Anyone here doing better than last year? The screenshot I posted tells the story. What's the problem?
Yup, Traffic and earnings dropped.
I've been aware for some time that my traffic has been dropping. However, to be fair, I've been hesitant about continuing to write here because I thought without Paul here, in the medium to long term, things will not be in favour of writers here.
So far I'm up 31% year to date versus a year ago. But the gap has steadily become more narrow since January. April is up only 6%.
So the trend is not good.
I am. Even my numbers from January are higher, but I do think this is due to the popularity of my topic.
Where do you get these graphs? I can't see something like that on hp.
Ah. Thanks. I wondered. I've finally gone to set mine up
I've always wondered, though, why Google has different numbers to hubpages, and even hubpages has contradictory information with regard to how many people are reading one's work.
Interesting. I did an Analytics chart January 2018 to April 2019 for HP. Sure enough, traffic dropped about a third. Then I did an Analytics chart of my website traffic over the same period. That traffic went up the same amount that HP traffic had gone down.This was because of all the hubs that were thrown off or not allowed on the HP niche sites and were thus transferred to my website. If all those fracas's hadn't happened, I'd be earning double here now. HP needs to be more SEO oriented and less "quality" oriented. And HP wouldn't believe some of the short articles on my website that get daily traffic. In fact, I've got some that are downright idiotic, but daily traffic they get, day in and day out. Give the reader what they want.
I'm driving right now, but definitely will respond. I agree
Overall down 20%, but the top performers on Dengarden are doing pretty much the same or better than last year. Caloriebee is down 50% compared to last year and 75% compared to the year before.
Yeah, there was a memorial service for all things recipe around the same time they did one for all things medical.
Dengarden traffic is way up for me. My earnings haven't increased comparably, though. I'm earning more but not as much as I would expect with my current traffic.
I was seeing better traffic than last year until about mid March. Not sure what happened around that time whether it was Google, HP, or the mysteries that are writing online, but I've seen drops in traffic since then and it's only trending downward.
I wasn't really monitoring it, just noticing it on hp stats page and the weekly newsletter. However, checking analytics now, it shows a drop of just over 13% for April.
I've had low traffic all year. After the holidays it's expected, but I am making a third of what I was a year ago. It's not even worth it to me to write anything new.
Curious. Why you think that is. I've been watching my traffic go down for about four months now. I've also noticed that articles which were previously number one on Google are now number four.
I'm not really sure. The CPM's are low. But I was doing better and last year was making more each month, so began writing a few articles again. I didn't care if it was lower in January, advertisers always spend during the holidays. But after January, I hit such lows that I hadn't seen in two years, and this month made less than I did two years ago. I have a lot of articles on Exemplore, but if I look at the analytics, people are on them. Not in the larger numbers they were, but there. Also, the articles I have on Owlcation remain popular. So I don't know. I blame it on the merger.
Oh, I'm absolutely sure it's the merger. I also expect Paul Edmonton to leave within 24 months. And then we're on our own. I'm just trying to figure if the drop in viewsing is a result of less attetion paid to SEO by Hubpages or whether Maven is paying us less in CPM or a combination of the two.I know my page ranks for my various articles have fallen for the first time in years.
Actually, CPMs have increased due to the Maven merger and HP SEO is the best it ever was. There are things that can be improved, but it was never as good as it is now. It's just that the search algorithms are changing.
Maybe it's the result of lower overall traffic, which may boost CPMs.
Either way, we have much more to worry about with the health of Maven / HP as a company than we do with average CPMs or average Amazon sales.
Any public company that doesn't report its earnings to the public for nearly a year is a reason for concern.
"Any public company that doesn't report its earnings to the public for nearly a year is a reason for concern."
This has been mentioned before. It would be good to get a response from HP about this.
Companies don't usually post results for 'nearly a year'. Find out when the company's year end is. In the UK that can vary, although the majority are in line with the fiscal year end, 5th April. However, accounts aren't generally posted for several weeks, even months after year end.
Yup, as in the reply by gerimcclym this has been pointed out before, probably by you.
51% difference here. Traffic was outrageously good this time last year (best ever for me) but it is disappointing when it tumbles back down.
Wow, that's a big chunk. I guess it's the niche site that was hit, I see similar drops on my Caloriebee hubs.
What niche site/s do you think were hit? I only have one article somewhat maintaining traffic and that's on Owlcation. But that article is also ending a season high (Lent/Easter), so I'm not surprised to see it lose a little traffic. It was particularily popular this year for some reason.
Pethelpful, Delishably, and Wehavekids articles that are generally doing well have dropped like a rock as have some of my other Owlcation articles. I haven't noticed any one site (at least for me personally) that is doing better than any other one. Delishably has hit me the hardest though. I was getting upwards of 400+views a day with multiple Amazon sales and now I'm just barely making 100 views and zero Amazon sales.
CPM's are down from this time last year as well, so I'll barely make what I made last year at this time. It's been tending downward all year though, so I'm not surprised to see it continue on this trend. I've barely been around lately, and like Jean I have no desire to write as nothing I do seems to make a difference any more.
Health sites seem to have lost traffic. Surprising about Pethelpful.
Just a speculation about pethelpful, me thinks the video platforms are taking away their traffic.
That's what happened to one of my top performers that is seeing a slight drop on Dengarden so I wouldn't be surprised. A video result has the snippet. One that is totally useless though. People watching it may not know, that's a sad fact.
Copying to video has now become such a "thing" that I check each new hub on the SERPs after about a week and try to identify any youtube copies. If they exist, Google is good at taking them down. (At least so far.)
The videos seem to get more page views than my written word. Instead of checking for copies of your article, which will probably rank far below the original, I think it is a much better use of your time to look at youtube and try to identify copies of what you have written.
Surprising, but as you are well aware you cannot judge an entire websites performance on one persons article.
Popularity of some math articles on Dengarden compensated for an overall drop in traffic to Dengarden guides since last year. CPM pretty much the same as this time last year and earnings up.
Maths on Owlcation you mean? Or do you have some Gardening guides on Dengarden?
Yes on Owlcation, sorry. Although math for gardeners could be an idea. Like how to bisect a flower bed or draw tangents to flower beds. Now you've got me thinking
My earnings are pretty much the same as last year. A little disappointing, as I've done a lot of work over the past 12 months, but no huge drops like others are reporting in this thread.
I try to be diverse, and if one topic area or style of hub goes down, I focus on another.
I haven't thought about it, but looked and roughly 40% less between 4/1/18 - 4/27/18 and this month.
Oddly, I feel optimistic about May; I have no idea why.
The summer was good for me last year, so let's hope for the best.
My views have been pretty steady over the past year. Income actually increased, but mainly due to more Amazon sales. Roughly half my monthly revenue is from Amazon.
I wonder if those of you who noticed a drop in views might be mostly on HubPages. In my case, all my hubs are on niche sites, and I think that makes all the difference. I think it’s pretty much in agreement that hubs on the home site don’t do well.
Finally, every one of my articles is on a niche site. They are mostly on Exemplore or Owlcation, but I have one or two on many other niches too. So I was happy to have upgraded so many articles and was doing great at the end of last year, then everything dropped like a stone! I wrote about four new articles at the beginning of the year, and they are beginning to get noticed now. So I don't know what to do. I will make less this month than I did in two years. Pretty depressing.
Jean, my hubs are scattered over 17 niche sites. As for the two you mentioned, my hubs on Exemplore are holding steady, but I’ve noticed a downward trend with views on Owlcation.
Is that because of the Easter vacation Glenn and views from students? Mine dropped in the last two weeks, but views were steadily increasing before that.
Yep, I am mostly on WeHaveKids and have had a big drop in traffic since last year.
There was a Google update in late March but my traffic had dropped before that I think, just dropped again afterwards!
This seems to be pessimism day around here. Figured I might as well add my usual rant.
Hub ad earnings up by 50% from last April. But I have written quite a few articles over the last 12 months.
However, Amazon down by 50%. And it's been like that for me since HP changed the way they calculated the earnings. Still plenty of sales but teeny commissions.
It's weird that you are seeing Amazon changes after the change. It should not differ unless you were so damn lucky that all the big commissions were happening on your share of clicks.
Great news on the 50% increase.
I am seeing the same problem regarding Amazon on my main account, and like you said it appears to have started when HP changed the way they calculate the earnings. It has gotten much worse over the past few months.
Very discouraging. All I can think to do is update old articles and hope it makes a difference somehow.
Bev, are you sure your comparing things correctly? You say your Amazon earnings are down 50%. Under the old method, you were paid full 100% of the residuals on only 60% of the impressions. Now you get paid 60%, but you get that on ALL the sales. So if you are looking at the amount you get per sale, it would look like you’re only getting half (actually 60%). But in reality you’re getting that on roughly twice the sales.
To put that another way, you are now seeing all the sales in your report, and sharing that 60/40 with HubPages. Under the old method you only saw your 60% share of the sales. The other 40% that went to HubPages never appeared in your report.
When this first started, I noticed in the forums that some people misunderstood it and thought their commission was cut in half. It wasn’t.
I must have been really unlucky that virtually all my sales went to Hubpages. How did it work previously? Either that, or my sales have genuinly picked up as a result of some other factor.
Tess, that’s how it worked previously. You could have been unlucky with sales occurring during HP's 40% impressions. Now it’s balanced under the new method since you will never miss an honest sale.
I call it an “honest sale” because Amazon has an algorithm that detects if your friends repeatedly click through your affiliate link to place orders. Brandon explained that for you.
I'm curious as to why they would worry if some people bought from you repeatedly. Why is that an issue? Also, it would have hardly been detectable. I'm not talking massive numbers of sales over a long period of time. I'm talking maybe 6 or 7 sales in total over a 3 or 4 month period. How would Amazon detect that. I just asked a few friends to use links in my articles to buy some stuff, and they did. I never saw any of those sales register.
I also did that beause I have been earning maybe a $1 or $2 per month for years. Now it's 5 to 8 times that.
So, sorry, you can't take a three or fourmonth period out of 4 years (for half a dozen sales) and say that is why I haven't seen the sales. Sorry, I don't believe that.
If a certain person buys from Amazon occasionally and the majority of the sales are through a certain affiliate tag it is known that the person is doing this intentionally.
Also, this is not allowed because the affiliate program is meant to bring customers to Amazon and not take away commissions from people who would have bought from them anyway.
I understand how it works, Glen. I am comparing this month's figures with the same time last year. However, since the changeover, my Amazon has fallen from $200 per month to less than $100. It's quite obvious to see in the stats.
I started a thread when it happened and was told that I was wrong, that it couldn't have impacted my numbers. I might well be wrong, but from that very day, my commissions plummeted.
Edit: Just to reiterate, the number of sales hasn't fallen, in fact, they've increased (obviously because the stats show all the sales). It's the actual commissions which are teeny. I used to get quite regular big sales... $30, $40 earnings sometimes, but now.... cents or a dollar. So, perhaps the changeover occurred with a sudden change in the buying habits of my readers?
Same here. I see more sales and more clicks thanks to the new way it is calculated, but the number of higher-value sales and their corresponding commissions has dropped significantly over the past year.
It makes no sense.
Amazon commissions did drop on many categories too. Could play a role maybe? But as you say, nothing you can do about it
Interestingly, it always frustrated me that I seldom earned anything on Amazon, but friends always said they bought. I assumed that my friends must have continually bought during the time that it was HP share. For the past few months, my Amazon earnings have gone from about $1 a month to between $10 to $15per month. Not much. But quite a change.
I've given up on HP regarding Amazon, but I know others have done well; so I know the problem is me or my topics.
What with the latest Google adventure, I might try to see what I can do with Amazon on my website. There's various platform restrictions, but still might be able to come up with something.
Do you understand what Google has done? I have tried to figure it out, but I haven't been able to do so. Why would Google send traffic to Amazon when they were competitors at one point? I don't understand.
Google seems benign to me in so many respects. If Google perceives a competitor's contribution superior to their own, they will serve it right up at the top of the list.
Amazon figures this out. If someone has bought from the same affiliate over and over the commissions are ignored because of friends buying, just like in your case.
I don't understand. What has it to do with who buys something? Surely it doesn't matter? It wasn't something that happened every day for years. It would be a friend using a link on an article twice in a year. And because I had quite a high following for a while, That might have translated to two or three sales a month, and I never ever saw any of it. I just never saw a single one of those sales.
I just thought it was me. For some reason mine has gone down too.
by Liz Elias 14 months ago
I'm extremely under-impressed since the **Maven** takeover. Yes, I regard it as a hostile takeover, and not a friendly merger!My earnings and traffic are WAY, WAY DOWN compared to last year at this same time, when they were way, way UP!!While I am still making payout each month, I am seeing a...
by Eugene Brennan 13 months ago
I don't know whether the rumoured ongoing algorithm update over the last week has anything to do with it, but traffic on this article has returned to September levels.
by Poppy 10 months ago
It's disheartening to work so hard only to see your earnings drop to lowest than they've been in a long time. For the past two days, they've been about half what I was earning daily in 2017 and even lower than they were in January! Has this happened to anyone else and will it pick up soon?
by Rob Hampton 9 months ago
My traffic is way down this year, and even worse than two years ago. I'm feeling a little uneasy about the whole Maven takeover thing and am wondering if I should even bother putting my time and effort into writing more articles. Gut instinct tells me HP days are numbered. I really hope I'm wrong.
by Don Bobbitt 13 days ago
What did I do to make Google, or maybe Maven mad at me? This Time? I went from signifiant Android business to ZERO two weeks ago. Yeah, that's what I said, ZERO! )*&*&$^^&*&^*&^
by Rob Hampton 8 months ago
This year my traffic is lower than last, but Amazon sales are through the roof, making up for and then some for lack of traffic. Averaging near $20/day the last few weeks in Amazon earnings alone. There has been a huge uptick with Amazon
Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|