Any one else having problems with them?
None of my are accurate? They're all dog food ads.
Each one of my hubs have the same ads.
I noticed that - its an ebay ad, I think.
Kind of annoying, but if you refresh I think they go away, so I dont think *everyone* will see them. I'm sure they will cycle out soon.
Isabella- I've refreshed, closed out, started over, reclicked, etc. They won't go away... *pouts* Ha... I just hope they cycle out soon.
Maybe I'll try a different computer. See if it's just mine.
Not just yours, Whitney - I have the same thing! Not that I have anything against dogs!
I've been looking around HubPages, and have noticed that several people seem to have the same or similar ads. Hm...
At one point, the ads were fine, and then when I went back to them a few minutes later, they were back to the dogs.
Marisa- Same here. I even have several dog hubs, but their on other hubs too. :-(
I came here because of the same problem.
I'm seeing dog food ads from ebay...well maybe they are relevant come to think of it. Russ Dalbey is a dog.
Well glad to know that I'm not the only one. Hope they'll go away.
I just noticed it on each of the hubs I just surfed through.
Including 3 from Relache.
So it's across the board and I guess we just have to wait for them to go away.
Odd, really, as I can't imagine the ads appealing to anyone - the one's I'm seeing don't really say anything more than dog food or summat.
My ads seem to have corrected themselves for now. My last two published hubs still have generic ads, but they're ads nonetheless.
Yes you are right dog food and tatoos. But will go away as soon as it picks up.
Sorry this has happened to you, but glad I'm not the only on. I noticed today that my no-bake pie recipe hub has dog food ads. I was very puzzled about the trigger ...? Whipped cream ... pudding? Hmmm...
It looks like their gone, mostly on my hubs. What about you guys?
I am seeing that the ebay ads in the middle of the hubs are back. :-( They aren't content related either...
I just emailed a screen shot of that to Paul.
Hopefully he'll see it soon!
Those ads are useless, I can't imagine anyone clicking them!
Hi all -
I'll offer a bit of an explanation, since I know how the "other side" works (AdWords = AdSense from the advertisers' perspective).
Basically, there is not an unlimited number of ad impressions from each advertiser/category, necessarily. Advertisers can limit their daily budget, or can choose to only display ads in Google search (instead of broadening it to publisher sites like HubPages).
Also, advertisers will start and stop campaigns based on (presumably) their performance, so if an advertiser isn't getting the return they want based on what they're paying per click, they can pull a campaign. Campaigns come and go; it's a very dynamic process.
Advertisers can also advertise across particular sites (site-targeted ads, as opposed to keyword-targeted ads), and pay a relatively low flat rate for doing so.
HubPages as a whole apparently does well with pet-related topics. AskSusanPeters, among others, contribute a lot of Hubs on the topic of pets in general, so advertising on HubPages as a whole probably makes for a good business proposition for pet-product advertisers, because those pet-related Hubs probably perform so well for them that they make up for the same ads appearing on non-pet-related Hubs.
Because keyword-related clicks are typically more valuable than site-related clicks to Google (and they tend to perform better because they're better targeted to the content), Google will prefer them, but if there is no "inventory" of keyword-related ads related to a Hub's topic, or the Hub is so new that Google hasn't had the chance to crawl it and determine which keyword-related ads are best suited to it, it will run the site-related ads as a backup.
And our ad optimization engine (YieldBuild) will try eBay ads and other formats for your Google ads to see which performs best. If they don't perform well, you'll eventually see them phased out.
Thanks for that Jason, but I think we may be talking about different types of ads..
They aren't dog food ads, really - they're ebay ads.
They literally are a big white space with the word "dog food" written there and the ebay logo.. ??
Is that the same thing you mean?
People just plainly don't understand how YieldBuild works. I think somebody from the team should come up with a detailed explanation for beginners, since I see related topics more and more lately...
PS I wish I could have it on my site...
I dont personally care what ads show up where on my hubs. I dont care if they are huge towers in the middle of everything, or I wouldnt use capsules.
I just dont see the point in those specific ebay ads that only say "dog food".
Who would click on that??
To be able to tell a crap from gold, you have to test crap, too. And it takes some time...
Exactly. YieldBuild will phase out worse-performing ads, so those eBay ads will vanish if they truly don't perform. But sometimes they do. Like Misha said, you really don't know if they will perform until you test them, which is exactly what YieldBuild does.
Misha - You can apply to use YieldBuild on your site by using this form.
Thanks, I tried yesterday. My measly 75000 monthly pageviews were not enough to pass the threshold... So, David just kindly put me on a waiting list until you guys start working with small folks like me
Meanwhile I'm trying Pubmatic. Just installed it today, so no opinion so far...
A hungry dog would click on it...!
It just depends on whether the dog had a can opener or the necessary means to open the tin....we must be there for our dog friends as they are the future of the world and really are the friends I never had....make sense...good...thank god for red wine...I feel slightly sick now...drink is bad now when binge drink becomes too much....must sleep! good night!
Thats such a slavic reply, lol!!!!
Ok, I'll just have to find something to entertain me while the time passes!
Those ads are just a subtle suggestion that you write more hubs about dog food and tattoos, our two favorite topics here at HubPages (actually between us all, I think we have 2 dogs and maybe 1 tattoo).
But in all seriousness, those ads should be fading away now. I think someone may have misplaced a decimal point when estimating the earning per click for the ebay ads yesterday.
These ads are still all over the place, and given their virtually useless content, I'm sure they are hurting everyone's earnings.
I've surfed around and pretty much every ad that comes between capsules is showing a senseless ebay ad like this. They are not fading away.
Isabella: I agree. I don't understand who would click an ad with only 1 or 2 words with no description.
I've been waiting 2 days for my last 2 hubs to have accurate google ads. Should I just continue to wait?
Yes. We have control over what type, color, and where ads appear, but the contextual accuracy of the ads isn't something we have much influence over. Normally it doesn't take very long for google to line up some relevant ads, but maybe they are having trouble getting new stuff crawled right now.
Paul- I have older hubs that seem to have reverted back to blogging ads and such. Hubs that I've never had a problem with these hubs and the ads on them updating.
Paul: I have noticed a decline from say last week. I just checked out the adv. report, and saw about a .2 - .3 percent decline.
That sounds like it may be in the range of normal fluctuation.
There is another good report you can run, under advanced reports, select show data by "individual ad" and then check the "show data by targeting type - contextual or placement" box. This will show you the number of ad impressions that were "contextual" and the number that were "site" based. Look at the numbers over the last week or so, and let me know if there was a significant move.
Across HubPages it bounces around a fair amount but around 4-5% of the ads are "site" based lately. There does seem to be a slight trend up in that percentage in the latter half of November. I'm not sure what the reason for that is.
Oops, Paul I looked at the wrong CTR percent. From the 19th till today, My Ad CTR decreased about 10%. Impressions are about a third of what they were on the 19th.
Whitney, in the decade I've been doing web sites and watching web traffic, I can attest to the fact that you will often see both web traffic and clicks go down around the holidays, as people have a lot of other things to do than be online.
You'd be surprised how much web traffic comes from when people are at work versus when they are at home...LOL...
Relache: That's what I was thinking last night. That I noticed the decline after Thanksgiving, and attributed the decline to the holidays as so much is going on elsewhere.
What does everyone have against dogs? Dogs need attention too.
My google earnings went down by almost 50% since the start of the holiday season and my number of clicks just went down by around 25%, my traffic is much the same. I guess advertisers are paying less now because there will be less people who will use the internet during the holiday season. Im expecting it to go back to normal early next year.
I was trying to calm everybody on this issue, but now I myself think something is going wrong. Since I plugged in my ebay id into hubpages a few days ago, I got more than 6000 impressions and ONE click and no sales = $0.00. It would have brought me at least $50 at the current eCPM I have on HP. This can't be right, there is a bug somewhere.
Guys, please look into this. It is taking too long. We all (including you) are loosing money...
I've noticed that often the ebay ads run in addition to a full complement of adsense ads. So you're not necessarily losing money as a result. We actually saw the highest adsense CPM we've had this month yesterday. That, said if you remove your ebay token the ads shouldn't run in your share of impressions. If you want to run a little experiment for us and report back what you find (with and without ebay set), I'd be curious what you see.
We are working with ebay to improve the contextual-ness of the ads. It's still a relatively new product for them.
I'm not sure what this means. Either there is an ebay ad in a particular slot, or a google one, not both. So if a bad ebay ad is displaying, is it not taking up the spot that an adsense ad could have been?
Does this have to do with the fact that I just added an ebay affiliate code? I'm more than happy to take the thing out if it will bring back reasonable ads.
As for the context-ness, it's not working at all. I have not seen one single ebay ad that made sense yet.
NOTE: I just deleted my ebay affiliate id and I am no longer seeing the bad ads on my hubs. YAY.
I would gladly run any test for you I need to understand exactly what and how you want me to test, though
Please clarify, that I understand you correctly:
You want me to remove my ebay id from my hubpages account and after a couple of days to report whether my adsense eCPM changed or not, right?
Yeah, I'm just curious if you see any significant difference in your adsense numbers with or without your ebay token set. It's a little hard to control for externalities, but as long as your traffic is relatively steady it should be a reasonable test.
Terri -- There is a limit to the number of adsense ads you can run on a page. Once you reach the limit, they just won't serve an ad in that spot and the area will collapse away.
I believe the current limit is 3 ads, plus up to 3 link units.
I'm still having problems with google updated ads. I have hubs that were published monday, and 1 minute I'll see content appropriate ads, and the next their blogging ads or some other default ad. Should I contact google, or just sit on them... I'm getting decent traffic to the hubs, I would just like to see ads that are related.
Whitney, did you try running the adsense report that I suggested? It will show you the ratio of "site targeted" ads to "contextual ads" over any period you specify. Here's you do it:
1. Login to adsense
2. Go to the advanced reports tab
3. Select a date range, I'd suggest "this month".
4. Select "Individual Ad" under the "Show data by" drop menu
5. Check the "show data by targeting type" check box
6. Display the report
It will show you the number of individual ad impressions for each day that were contextual, and the number that were site targeted (plus the click through rate, cpm, etc.) for each type.
Across HubPages around 5% of the ads are site targeted. If you're ratio (you'll have to do the math to calculate it) is way different, then there might be a problem. There are two reasons google would show a site targeted ad, 1) they don't have any inventory that match your content, 2) they haven't crawled your content yet.
Paul, I tried did attempt to run the report. I pulled it up, but I guess what is confusing me as to what exactly I am to calculate to figure the percentage. What figures should I be looking at?
I, also, considered that there may not be ad to put on these hubs, but one of the hubs is about a topic I have already written about, which has ads. The other topic is similar to that of what has been written by other hubbers, which have ads on their hubs.
Whitney -- For each day there should be two rows in the report, one where the targeting is contextual, and one where it is site. Add the ad impressions from those two lines to get the total number of ad impressions, then divide the ad impressions that were just site into the total. That would give you the percentage that were site targeted for that day.
For instance, if you had these two rows:
Row 1 --
Friday, November 30, 2007
9,500 Ad Impressions
Row 2 --
Friday, November 30, 2007
500 Ad Impressions
The total would be 10,000 impressions, and then 500 / 10000 = 0.05 or 5% that are "site targeted".
Do that for a few different days scattered through the month, and you should be able to see if there was any significant change lately. If your percentage is a lot higher than 5%, then it may be worth investigating further. If not, it's probably just normal.
Paul that's what I thought. When I calculated it earlier I got a ginormous tally, so I wasnt' sure if it was right, but i accidently multiplied one of the numbers versus add. But I finally got it. I'm not over 5% but WELL under...
I wanted to attach the file, but did not find a way to do this. Here is my Hubpages adsense data listed as a table. Today's data is incomlete of course. Overall I don't see any pattern related to ebay, so my fears probably were ungrounded
Date Normalized eCPM Normalized earnings
10/25/2007 0.8 0.019341801
10/26/2007 0.356722689 0.033487298
10/27/2007 0.526470588 0.006928406
10/28/2007 0.609243697 0.053983834
10/29/2007 0.590756303 0.09613164
10/30/2007 0.762605042 0.174942263
10/31/2007 0.830252101 0.205254042
11/01/2007 0.609663866 0.156755196
11/02/2007 0.678571429 0.172632794
11/03/2007 0.633613445 0.136258661
11/04/2007 0.793277311 0.290415704
11/05/2007 0.812605042 0.525981524
11/06/2007 0.697478992 0.400115473
11/07/2007 0.673109244 0.046766744
11/08/2007 0.718907563 0.043879908
11/09/2007 0.582773109 0.039549654
11/10/2007 0.571428571 0.026270208
11/11/2007 0.522689076 0.033775982
11/12/2007 0.787815126 0.373845266
11/13/2007 0.869327731 0.521939954
11/14/2007 0.728151261 0.461605081
11/15/2007 0.592857143 0.382505774
11/16/2007 0.487815126 0.285796767
11/17/2007 0.633613445 0.278290993
11/18/2007 0.52605042 0.202078522
11/19/2007 0.583613445 0.432448037
11/20/2007 0.615546218 0.450635104
11/21/2007 0.595378151 0.359988453
11/22/2007 0.606302521 0.236143187
11/23/2007 0.634033613 0.332852194
11/24/2007 0.78697479 0.454965358
11/25/2007 0.617647059 0.357967667
11/26/2007 0.578151261 0.50721709
11/27/2007 0.609243697 0.551096998
11/28/2007 0.807142857 0.670034642
11/29/2007 0.831932773 0.702944573
11/30/2007 0.842016807 1
12/01/2007 1 0.508371824
12/02/2007 0.763445378 0.279157044
Well, people do need to buy dog food on a regular basis, if they have a dog. So dog food ads are not completely out of place. What is, though, is the sheer throught that someone would buy dog food online. I find that a little absurd.
by Dorsi Diaz 10 years ago
Something just occured to me, not only are we writers here but we are ALSO CONSUMERS. I see nothing wrong with clicking on a fellow hubbers google ad if it's something we are interested in. I am getting the feeling that some people are afraid to do this for fear of reprisal for being click happy...
by Christine 7 years ago
HiI have been going through my hubs and I have noticed that I only have Google ads at the end of a lot of my hubs. The Google Ad that is normally in the second capsule to the right only appears on a few of my hubs. How can I earn money if I have no ads ? :-(Garlic Angel
by Cathy 7 years ago
I want to preface this, first, with I'm hoping I have placed this question in the appropriate group. It's becoming more apparent to me that the Google ad images (not "Related Searches" column) no longer relate to hub subjects for my hubs. I was amused to just figure out that...
by Shauna L Bowling 6 years ago
Recently I've noticed Google ads for hotels I've been writing landing pages for when I read hubs. Is it just coincidence? Or does Google place ads based on the individual reader's search habits? Is anyone else seeing ads for recent search results showing on the hubs you read?Just curious.....
by Adrienne Farricelli 12 years ago
Is it just me experiencing this problem? There are no google ads anymore in any of my websites. I took a peek on other's hubs and I cannot see them as well.
by malachauhan 9 years ago
I had created a google adsense account for my hubpages account. but the Google Adsenses rejected my application for the Google Adsense account. However, i have been noticing google ads on my hub pages for the past few months although my google adsense account is still not validated. Nor have...
Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|