I noticed today that one of my best articles (that really needs a rewrite) has been duplicated on a website called PetRadars.com. They copied everything from the title to the comments, though they left out the poll and all but one photo. They list on the bottom that they duplicated the article under a Creative Commons license and linked back to my article. I have reported the article to Google anyway because I don't recall agreeing to a CC license.
There is a section for comments to be left and I'm very tempted to leave a comment stating
"This article has been illegally copied from PetHelpful.com. I am the author of this article and have NOT given permission for it to be reproduced on this website. I wasn't even asked. This article was NOT published under Creative Commons at any time. For the original article, please see (url)"
Should I leave this comment on the duplicated article or just leave it alone?
File a DMCA with the website host, the webhost will remove the article because DMCA has to be taken seriously because if they ignore you then you can sue them for not removing the article.
It's a Chinese site. I sent a DMCA, but I doubt it will matter.
File it with Google, i.e., apply to delist the page from SEO. It wouldn't remove the page, but if successful, it will remove ads. Sometimes, that has an effect on the involved ad account too and the copycat will remove the page.
Try filing a DMCA complaint with Google. See the FAQ for instructions: https://hubpages.com/faq/#copiedhub
Also send a DMCA to Google because they will de-index the article.
The best thing is to ask them to remove it. if they don't remove it then filing a DMCA claim will solve your problem
DMCA would be a better option. Pressurise them to remove it and threaten them that you might follow with a suit on them and there site itself would be in danger. It might work.
These days, they is regular report of articles being copy from any Hubpages site to the PetRadar.com stable. My question is: is HubPages aware of such theft actions right from her site? If not, I believe a security software device should be created and instal on her site. So that if an article or parts thereof is being copy, an alarm is trigger against the theft. And hubpages sits up to query the theft. That will save us lots of trouble via, DMCA. I've not taken a dmca action any website. But I understand the process is time consuming and frustrating to others. So let hub-pages helps it's writers.
Matt came in on the last thread that addressed the entire PetHelpful site having been copied to PetRadar. He made it clear that it's up to each individual author to file a DMCA report, despite the fact that HP's logo is also being used on the suspect site.
They are a repeat offender copying several articles from a variety of websites. I have filed a DMCA with Google not too long ago.
Is it normal for websites to ask for a copy of your passport to verify your identity? The domain registrar asked for a copy. I have refused thus far.
No, it's not. Continue to refuse. I've never been asked to prove who I am when filing a DMCA or contacting the domain owner.
That's not normal. They never ask for passport copies.
Keep refusing. It is a good Idea to file with Google but realize too that this is not going to effect your page views.
I've never encountered this. (Never when I file with Google too)
I don't think there's any dodgy business, though. The host might be trying to drive you away; they antagonize a client after all if they remove the copied content. Or, they genuinely want hard proof of your identity for whatever reason. So I've read, many trolls file fake DMCAs.
In any case, I'd refuse and just file with Google.
This is what they emailed me:
"Dear Halley Parke,
Please note that we are only domain name registrar not the Registered Name Holder nor the website adminstrators. You do not indicate clearly where the infringing content is, is that the image or others? Please circle it to us. According to Article 1195 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China and Article 42 of the E-commerce Law of the People's Republic of China, if the right holder believes that their rights have been infringed, the notification platform should include preliminary evidence of the infringement and the true identity of the right holder. So please provide the following materials to us to verify the true identity of the right holder for our further investigation.
1. The valid passport of your ID indentity, which stated your name "Halley Parke".
2. Any further evidences that can be proof that you are the copyright holder such as trademark certifications etc.
Moreover, the DNS provider who makes its website online is "cloudflare.com", please also contact "cloudflare.com" to let them delete the hosting records or block the IP address.
Anne, It looks like you sent your DMCA takedown request to the domain name registrar and they are probably trying to get you to give them vital information they can use to steal your identity. Don’t ever give that information to anyone.
From my experience it had also been a waste of time sending a takedown request to the domain registrar or website administrator.
Instead, I always go direct to the hosting service. You can find that with this tool:
The hosting service ia required to remove the content and give the account holder the right to file a counter claim against you, but plagiarists never do.
You didn’t mention the domain where your plagiarized article is located, but that reply you got indicates the host is Cloudflare.
If it is Cloudflare, it’s not going to be easy. They are the only one I have trouble with since they claim to be a network provider offering a reverse proxy, pass-through security service, and they claim they are not responsible for their client’s doings. Hundreds of webmasters have sued them.
Here is one example of a lawsuit against Cloudflare:
You might try looking for the DNS Nameservers, and if not Cloudflare, then send a takedown notice to that host of the nameservers instead. That always worked for me.
The only exception where it’s going to be very difficult is if the host is in a country that does not honor the DMCA of the USA.
I wouldn't worry about the duplicate content. Does the duplicate show up in SERPs when you Google key phrases to your article? The site that stole it is China. I agree with Glenn; they're scamming you for vital information in order to steal your identity or worse.
Thanks everyone for the replies. I'll have to go through them properly when I'm not dead from deconstruction on the house I'm moving into. At this time, the copied article has been taken down. The PetRadars website is connected to Cloudflare. For anyone who wants to know exactly what I emailed and the responses, I can definitely post the email threads tomorrow (Friday).
by Kylyssa Shay 8 years ago
A few of my hubs have been copied by a site hosted by GoDaddy. I looked up their page about copyright infringement and something about the DMCA wording and the way that the counter notice was worded made me a little nervous. The GoDaddy reaction to copyright infringements seemed too extreme to me....
by Cholee Clay 2 years ago
The site petradarsdotcom has taken Pethelpful in its entirety (comments, author bio, ect). I was not notified by HP that these articles were copied, so I'm not sure if they are still checking our articles or not as these articles were initally posted back in March/April of this year.The very bottom...
by Titia Geertman 20 months ago
I just found a © on one of my animal hubs and discovered it has been stolen and is sitting on the site boburga dot ru Obviously a Russian site, but most articles and text on the site is in Italian. I think there are a lot of hubs from others published there. I've send them a message to take...
by Audrey Selig 12 years ago
There is so much of this going on that it may not be worthwhile to mention. Since I know that this site is not cooperative, I sent my DMCA complaint to Google. My hub is copied word for word with all the lovely photographs and even a link to another similar hub. It probably is my best hub with lots...
by Don Bobbitt 9 years ago
I have several Hubs that other sites have copied, so I decided to go ahead and go through the tedious process of working on the problem. But, when I followed the link to the site. Once at the site, there it was, a cheap and total copy of my article, word for word. But, here is the problem; To leave...
by premsingh 14 years ago
If any content of the hub is being copied by someone and used elsewhere, its not the fault of hubber. This is nice that HP is motivating hubbers to file DMCA to the concerned site and take appropriate action,who is going to waste time to fight with the copyright violators. HP has witnessed...
Copyright © 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of The Arena Platform, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|