Is it only me, or are there others who think that it should be a common courtesy to reply to comments made to a hub. I always reply to comments made by my followers and others, and people who I follow do the same. I have noticed however, that some hubbers have comments left on their page, and they don't acknowledge the comment with a reply. I think a reply not only shows sincere interest in the comment, but further shows appreciation to the perosn who left the comment.
What are your thoughts? Is this too much...over-bearing even?
I would actually rather see people discuss my topics among themselves, although if something I wrote seems to be misunderstood by someone, I'll clarify it, although that's only happened one time.
Are you saying that you simply read the comments, and have only replied once to clear a misunderstanding?
...humph. I guess what works is what works. There is no wrong or right, just differences of opinion.
You are all talented and successful writers. That's why you guys are 90's and 100's, AND your followers adore you anyway!
Nah, I've replied more than once actually...I do talk occasionally...LOL. I guess I just enjoy the commenting more when other people are talking...LOL. Maybe I just run out of words after writing the hubs...LOL j/k
I try to reply to all of my comments, but sometimes, I simply don't have time.
Depends. I get ten or more comments a day and some of my hubs have fifty or more comments. If it's just a generic 'Thanks for this hub, it helped' I usually don't reply.
I agree with WryLit. Sometimes, (I'm sorry to say), it truly depends on if I have the time. For example, one day might go by where I only receive two comments, so will I reply - Sure. However, if I just worked ten hours, and I come home to ten new comments, I just don't have the time to reply to all. Also, some comments are more personal and even ask for a response, while others I've received are as simple as "Nice hub."
I take Kirsten and Wrylilt's policy even farther.
Starting recently, if a comment is just a generic "Great hub!" sort of thing, I delete it.
No offense meant to the people who leave such things - I'm sure some of of them genuinely mean it and are just being friendly and polite. However, enough others are just looking to attract attention to themselves and are too lazy to think of anything useful to say.
So, my new rule is that a comment needs to ask an appropriate question, or be critical, useful or at least entertaining. If it is just an empty, fawning, "Nice hub" equivalent, I am deleting it - no bad feelings, but it's going.
The ones that survive will almost always get a reply.
I used to work for a bank, and my clients each, and of course, had different balances in their accounts. Each balance maintained was a significant amount to that client.
One day a client, suggested that he should receive preferential treatment because of his balance. I told him that everyone's balance was significant, I can't justify treating the client who has $500.00 dollars differently than the client with $50,000.00. That's like saying that because you have less, you're not as important.
I think of the same when it relates to comments. Everyone is as important as the next and so on. For me, a simple "Nice Hub" would get a simple "Thank You".
Pcunix, I know you're a busy dude, you're like a Hub Guru! People gravitate towards you, not only for your keen abilities, but you have a great sense of humor!
This forum post has transcended into something far greater than I imagined, but still I am grateful to have communicated with so many people.
So, one general reply "Thanks to everyone for your comments and interest..." wouldn't suffice, or responding to say (5) comments a day?
Perhaps I'm old school. Please don't misunderstand, I'm not being argumentative, but I think any comment, no matter the number or type of comment is worthy of a reply.
WryLit and KristenGrace, thank you kindly for your input. I was curious and your responses have helped to satisfy my curiosity.
I understand your position. And yes, I have done that general reply to a group before. I don't see anything wrong with that.
So if one has hundreds of articles with many comments each day, a hubber should reply to all of them? Get real!
That's right Randy Godwin, it's no different than customer service. The people who comment are your clients and you are the propreitor.
I'm not suggesting that anyone does this, I do however think that's it's a reasonable idea. While the responses, and especially yours suggest that it's not practical, it is possible.
The time you took to respond to my post, could have been time to submit one general thank you to your audience....boohyaaah!
I am a proponent for communication, good bad or indifferent!
I thank you Randy Godwin for your reply.
I'm not sure if I'd feel the same way when I do have a few dozen hubs with multiple comments a day. But I always thank them for leaving a comment. And I usually check back on comments I leave on other hubbers. If they do reply to comments (doesn't have to be mine) I'm more likely to comment on more of their hubs.
I just said comments alot in this post.
evvy_09 that's okay...about saying comment alot, that's what this post is about! I've been outnumbered here, but that's okay, I was simply sharing my opinion. I follow a couple of veteran hubbers, who somehow find the time...no make the time to comment to everyone. I am so marveled by that, and appreciate them even more for just saying a few kind words.
I've worked in business management nearly my entire life, and so in my mind it's just what you do, even on a personal level.
Thanks for your reply....by the way, love your profile picture!!!
When you have a large number of hubs with plenty of comments getting posted everyday, replying to them will become a full day job!. You won't have time for anything else.
It seems I'm the alone on this one. Perhaps I shouldn't relate it to being customer oriented.
It really depends on how you use Hubpages, but in general, I don't think that the people leaving you comments are your customers. They're more like your coworkers. People on Hubpages aren't going to be the people that buy stuff from you. That's going to come from the people who find your page via Google search.
I don't really think that every comment needs a reply. Unless I ask a question, I don't really expect a reply. I'll reply when it makes sense to, but I generally don't think a reply like "thanks for leaving a comment" is very productive. I'm more likely to go visit one of their pages and leave a comment over there.
I don't get it....I worked with people who treated their clients like cream and their co-workers like crap. My employees were (yes were...disabled mother...long story) always expected to manage themselves in their positions like they were the client. This brought greater value, and an even better interaction with others, for they worked with a reminder that when they leave their jobs, they are now somebody's client, whether it's the gas station, the dollar or liquor store...well, maybe not the liquor store.
By no means am I suggesting that not replying to a comment is treating someone crappy, oh no...unh...unh. Please don't misunderstand I just think, and, using your analogy of client vs. co-worker, that the source is irrelevant.
This subject is obviously a matter of preference, and that's quite alright. I've ignited a firestorm of a topic....I'm about to dial 9-1-1!!
Perhaps it's just a matter of people's personality types.
I'm generally not a chatty person. If I have something of substance to say, I'll say it; otherwise I'm more of a quiet person.
I agree that you don't treat your co-workers like crap. In addition to not being nice, it doesn't make good business sense either.
Probably the people that like to leave comments responding to everything are more talkative in real life too. That's just a hunch. I could be wrong.
its nice to reply to comments, but when you have a lot of hubs (say about 200 hubs), it becomes pretty difficult to keep up. I guess at the initial stage it will be good and then over time your followers know you will always respond and would understand if you dont that you are burdened with work. Welcome to hubpages, I see you are new.
Yeah...I'm new xixi12! BUT in my personal life I interact and interface with many many people...nuth'n sleazy though!
It just seemed like a good idea....gone down the tubes! I follow some people who have hundreds of hubs, followers and comments, who reply to everyone. Sure, they can't reply to them all in a day, or two...three, but they do, somehow...some way. Quite honestly I've seen this same pattern with people who only have a few hubs...not call'n anyone out.
It seems that I generated quite a conversation...I won't do this again!
Thanks for welcoming me xixi12...that was very nice of you!
Well, I know there are many Hubbers who receive so many comments, it would be impossible to reply to all of them. Maddie Ruud of HubPages Staff said on one Forum Thread that just approving comments on her Hubs was a big job, let alone replying to them.
I've seen a lot of Celebrity Fan Sites where there is a place for fans to place comments, and they're always replied to, but I'm more than certain the celebrity her/himself does not answer personally, even if it would appear so. The Jackie Collins Fan Site is a good example, but most Hubbers don't have the same resources as Jackie Collins does. Anyway, this tells me that replying is probably good practice.
Then again, Hubs are quite different to a Fan Site ...
So far, I've been able to reply to all comments and have enjoyed doing so, but there could come a time when I can't. Maybe I'd put a notice above the comments box to thank readers and let them know I won't be replying, which I think is better than replying to some but not others. Or, I'd take away the comment's box altogether; end of problem.
I hope you will reply to my comments Camlo...I love hearing from you!
A reply to a comment makes you feel connected somehow. Today I updated my hub on Creating a HubPage, and I marveled at how I've met people from Canada to Germany (You're Germany).
A reply, and obviously I stand alone (no woman is an island...teehee) is a way of keeping an open dialogue and showing appreciation for those who not only took time to read your hub, but to leave a comment as well.
I am most certainly not trying to change anyone's mind or start a campaign even, I simply think it's a great gesture, one that perhaps may be a little undervalued. When I joined HubPages, you were one of the first people to reach out to me. I can't fully express how much that meant and still means!
That is actually a great idea, you could say that you will try to answer new questions when possible but cannot give a personal reply to every comment, but you will be reading them. I can see that working quite well actually. I have a hub that gets comments from time to time from someone with the same injury as I suffered last year, often they respond to something said in the comments not the hub itself! The relevant back and forth that happens seems to really do a lot for that hub so I do try to respond to every comment there (they tend to be from people with the same injury as I had). On other hubs that have less chance for good back and forth I may try this on. I do find that by responding to questions or fun comments seems to encourage more comments (a good thing that).
That's right kirstenblog, it is encouraging and then some. The comment field is a non-verbal prompt to initiate a course of action. That action is a comment, and when it's left dangling like a participle, then the only course of action to correct is a reply.
I went to a store one day, and the clerk who waited on me uttered, not one word. Before I left his register, I said "Thank You!", and he said "You're Welcome!". I then said, "I'm sorry, Thank You is what you should have said to me!"
I reply steadily. I reply a lots of comments at a time but I surely do.
saleheensblog is da' house!!!! Now that's what I'm talking about!
One of my motto's is "Ain't Nuth'n To It But To Do It!"
Yah, to reply is a courtesy. If you have tons of comments you can just make a reply after every 10 comments mentioning everyone's name.
A comment not only appropriate you but also it add SEO value to your hubs. So, a reply is not only to recognize the love but also to refresh your content and make it look new to search engines all the time.
Yeah I've seen that, where there's a general reply to a group, and then another reply to another group. That works too, because it's still sumth'n.
I didn't know about the SEO value! Wow saleheensblog you're sharp, smart and my new best friend!!!
New comment> New content> New keywords > Google Happy
Your Reply> New Content> New Keywords > Another backlink to your Profile >Google Happy.
Your awesomeness is only exceeded by even more awesomeness!!!
thanks for the great complement. I am only learning everyday. BTW I sent you a mail.
I reply to all followers who comment especially those asking questions and help reqarding the topic... as much as possible too, I will respond to all comments even if they just say thanks or generic something.... it's not the comment but the effort and letting you know that someone has read your hub... it's a different story if you have plenty of followers and has too many comments and everyday, having no time is out of the question.....
Maria Cecilia, it is the effort that matters and makes the difference. When I read replies to my comments. I chuckle, I smile, I feel all warm and fuzzy inside . I can't imagine that I'm the only person who gets a big kick out of a reply.
I feel the same imatellmuva, I don't want to think that I am this appreciative because I seldom recieved comments in my hubs, well if that is so still I will be very thankful especially to those who said thanks to your hub..
When someone doesn't reply, it doesn't mean that they aren't grateful for a comment. They may smile, say an "aww shucks" in their head, or do a little dance, but it's the reply that let's the reader know.
I said I wasn't going to push this, but I read through my replies and it sounds like I am....call me FIESTY!!!
I think replying to comments on your hub is great. It shows that you didn't just throw the article out there and forget it. I will make it a point to reply to comments no matter how many I get. Might be one reply to several but it will get done.
I wonder if it will ever become a problem for me
While I am fairly new to HubPages, and I haven't reached the 100 or more comments a day status, I would reply to everyone, given the person that I am.
Even if it's one big shout out, "A special Thank You to everyone for your interest in my hub. Your comments and opinions are very much appreciated!"
While I have not had a lot of comments directly on HubPages, I receive an overwhelming number of comments on my Facebook page, and I reply to everybody. I want people to personally know that they are important to me, and are appreciated. What other way is there to do that than reply?
I think it depends on the quality of the comment. I don't like to encourage useless comments by leaving a reply. In general, I only like to reply to a comment if it provides additional quality information to the hub or provides something useful to the reader. My "thank you" to the commenter usually comes in the form of a return comment on one of their hubs that I find interesting.
hmmmm lender3212000....so, you may not reply to a comment, but will comment on a hub. Could the comment have been a reply? ...and you still squeeze in a comment on another hub?
Have you ever, in your wonderful life, sent a message to someone who didn't reply...then think ohmygawsh...did sumth'n happen to em', are they all right? Okay that might be a stretch here, but the point is...I don't even know anymore...the room is spinn'n!
Lender this forum post is getting so deep, I need a ladder!!
To go deeper you don't need a ladder. You have to jump down or use a rope or use an escalator or anything that help to go downward.
Yes I do need a ladder! I have to use it to climb down into the hole that I dug!!!
...out of the hole that I dug!!! :rollseyes:
Oxygen and a sandwich...I'm going to be down here for a while...the ladder broke!
Oh saleheen...you got jokes!! Clever...very clever!!
you never told me that you don't get poor joke
I guess this is a picture of someone who was depleted of oxygen or had too much!
It's really me before make-up...how could you have possibly known??
What were your keyword searches? Ugly-As-Crap-In-The-Morning?
I try to reply to all serious comments but do understand how it could be a burden for those who have many hubs. Nothing is written in stone about comments nor how to handle them. It is a personal choice, as it should be.
You're absolutely right. It is a personal choice. I don't want anyone to think I was trying to sway their opinion...it may appear so! I've learned a lot, heard many different view points, and gained some new friends...believe it or not. All in all this was healthy conversation...well, after I took (2) advils.
I want to be a 100 like you some day.
Glad you see the different viewpoints here. And welcome to HP!
Getting a 100 profile score is not that difficult. Keeping it there is the hard part. LOL!
I try very hard to respond to all comments in a timely fashion ie; 1 day. I don't have an outside job like most so I am a bit more fortunate to be able to do this. On one Hub I have been blasted and have received over 300 comments, that one can get a bit tricky. Depending on how many I get I may answer them all in one comment, separating the names and comments to each one.
The only comments I delete are the spam comments. Sometimes I recognize it as being spam (telling the person who entered it 'no spam' please). Do my best in answering each comment. I have a tendency to look for reply's to my comments as well. It's just an acknowledgment from the writer that I was there.
I try to reply to virtually all comments unless they really contribute nothing to the Hub. It would be rare for anyone to say I failed to respond to their comment unless it was abusive and therefore deleted, which is fortunately rare in itself.
Welcome to Hubpages also, it is nice to see you start off with the right idea about good manners and interacting with the community.
mistyhorizon2003....you're making me blush!!
When I receive a reply to a comment, it makes me appreciate the author even more!
What's the saying? ..."Nothing beats a failure but a try". What you do is to be applauded....I'm clapping right now!!! Go On Wit' Your Bad Self!! (bad, meaning good)
by Margaret Schindel 8 years ago
If I view my account's Comments page, it's easy to view, approve and respond to unapproved comments. However, if I go to a new comment in one of my hubs and click Approve, I cannot reply to it directly on the comment. Instead, I have to go to my main Comments page and find the now approved comment...
by Lesleysherwood 10 years ago
Do you find that leaving comments and replying to them increases your stats, or does it take you away (time wise) from writing hubs?
by Liz Elias 6 years ago
So, I've always thought it was the polite thing to do to reply to commenters, and thank them for their time and input, and I've made an effort to do so consistently.However, I'm wondering if this is now being discouraged by HP, as there is no available comment box for replies on hubs that have been...
by Misha 15 years ago
Pretty much like one would have it on a blog - with the difference that I am talking about hubtivity here.I had posted a single comment to one of the hubs a while ago. I am not too interested in the topic, just wanted to share my experience and forget. Well, the thing is - for many months this hub...
by SaritaJBonita 10 years ago
I've only written a handful of Hubs so far, and I knew that I would encounter this issue due to the nature of my writing. I have one Hubber who continues to post personal insults in the comments of all of my Hubs. This individual has also indicated that he votes down my pages because he...
by Gracie L Sprouse 6 years ago
Just learned that commenters have to be signed in or sign up in order to leave a comment on any hub.How is this going to help ???????? Who is going to bother to do this???? NOBODY!
Copyright © 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of The Arena Platform, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|