Im not a big fan of jumping through hoops...filling out numerous forms (although I have today) to make of for others mistakes and poor systems. I Ilike to go right to the source
So here are all the contacts I could find on the owners of the site, crush their personal websites with comments about their assisting in copyright violations, give them a call, see if they are enjoying there day off..etc.
Alon schwartz personal website
His linkedin profile
his facebook profile
his pitiful twitter profile
(hit em with hundreds of @alonsh = thief tweets)
more personal email
Hundreds of outraged comments and contacts addressing the owners should lead to a quicker resolution
@alonsh Your website is responsible for thousands of DMCA violations, Hubpages writers have been filing dmca's with adsense all morning
Or you can just use the DMCA notification page:
Or email: firstname.lastname@example.org using their DMCA guidelines (http://www.docstoc.com/User/cmsstatic.aspx?page_id=100)
You get things done by playing by the rules. Remember they have Google Adsense on their pages, as do we. The best thing to do is play by the rules. They can easily cause false clicks, if you piss them off enough. Do you want your account closed with Adsense? I don't. Just play by the rules.
How is it their hoops? When Google tells you to do it that way? They want you to play by the rules.
Or you can be childish, and do it your way, and suffer any potential consequences.
I see childish as an insult, I think you are a sheep, you are jumping through hoops and following directions of a site you have no interest in.
DMCA complaints have been filled out in Bulk, docstoc has been contacted hundreds of times im sure,
Get a message to the owner, things happen..have any experience in Sales? never bother talking to the secretaries -
I follow rules when I am a willing participant.
The owners of Site A are profiting from my work, I am not a member, friend or associate, I contact Site A , however I feel like until the problem is resolved
I imagine I get things done much quicker
I posted a comment on his personal website telling him about the copied hubs (called them articles) and that he should take a personal interest in it since he's very proud of what he created. I don't know if he is personally responsible with what has happened but with the amount of DMCAs his site is going to receive, he should very well be worried about it.
As I posted in the other thread:
Don't you think we should wait and see what the other site has to say about it before we decided to destroy them? You are opening yourself up to libel charges if you say the site is complicit with the thief. We don't know that is the case yet.
Now if they ignore all attempt by HP to rectify the situation, that will be different.
You can wait, my systems are automated and personal. Personally contacting the owner is all I suggest.
True, although it is probably fair to accuse them of some level of incompetence.
Have to go with Sunforged on this one - I am pretty sure that the site's owners will want to fix this ASAP. I suspect that they are legit, and this is the sort of thing that they will cancel holidays for - it is that serious,
Definitely incompetence on their part for not checking copyrighted material. And, probably true that they're a legit company, but what gives us the right to harass them, when we can see what they have to say after all the bulk reports and official HubPages complaint?
We have not given them any time to correct the situation, so what makes this method of harassment right?
Yes there may have been bulk reports, but it's been 20 hours or so since the other initial thread. Many companies take Columbus Day as a holiday. Plus it's been a weekend. Give them time to get in the office and read the reports.
You are being childish.
File the reports, give them a chance to read them, and rectify the situation.
HubPages has even contacted them, but remember it's been over a weekend. Like Uninvited Writer said, if they ignore the reports, and HubPages, then take further action. Until then, you can't tell if they're ignoring anything over a freaking weekend and holiday.
Google works everyday. They have the phone numbers and contact information for this company, as the site makes money with Adsense. If an Adsense associate got 1,000 clicks an hour they would be banned without question. This site is making personal money off of copyrighted material. That alone is enough to go to court about, never mind be removed by Google. It's there problem that they don't check the copyright status on articles. Just like its the associates fault they didn't monitor there adsnse code.
Don't argue about that, its true and you know it. Thats why Hubpages has its program to flag copyrighted Hubs.
True, but if you're filing the reports with the company, they may not work on the weekends. Not every company works and checks emails on weekends. You can't guarantee they noticed them all immediately.
If you filed a report using the companies email and methods, they would be the ones to remove it from the site. Not google.
I've contacted Yahoo Answers DMCA numerous times, and they remove the content, not Google.
This does not give anyone the excuse to harass another company.
Cancelling a couple of user accounts and blocking an IP, can be done with one phone call to their engineers.
Your wasting my time. You do you...you would be amazed at the speed I have gotten my copyrighted content removed from other sites - its amazing what a phone call can do, while you fill out forms ..bye
I am also waiting for a few days for this to play out. I'll fill out 200 DMCA forms if I have to, but for now I've just filled out a few.
Remember weekend! The company probably doesn't work on the weekend.
Just wait at least a minute.
I'm not happy with it either, but Lord...
Plus remember thousands of articles stolen and republished, there's no easy button. They'll have to go through all the complaints. And what about those who didn't report stolen content. I myself don't have time to search for over 600 hubs on their site and then report every last one.
They had 7 views off one of my hubs. That's minimal compared to what I've gotten on the same hub. My traffic hasn't changed one bit, and over time I'm sure it would, but no one has given the site any chance to correct one thing.
I don't see anything illegally wrong with what is happening on DocStoc's end. A user chose to abuse their TOS and steal our hubs. They didn't tell this punk to do so. They probably still don't know about it.
If somebody came on here and posted copyrighted material, it would only be HP's responsibility to delete it after receiving a valid DMCA notice. Site owners are typically protected from these situations.
It is rare for a website to be held liable for other users (that agreed to their TOS upon registering) posting copyrighted material if they promptly respond to DMCA notices. If they ignore the DMCA notices, that's another story. Since DocStoc is a multi-million dollar company, I am certain they'll respond promptly.
Let's remember - it has only been 20 hours. It's a holiday weekend. No court would rule negligence or anything like that because a general guideline of receiving a DMCA notice is that you have a reasonable amount of time to respond. A holiday weekend is not reasonable. People are on vacation - they might not even know about it yet.
Like I said in another thread, I really hope that DocStoc simply deletes this guy's accounts, bans his IPS and deletes ALL his documents. HOWEVER, if a DMCA notice isn't received for each, individual document, they are not necessarily responsible for removing the content. (Although they should for Google Adsense purposes).
I sent a letter to them requesting my hubs be taken down and the user banned. Not sure it will help but I sent it.
What I am getting at is Weekend or not, if we are responsible as individuals, why isn't the company responsible at the same time too? You know, that guy will probably get a digital transfer of $1,000+ before his accounts is banned. And if the site never was, they made money off of your articles, and everyone else.
Google does not pay out until after the end of the month the person makes 100 dollars. Even if the person received 10,000 dollars in clicks, the money will not be paid until after the end of the month. If their account is banned, then they will receive nothing.
I agree with Whitney that everyone should just breathe and play by the rules. Running around like a chicken with it's head cut off does no good at all.
Sigh..thats dense. They started this in August. For all you know the 1st day they uploaded was 1 day before Payday, aka, allowing them to receive it before google notices. Hopefully, if they get our DMCA's quickly, they will ban his account before that date. Sitting around lets him get that Digital transfer.
The problem is that they are putting the documents into the public domain - that could create problems further down the line.
Also, if DocStoc doesn't remove the accounts within a week, they side with the person automatically and can face charges. So in a way, we help them by getting them to fix it swiftly.
Yes, but why not follow the rules versus harass and bully them? If they do not comply, then go to higher measures. All I'm saying is why harass them if we haven't given them time to correct anything?
Anyway it will take Google more than 24 hours to research and correct the situation. I forget the time that their DMCA says, but once you fax or mail the copied content report, they don't just automatically delete the other people's stuff. They do research to see if what you are saying is accurate.
Yes if more people are faxing in the reports, they'll notice it faster and they'll get on it faster, but they still have to verify if they're all accurate.
We verified it using there search engine. It shouldn't take them more then 10 seconds to know one is copied. Then come here and find 2..3...10...500...it only takes 1 to break there TOS.
Their reputation and even existence are at stake - they will want to know about it and fix this quickly. It is not just a user stealing a few articles - if I was the site's owner, I would be on my way into work to pull down the accounts. In fact, I have a feeling that they will want to sort this long before Google gets involved.
I believe that faxing is indeed one of the best options since it sends a copy or image of the original document.
Because we all know that Google are just sitting there waiting for information about copied hubs... No like there are hundreds of thousands of other articles on the web that are probably stolen... oh...wait...
I also sent a message to the user to remove the content as I knew it had been stolen. Again, not sure it will help but I am hopeful.
10 seconds times how many stolen articles? thousands. It's not going to be 5 minutes and it's done.
Plus again, not everyone will sit and search though several thousand pages to find theirs that have been copied.
Exactly... We're not the only ones making complaints and they still have to research them all. No matter how long or short of a time frame it may take them, they still have other things to do.
Whatever this is childish. I'm waiting to see what HP says to their complaint they posted before I do anything.
Message sent via Facebook
"Thousands of stolen and copyrighted articles have been showing up on your site docstoc. These articles have been stolen from HubPages writers - these articles look like they have been scraped and are being automatically uploaded to your site by user(s) with multiple usernames all starting with shift (shiftA-shiftZ)
this might interest you as hubpage writers are filling out DMCA complaints by the hundreds with adsense, speedy resolution is suggested
http://hubpages.com/forum/topic/24060?p … post431960
They just started copying hubs last week, according to other people in the other thread.
And I highly doubt they are making 1000s in just one week. It takes time to get in searches, and depending on what the terms are, they may or may not show up.
And, again, they're getting few views per hub. 5-10 views in the past week, isn't that substantial.
One of my hubs was copied last August. But it seems that the bulk of the copying was done just this October.
please RT thousands of articles stolen from Hubpages writers hosted on docstoc @alonsh
"give them time?"
um we don't live in the age of telegraphs and horses and buggies....what, this site owner doesn't have email, twitter or a cell phone?
last night i registered there and flagged my stolen article as stolen, then i posted a link back to my HP profile ... i went to log in this morning and find myself locked out...with this message:
The provided e-mail is not in the system. Please verify the e-mail.
they locked me out so i created a new one with the same email address.
i don't think sunforged is being "childish". i would't twitter this because the site owner may need time to investigate this, but i can certainly understand sunforged's outrage.
i took Mark Knowles' advice and am posting my link in my docstoc profile. good idea! (i'm RORSHACH over there). i am going to do everything in my power to expose and embarrass that little thief siftin. (well, as much as i have time for this morning).
oh thank you!
Rorshach: Never compromise. Not even in the face of Armageddon. That's always been the difference between us, Dan.
I'm going to try to figure out what you guys are talking about and join you. I do believe that being calm is the answer, but having been pirated before, I am usually one aggressive SOB about this stuff. Sound good. I'll figure it out and join. Thanks.
methodical, but calm.
alas i am too busy today to deal with this further but i will.
(said in ominous Rorschach-sounding voice
Well, cosette, your invitation was too good to pass up.
My username there is Bloodletting.
Doesn't that have a nice ring?
I backlinked to HP, etc.
I've got to get to other deadlines too.
Thanks everyone for providing such good info on this. The way to slay the dragon is to get the whole town out and dismember him all at one time. I think this will pay work mighty fast.
They also appear to have been "stolen" by more than one "user"
You must understand that my twitter is automated and has a 5.5k user reach - making a few tweets and setting it to post hourly isnt difficult, takes much less time than those DMCA's!
of which I have filled out many
The site hosting this junk should have an easy time finding it all. During the copying process of all my hubs, they took not only the written material, but also all of the advertising, which on the ones i saw of mine the ads were embedded in the text. Are all of yours that way too?
Thanks for his details J....... This personal message arrived on his personal site @ 8.03am this morning.
Be Advised that you have 48 hours to Remove all 22 Articles owned and identified as copyrighted by the above named author, stolen from Hubpages.com and posted within your site Docstore.
I am author of same and advise you that my documents are not of Pubic Domain status contrary to your site declaration that such content has been legally sourced.
I am aware that your company has also illegally obtained thousands of further documents from other writers within Hubpages and that collectively those articles have received in excess of 250,000 page views up to this time.
Should you neglect to action this request within the aforementioned timeframe; the writer will advance legal proceedings against your interests without further notice.
So.......... Let's Rock n Roll
Filing the form, and giving notice in a professional manner is all that's needed to start. After that, if there's no response, (and I'm pretty sure these site owners are probably scared to bits by now) then the legal process can handle it all pretty well.
The sky is not falling in. It's just another day in cyberspace. This, unfortunately, is what happens.
What you might? be missing is that every single one of these articles that has been posted at doctocs gets a little "Public Domain" attribution and one click download.
Its not the same as some blogger lifting your article and reposting, people come to docstocs specifically to download content for reposting.
Those hubbers with frequently views articles on doctocs can expect to see their content everywhere - those views are probably downloads.
Yes, its just another day in the net and im sure it will work out in the end, Im just a sooner rather than later type of guy - instant gratification generation and all.
i want to see at least an email that says "we are investigating the matter" ya know?
It's not that I'm not willing to do all I can. I've been through this before, along with pirated music copyrights, and even bad divorces. I'm familiar with it, and I know what the outcome can be and it's not good when so much potential damage can be done so quickly (and likely has been.) I agree in contacting. I agree in you're proposing, but really, at the end of the day, I've found that after having done all I can, I shouldn't have fretted the night away in lost sleep. And I've made a few mistakes in calling out people who weren't supposed to be involved, and I don't want to do that again, either. So that's why I take the approach I do.
I'm on your side. I've been pirated too, and so obviously it's crap for all of us. Just trying to keep a sense of perspective.
Won't it be FUN..... Read their vulnerability Daniel... I Don't Bluff!
I also went into my hubs and added a line of text about it being copyright to me at hubpages in '09. Not going to delete my work but going to start putting that in all my hubs.
heres the company phone numbers and legal counsel
Docstoc is the premier online community to find and share professional
documents. Docstoc provides the platform for users and businesses to upload and
share their documents with all the world, and serves as a vast repository of
documents in a variety of categories including legal, business, financial,
technology, educational, and creative. All documents on Docstoc can be easily
searched, previewed and downloaded for free.
Docstoc also provides technology through various APIs and Widgets to help
facilitate the sharing and promotion of documents across the web. The site has
popularized the use of embedding documents throughout the blogosphere and
mainstream media. You can learn more about embedding documents here:
Docstoc, Inc. was founded by Jason Nazar and Alon Shwartz. The company was
selected in September of 2007 to debut its product at the prestigious
TechCrunch40 Conference. The product was subsequently launched to the public in
Docstoc is a venture backed company (Rustic Canyon) and received funding from
the co-founders/investors in MySpace, LowerMyBills, Mp3.com, PriceGrabber and
Baidu. Their legal counsel is DLA Piper.
1317 5th Street
Santa Monica, CA 90401
Main Telephone: 310-255-1172
Type of Organization: Private
Key Executives: CEO: Jason Nazar
CTO: Alon Shwartz
Vice President of Business Development
Contact: Robyn Ward
Director of Marketing
Contact: Serena Ehrlich
Copyright Business Wire 2009
I just got off the phone with them - couldnt get passed the receptionist but she claimed she would pass my message along
Perhaps a couple of hundred more would help
Find this forum, and then discovered one of my articles was also copied there. I reported it to the site and Google, so I have a feeling that the plagiarist site will be taken down soon.
Spoke with site CEO, he specifically called me back to say that he did know about the issue, he does care and it will be resolved within 48 hours.
Oh OK Are You Sure that's Not in Response to my 48 hour notice?
He is probably aware of the fierce reputation enjoyed by Bumbletown's lawyers.
I spoke to the other owner
He said that it would be done quicker but due to the huge amount of content, it cant be all removed at once without damaging the site..so it is being taken down in chunks.
he is completely aware of the user shift(a-q) and is all over it!
Also put a link back to the original in the text for those who copy links and all.
by Pamela N Red 6 years ago
Someone here at HubPages has copied one of my articles. It was actually HubPages that added a copyright symbol letting me know. I flagged and notified HubPages of this but the story is still up. Why would I have to file a DMCA report when it's in house and HubPages knows about this violation? The...
by Arun Dev 5 years ago
Why are these HubPages subdomain urls being listed like this on Google search?jptrans.naver.net>Explore>Health>Health Care, Drugs and Insurance>Selecting a Procedure or Treatmentfcmalaga.ru>HubPages>Education and Science>Life...
by Poppy 3 years ago
I'm so angry. Today I got the little red circled C warning me my content was stolen. A quick scan in the plaguirism checker showed that someone had copied one of my game guides word for word onto their site. Do they not realise that just adding "Source: (link to the LevelSkip article) doesn't...
by premsingh 11 years ago
If any content of the hub is being copied by someone and used elsewhere, its not the fault of hubber. This is nice that HP is motivating hubbers to file DMCA to the concerned site and take appropriate action,who is going to waste time to fight with the copyright violators. HP has witnessed...
by Justin Choo 7 years ago
Since last week, my traffic (page views) has been decreasing. Hope not because of someone stealing my hubs as is happening so damned frequent recently. I will be at a lost if I am also a victim as I am not IT savvy. All those reports and DMCA notices to be made. So far lucky...
by Alyssa 2 years ago
Question for seasoned writers: I found an actual instance of someone who copied my hub, word for word. The only thing missing were my pictures. It was posted on a blog. I used the contact form I found to reach out to the blogger and ask that the content be removed. What is a reasonable time frame...
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|