Why would any HP writer purposely not allow comments on his/her hubs?
I just read two hubs--good ones--by an HP writer I hadn't encountered before, but neither has a Comments section. I wanted to comment on both, and the inability to do so stops me from reading any more of this writer's hubs. Why set a hub for no comments when the feedback can be so helpful and add to the community interaction?
Maybe the writer is new to HubPages and has unwittingly disabled commented for his/her hubs while attempting to change the settings? I cannot think of any other reason why an HP writer wouldn't want comments on their hubs, comments can do no harm really, even the negative ones. Of course comments only earn accolades and gets you more followers within the HP community, they don't give any actual earnings as the traffic has to be from outside the community (as far as I know).
This was my first thought, but I checked length of membership and the writer isn't a newbie. Still, it may be an inadvertent setting. The topics of the two hubs I read weren't controversial at all, so they didn't seem the type to attract trolls.
Jaye..... Have encountered this too and felt the same way. In fact, I was really disappointed as well as curious.
After thinking about it for a while, I could only come up with one guess as to why a writer might do this.
I considered that these writers have one and only one......specific purpose in writing. To roll out hub after hub and not spend any amount of time reading and responding to comments from the community. It would seem to me that they write solely for the purpose of search engines, to inform the general public. Obviously these writers have no desire nor need to receive "feedback" on their work, nor must they enjoy the socialization part of our site.
I realize I could be completely wrong...but like I said, this is my best guess.
It would be extremely interesting to hear straight from these writers what their individual reason is for this.....but they probably have blocked the ability to be emailed as well.
Great question, Jaye !
This is a good point fpherj48-they are writing to write - not necessarily for anyone to enjoy, comment, post a hub in response to their hub, but just to write.
You're right--the email option is not there either. It's a shame because I really enjoyed those hubs, but felt 'cheated' when I couldn't comment. So that writer lost a potential follower.
You are right fpherj48. Didn't think of that one. The writer is probably interested only in traffic generation and earning on this site. So feedbacks don't matter.
I have the same question- I don't understand why you post something if you do not welcome comments. Another question I have is why do people write hubs, and when they get a comment that differs in opinion from the author-they delete or block you from commenting.
Only very few people will delete a comment, just due to a difference of opinion. Any time a comment is deleted it's usually because it was very personal or generally inappropriate. That's pretty rare.
I gave a difference of opinion before, was not disrespectful and my comment was deleted. Them, they sent me a message saying they do not agree and that's why my comment was deleted.
I'm sorry you encountered this. Please know that this incident doesn't describe the usual way things work here. Most hubbers welcome healthy debate or disagreement. Every one is different. Don't let that discourage you pls.
I have found that extremely controversial hubs sometimes have comments disabled. Judging from what I know about some authors here, I think some of them just want to spew their opinion around without having to deal with any negative feedback.
Some people also close questions when they want to have the last word.
RtB...What you have described happens much more often in the Forums as opposed to hubs. Forums can get insane.I learned to avoid them.People get downright nasty.I tend to bite BACK. I'm the schmuck who gets banned.Not the jerk who started it all..
I've actually never taken part in the forums. Sounds like I'm not missing much.
I stay out of the forums on controversial topics (mainly politics and religion) because I don't want my blood pressure spiking! I don't need the aggravation, and there is rarely reasonable discourse on those forums.
Jaye...And a WISE woman you are!.....Anyone who may think "ignorance" is fading, just need read a Forum thread on RELIGION or Politics!! Whoa!
Because the comments are spam, sarcastic, or from a possible hacker or such.
Since the topics of both hubs I read were not controversial, were interesting and well written, they didn't seem the type of hub to attract such unpleasant people to comment. Perhaps the writer was 'bitten once, twice shy" as that old saying goes.
I just realized that I had not read your question through. Now that I have all that I can say is perhaps they mistakenly checked the "Do not show capsule" in Comments box, or accidentally deleted it.
Hey Jaye, I was briefly writing on another site and I wanted to comment on someone's article. I messaged him and asked him why his comments section was closed. He replied that he didn't like the mean comments he would sometimes receive. I guess there was no way to individually monitor comments, like here. Maybe it's just too much grief for some people to receive any mean and/or wacky comments.
Since HP does allow us to monitor comments and delete spam or personal attacks, it would seem helpful (at least, it is to me) to receive comments that don't fit into those narrow categories.
Jaye, I'm open to comments and I guess it is someone's right not to be, but it does take away from the group experience.
I have found the same thing. The hubs were very interesting and I would have loved to have left a comment, but....no comments section....disappointing. I wonder if we are all talking about the same hubber.
Actually Jodah, if you really float around a lot to read work from hubbers for the first time...you'll see that the "closed to comments" is not one or only a few hubbers. U'll also see they are old timers, obviously all done w/ the comment thing?
don't want to answer any comments, dislike to read hurtful comments?
It could be that the person isn't aware that they have omitted that box or deleted that box, or that maybe they don't understand what that box is for so they choose not to use it. Maybe try sending them a fan mail and ask them?
by Dennis L. Page 9 years ago
Why do people write personal fan mail notes, but yet haven't commented on an article?Am I the only one who sits in utter amazement at people who send personal fan mail notes telling you how wonderful, inspiring, creative and informative your writing is, only to find out they have NEVER even written...
by Kylyssa Shay 6 years ago
I understand you've decided to take a cue from Squidoo and you've chosen to make at least one rule unclear on purpose. It's creating more work for everyone and alienating the people who produce the content you sell ads on by either making it clear you don't trust or respect us or that you are so...
by Tessa Schlesinger 4 years ago
I was quite stunned a week or more ago when someone made a statement on one of my hubs that she had commented twice and I had snubbed her by not replying. Her comment had been particularly flattering, and probably because I've spent a lifetime being flattered by others only to find that they wanted...
by Stephanie Henkel 10 years ago
How do you react to hubs with comments disabled?As a hub reader, how important is it to you to be able to comment? Does it frustrate you when you are not allowed to comment on a hub? Will you still vote on that hub? Will you follow an author who disables comments? I wonder if disabling comments...
by Diana Grant 7 years ago
I've received numerous purposely mis-spelled comments from visitors. Should I still approve them?I think they might all be from the same source, as each comment has just one or two wrongly transposed letters in a word, and I'm beginning to think I am looking at some coded message. I have...
by John Coviello 18 months ago
I have an odd situation. When someone comments on one of my Hubs that's on a niche site or on discover.hubpages.com, I can't create a reply comment. It logs me out of the site, and when I try to log into the niche or discover site it sends me back to the old hubpages.com. There's some sort of bug....
Copyright © 2022 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|