I recently noticed that one of my hubs was taking forever to be edited. It had been at the top of google for years or near the top. So I mentioned it on here and now its done so thank you for that. But......
I looked to see how many times it had been edited. 6!
Why? and why are lots of my other hubs edited so many times?
Surely the point of editing is to read through and get rid of the mistakes and just well, edit it!
Does doing it 6 times mean that the first 5 edits were done wrong?
Don't get me wrong, I totally appreciate the fact that we get free editing. Its awesome!
But surely, two points, 1, Editing only takes one time, not 6, and 2, wouldn't it be better to edit it before it goes live?
Sorry for being pedantic lol! Just confused!
The way I see it, is if its good enough for the top page of google, it can't get better can it?
Sometimes editors will close out edits while waiting for photos and in between doing the work. This might cause your article to register multiple edits when they were really just phases of the original edit. That said, we do occasionally edit articles multiple times (though usually not 6 times) as our standards and SEO best practices around growing traffic get more sophisticated.
I agree, Nell! I've had a few articles edited more than once. By the 'bot,' then by 'pro,' then again for something else.
It certainly is confusing, and does feel as if the job is not done thoroughly in the first place.
While we're on the topic, it's very hard to meet 'editing standards' when mixed messages are sent. More than once (nay, many times), I've had an article edited to 'correct' title case, when I actually used their suggested title case website, and followed what came from that, (by copy/paste, no less, so no typos), only to have an editor come along and change it.
So, remembering that change, I follow the editor's preference the next time around, and gee whillikers, surprise, surprise, it gets 'corrected' again to the way it was on the case-setting website!
Confusing? Yes. Aggravating? In the extreme! I'm throwing in the towel, and I'm just going to make my titles the way I was taught back in high school journalism class!
Indeed! It sure seems rather petty to be so nit-picky about title case. Grammar, sure; fix away. Spelling, yes; important. Proper sentence structure and "flow," also important .
But to worry about whether or not words such as "be," " and, "if," or " of" are capitalized or not; please! That alone is not going to determine or detract from the "professionalism" of an article, particularly when the decisions/standards thereon are inconsistent, as I have found them to be!
I had them change my subheads in my latest hub, and they explained they were using APA style (American Psychological Association). I can't figure out why they would use an academic style on a magazine-type website. I prefer the less formal of AP (Associated Press) or Chicago. I think APA is too formal. I was taught to never capitalize prepositions or articles in a title unless it was the first word, both in English grammar and journalism.
The APA style is used here with a tilt to what HP wants, and it varies from editor to editor. I was told that a useful tool is capitalizemytitle.com. It also helps with sentence structure.
I learned articles "be" "if" et al should never be capitalized. But if they are 4 or 5 letter articles, check the link above, they break the APA rule.
"Be" and "if" aren't articles. "Be," "am," "are," "was," and "is," are are short verbs which are usually capitalized because a sentence is not complete without a verb; "if" is a subordinate conjunction, and conjunctions, including "and" and "but" are not usually capped. Older styles limited capitalization to the importance of words in sentences such as nouns, pronouns, verbs, then adjectives, adverbs, etc. Are the grammar police changing the rules now to limit capitalization to word size? That is starting to sound like a free-for-all. Where would one draw the line?
I don't mind using one of the hub tools to make titles in hubs consistent with HP's idiosyncrasies, but in my writings elsewhere, I still tend to follow feature writing style that I learned in journalism classes in college.
Exactly the way learned it. Thanks Ms. BJ.
Yes, the grammar police are out in full force and with many inconsistencies. I wrote that last post in haste and called the wrong words articles. The administration is at war over words with four or more letters in a title.
Jean, I don't think any of them know what a stylebook is. They are great with computers, but that is the way of technology people. They quote APA (wrongly), but they need to sit down and actually study a NON-academic stylebook.
They say when you think it's everyone else, it's you! But I've had so many issues over petty things I feel cranky lately. I haven't written anything in a long time, and I have many creative ideas. I spend all my time here correcting what I mostly wrote in 2011, so the articles can be on niches.
I have 19 hubs left...
That is the exact website I use(d), Jean, based on HP's own recommendation! And STILL they change things! Arrrgggghhh!!!
We have said to use capitalizemytitle.com EXCEPT it doesn't account for all words that are four letters or more and you should capitalize those words in your title, e.g., "with" is often not capitalized in the tool. We try to be consistent and have adopted one style guide, which is APA. We do have our own HubPages style guide as well, but it is constantly being edited and updated since grammatical conventions are dynamic. Here are the specific guidelines for capitalizing titles in APA format:
- Capitalize the first word of the title/heading and of any subtitle/subheading;
- Capitalize all “major” words (nouns, verbs, adjectives, adverbs, and pronouns) in the title/heading, including the second part of hyphenated major words (e.g., Self-Report not Self-report); and
- Capitalize all words of four letters or more.
From: http://blog.apastyle.org/apastyle/2012/ … style.html
I hope you can understand that we are 25 editors and do our very best to be consistent, but grammar nuances are constantly changing and although every HP editor has at least an undergraduate degree, we were trained differently with different style guides. We meet weekly to discuss grammar edits and how we can be more consistent. As you can imagine, it's a huge endeavor to try to retain author voice but meet our style guidelines! Yikes.
Please let me know where we have quoted APA guidelines incorrectly, MizBejabbers, so we can discuss in our weekly meeting! Most of our editors are writers and educators first, and we have trained them on the technology aspect of online writing. Thanks for the interesting conversation!
But this is info we should have been told in the beginning, not after submitting and resubmitting articles getting returned over and over for one word. That's just petty.
And although the editors are concerned with tech issues, we are writers, and the creative process matters more to us. So it's hard when we know we have a well written piece and it gets trashed or takes a month to get on a niche site. It alienates writers.
I hate to come back and be pedantic, but when an article is 'edited' and the word 'How' is changed for 'Hot' in the title I just have to sigh....! As in.....Hot to clean a smelly couch!! Oh and the photos were all taken out to. Maybe it was the automatic one? but Hot? really?
by Haley 6 years ago
Blergh, so I'm going back to my original hubs that are usually a single picture with a block of text and editing them so that they are prettier, longer, and hopefully seen as more Hubpage's friendly.It just seems like it takes forever to revamp them. Does anyone have any tricks to help the process...
by Kristin Kaldahl 5 months ago
I have 37 articles on PetHpful that are undergoing editing....AGAIN. This happens a lot. I'm expected to go into each article, read it, fix the mistakes the editors put into my articles, and repost the articles. I have other writing projects (book, book trailer) pending for my agent, and I don't...
by Lisa Vollrath 3 weeks ago
So, yesterday, I got an email saying one of my articles had been edited: a recipe that's been posted since 2017. I'm not sure it really needed editing, since most of what was done was superficial. I checked it over, hated about half of the changes, and edited the article to correct some of the...
by Sherry Venegas 2 years ago
I am working on an article and the editor of the niche has asked me to "Please update the subtitles to APA title case".Does that mean all words are capitals? Which words are not to be capitalized? I could use this information for all my Hubs. Thanks, Sherry
by Stacie L 5 months ago
I'm wondering if my best articles that are being copied can still be claimed as copied if the editors are making drastic changes to it.It really isn't the same article that the thieves took so filing a DMCA may be useless. BTW,most of my articles are on private blogger or websites without Google...
by Eugene Brennan 10 days ago
I have a fairly old article which doesn't rank for the first four words from it's title in the first 130 SERP results ("What causes electric shocks"), however there are no other articles with those words at the beginning of the title. Ubersuggest says that there's low competition for the...
Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|