jump to last post 1-6 of 6 discussions (9 posts)

Are live links allowed in reader comments?

  1. ShyeAnne profile image91
    ShyeAnneposted 5 years ago

    Are live links allowed in reader comments?

    someone left a comment on one of my hubs.  There was a link to another page in their comment.  Does this indicate spam?

  2. Austinstar profile image88
    Austinstarposted 5 years ago

    They are allowed, but are discouraged. I will delete all links in comments if I feel they are promotional or inappropriate.
    Actually, you have to delete the whole comment. But I also leave another comment explaining why I deleted the person's comment.

    1. ShyeAnne profile image91
      ShyeAnneposted 5 years agoin reply to this

      Thank you Austinstar for clearing that up for me.  I am going to go delete the comment as I believe it contains a promotional link. I can understand why links are discouraged.

  3. peachpurple profile image82
    peachpurpleposted 5 years ago

    I would add links to my hub in the "Answer" section. Some hubbers may ask questions like "what chicken recipe do you like?" Hence, i will add my hub link to answer the question. I don't add them in hubber's post. Just mainly comments and votes.

  4. davidkaluge profile image65
    davidkalugeposted 5 years ago

    Well, what if the link is related to the hub. That is a link a commenter uses to explain his comment. I don't delete links even if its promotional like mentioned here because I don't really see anything wrong with that.

    1. mrpudgy profile image81
      mrpudgyposted 5 years agoin reply to this

      Totally agree with you 110%. As long as it's not a completely ridiculous spam link ya know. Check out my comment. Explains it like butter.

  5. mrpudgy profile image81
    mrpudgyposted 5 years ago

    I don't mind if people do it on my hubs in the comments if it is relevant to the hub and insightful. You can tell if a comment is spam by just reading the comment, or if the link is totally off topic. Then I delete the comment.

    What I think is complete crap and snobby to the max is when some people on this site delete your comment even though it is clearly not spam and the link was one of your posts that either supports your comment or supports the hub being commented on. That's just completely rude if you ask me and I will never link to that author on ANY of my hubs for the rest of my time on hubpages. Interlinking relevant content HELPS hubs and honestly doesn't take away from the other authors hub by having a relevant link. Actually helps in pagerank to be quite honest. I have had numerous authors delete my comments that were like 2 paragraphs long on their hub topic and I put in a link to one of my hubs to support my comment and their hub. Some authors are OK with that, and some just get ridiculous and delete them with a smile. Oh well, some people just don't completely understand what spam is and think that anything with a link in it is automatically spam. So naive... I've been around the block so to speak with interlinking, spam, comments, and links in comments. I run 4 different websites outside of hubpages that are doing not bad. Just my 2 cents on the matter.

    Sorry for such the long comment but I feel very strong about this topic and am actually glad you asked the question. I TOTALLY SUPPORT putting links in comments to your hubs provided they are of high quality, helpful, and directly related to the topic at hand and being discussed. I don't think Hubpages themselves make linking to your hubs in the comments section illegal to say, but spamming definitely is not supported by hubpages or any authors that I know about. I hope that last bit there answered your question a little bit. And if your comment gets deleted and it is a good comment and your link is relevant, don't even waste your time commenting on that authors posts. They are just being rude hubsnobs. Support other hubbers that actually understand the matter of linking and helping brother and sister hubbers out.

    And have a wonderful day!

    1. ShyeAnne profile image91
      ShyeAnneposted 5 years agoin reply to this

      I have no issue with links in my hubs, I wanted to know if it was allowed by the hubpages moderators.  If I see a link in a comment on my hub I wouldn't necessarliy delete it.  I thought I read somewhere that no live links were allowed in comments.

  6. ShyeAnne profile image91
    ShyeAnneposted 5 years ago

    I totally appreciate you all commenting about links in comments.  I have a clear understanding now.  It appears that links are allowed and welcome if relevant.
    Thank you for taking the time to answer my question.
    Make it a great day!

 
working