Anyone have any comments on article spinners ?
i know they are evil -
and i would never spin someone else's article, but i have thought about the possibility of spinning one of my own. I have not thought that through yet.
And there are two more things to be say about them ..
since they are about, and sometimes you get the impression they are everywhere, one can only suppose that unscrupulous people are coming to hub pages to source articles, and then going away to spin them on other sites, while honest people are loosing out. Is there anyway to protect against them ?
The other thing to note - is that this is the one of the ways Mr. Google is imperfect. Not being able to recognize a spun article, which although they change in syntax, i believe they remain similar in structure, and maybe in word count too. But the word count thing can easily be changed.
Anyone have any comments in the light the above ?
unscrupulous people, and the " imperfect Google ? "
I realize that just talking about it might in fact encourage some to think about doing it - and this is a worry. On the other hand i believe issues need to be out in the open.
Meanwhile i'll go seek out other hubs on the subject. I remember seeing a few headlines but i did not book mark them at the time.
Free article spinning softwares are available in the Internet an you can try yourself. No meaningful content can be created through spinning. The software would put some synonyms for the actual words and the result will be a meaningless and sometimes absurd and laughable passage. It cnnot be published on any site like Hubpages. I think AdSense will not approve it for spam.
good news - they dont work. Ive seen one that is supposed to, but that could be spin ! But if they don't work thats great.
good thread here for anyone interested in comments on article spinners and getting traffic
I recently joined a pro link building program that includes free access to an article spinner. I've always avoided them in the past because of having seen the nonsensical results, but I've actually found that it is possible to get reasonable results if are willing to put a bit of thought into it.
I had always assumed that article spinners automatically replaced words, but the one I am now using is a manual one where you highlight a word or phrase, click a button, and then type in an alternative. I can quite easily get a load of articles with at least 60-70% rewrite that might be a little bit clumsy but make complete sense and wouldn't seem obviously spun to a reader.
Spinning someone else's article is a completely different thing - that is theft - but I don't see anything wrong with spinning your own articles to submit to directories and so on.
What kephrira said is right. Manual spinning can be used to rewrite our own articles. But again, if you are good at language, I feel, rewriting ourselves might be easier and more original and natural.
Actually rewriting an article yourself is definitely better, and I've done that a few times before, but it would take a long time and be very boring indeed to write 10-15 different versions of an article.
I do quite well and have not yet fallen into the trap of spinners.
If I put my mind to it I can put out 20 or 30 articles a day with all of them being a rewrite of the first one.
This can get boring but I think of it as a part of what I need to do to survive with my online income.
The thing is even if you wrote one article a day you would have 365 articles at the end of the year. That is more than most people will ever write.
I try and stay with an average of 5 a day and hopefully never fall into the trap of spinning.
yes Dale and i suspect a spinner may take as long as long as a rewrite - if you want to fix what it does
but Kephrira's post above counters that, and he's actually tried one. On his own articles of course.
It doesn't take as long as rewriting. As an example, if you have a three word sentence and you put in an alternative to each of those words in a spinner, you don't just get 2 alternatives, because the spinner can change just the first word, or the second word, or the third, or the first two, or the last two, or the first and third. So in just a little over the time it takes to write 2 versions of any article you can get 10+ with high rewrite and many more with lower levels of rewrite if you want them.
I'm just going to throw it out there: if you really need the same article rewritten a 100 times, you can pay a non-native English speaker like 2 dollars per article and still get something a thousand times more coherent and useful than the average spun article.
but what about the better than average article spinner ?
Ive read most article spinners are pretty useless and do spit out drivel, but there are supposed to be pretty good ones too.
Lee, article directories can be a useful source of links, but they just aren't worth $2 per article, so I think you would make a massive loss like that. Also, as I said, you can make completely coherent articles if you make an effort. Just because some people who use them don't really care and throw out lots of drivel, doesn't mean everyone does.
If you want to make alot of money online, the second most important thing you will have to learn to do is write compelling marketing copy for both search engines and people. If you are capable of speaking and writing in American English, then write your own copy and keep writing it, until you are very good at it.
Spinners might make for a lot of copy but are a poor subsitution for the real thing.
G is spending a lot of money on learning what real language is and how to spot spinners and spam.
If you are going to listen to one person here listen to Nelle. She backs up what she says.
Great advice Nelle
Nelle, of course you need to be able to write well. And if I write an article I do make an effort to write well and then publish it somewhere like hubpages or one of my websites.
But being able to then have a few different versions of that original article to publish elsewhere with backlinks to the original article is something that I am finding very useful and although I have only been doing it for a couple of weeks I am already getting more traffic.
interesting to know G is working on the problem, as one would hope and expect
very sensible .. its about making best use of our own work ( not stolen ) and doing it efficiently. it's just getting a little more mileage out of a great beginner article you have spent a lot of time on
I use spinners all the time. As I once mentioned already more than one of my hubs are spun copy. The trick is to do a quality spin template. It's a damn hard work and not something one would do for say 20 articles. Once you do it, you use it to the full extent.
Hi Misha, good to have a bit of backup on this especially from someone I know to be successful.
thanks for that Misha ..
" quality " is the operative word .. there are " quality " spun articles that have extra work and finesse put on them ..and low quality rubbish spin.
" not all spins are equal ! "
so its just another tool to help along the way, with fix ups by a real person.
Just a question here - I don't have any other websites or blogs or anything, just HP, and I don't see any need for rewriting the same article (for myself, I mean) at this time. But, if I wanted to, couldn't I just copy the article to a word-processor and use the Find and Replace commands? Isn't that essentially what a spinner does?
I can see how they could be useful to someone under some circumstances, but the person using them needs to know the language well enough to recognize ridiculous wording when he sees it. It's obvious a lot of people who have those ridiculous Hubs didn't write the thing the first time around either (and that's what, maybe, makes spinners seem more offensive than they really ought to).
I gotta level with you , I am so technologically challenged I had never heard of this.
no prob's Tony ..we all started that way ..you will learn. Hang on, ive just noticed youv'e written 1200 posts and 96 hubs. So your not a newbie by an means ! So you mean your new to the idea of article spinners. Ok. So this thread might be useful, and you'll find others on the subject.
by Cindy Murdoch 9 years ago
As I read and try to learn about the internet, I keep running across people talking about content spinners. Isn't the content that they create considered duplicate content? Or not? Does anyone use them for any other applications? Are there good applications for them? I'm curious on what everyone...
by oderog 11 years ago
Any free article spinner that you can recommend. I would appreciate
by Robert P 6 years ago
I have been hub hopping lately and I am disgusted with the incoherent garbage that I am coming across - nothing but poorly translated articles of about 400 words, usually without even any formatting. I would say that more than half of the articles I randomly encounter are clearly nothing but spun...
by Theresa Kennedy 9 years ago
I'm looking for a sentence or two that are obviously spun from an article spinner program. I've been told they are easy to pick out, but want a few solid examples please.
by Trsmd 10 years ago
Recently I came to visit these profiles of our fellow hubbers.Hubber-2009 and Kmachine..http://hubpages.com/profile/kmachinehttp://hubpages.com/profile/hubber-2009Their profile images looks like same and I think that they may be the same person..What is your opinion..?
by Misbah 18 hours ago
Sadly, from the time I have joined HP. I have seen a man who is continuously spreading fake news through his so-called good articles. I have ignored his articles a lot of times. but seeing him targeting every now and then is not acceptable for me and I am sure it is not acceptable for all those...
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|