if it's truly self defence then i would say no. i would not give up my life if someone was trying to kill me just because some people think we should
DEFENSE, SELF-DEFENSE. A defense to certain criminal charges involving force
When people protect themselves/family or other people from potential harm from others with the use of lethal force then I would say it is murder.
Murder is usually defined as when someone takes the life of others purposely usually with some sort of felt "gain" by the perpetrator.
This could be felt as getting even or as retribution "which is legal is some parts of the world to restore family honor". Or it could be to help protect the identity of the perpetrator after a crime of theft or some other form of criminal act has been conducted. The old saying "Dead men tell no tales" comes to mind.
But if it is truly an act of self defense results int he loss of life, then no one has the right to call it murder.
This is a thorny and ambiguous question - and one that assumes that killing someone is the only form of self-defence.
In most situations of self defence - the person defending themselves will have a number of options open to them other than killing their adversary.
In most cases - if death is the apparently "accidental" or "unintended" result of the situation, then the charge would be manslaughter - or accidental manslaughter.
i.e. - if you hit someone on the head with a heavy object to protect yourself, and they later died of that injury.
Realistically it's a very difficult thing to argue in court. If you had wrestled a gun off an intruder, you would not have the right to shoot them (not in the UK anyway). If you were to shoot them having gained the weapon, this would be considered an act of anger, retribution, and premeditation - no matter how brief the premeditation.
Realistically self-defence is a term that refers to your instinctive reflex behaviour when attacked. Anything outside this is a response rather than a reaction.
by Rajan Singh Jolly5 years ago
Which is the best martial art form for self defence?
by DrNaj7 years ago
Is there such a thing as genocide in self-defense?I was a witness to what is now called genocide "Srebrenica- Bosnia". So, what do you guys think? Is there such a thing as genocide in self-defense?
by L. Andrew Marr8 years ago
It gets to a certain stage when the police in your home town said they don't care how many fights break out in the streets as long as there are no stabbings.I live in, what used to be, a nice little English town. I used...
by Deborah4 years ago
Is Jodi Arias guilty of murdering Travis Alexander or is was it self-defense?Jodi Arias admitted to brutally murdering her ex-boyfriend Travis Alexander, but was it in self defense? Is she a true psychopath?
by Buildreps13 months ago
How do you feel about Trump raising the defence budgets?Trump is intending to raise the defense budgets with about 10%. What has Trump to gain except increasing the globalist agenda, while saying he's against globalism....
by Rev Bruce S Noll HMN23 months ago
Do you think the American legal system is designed to protect the criminal or the victim?Our constitution indicates that we have the right to a fair and speedy trial and that the accused is considered innocent until...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.