amazon about homosexuality in animals, however, ads have been disabled and in the warning why details it says: "Because this Hub was identified manually, and not through our automatic filter, this status will not...
Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|