jump to last post 1-3 of 3 discussions (4 posts)

Would Taylor Swift have done well as a competitor on American Idol?

  1. hawaiianodysseus profile image83
    hawaiianodysseusposted 4 years ago

    Would Taylor Swift have done well as a competitor on American Idol?

  2. HeatherH104 profile image83
    HeatherH104posted 4 years ago

    That is an interesting question! I only watched the first two or three years of idol and don't know how much it has changed. From what I saw of the show she probably would have made it through at least a few rounds because she is very cute and can sing. Her voice isn't super strong but I think her thing is mostly songwriting. Can't blame her for wanting to be the one to perform her own songs.

    Aloha friend. (I still can't get used to saying aloha. Lol!)

    1. hawaiianodysseus profile image83
      hawaiianodysseusposted 4 years agoin reply to this

      Thank you, Heather! It's interesting to compare how self-promotion compares with platform-promotion. Additionally, corporate promotion changes people. By the way, you're doing just fine with the aloha! : )

  3. GuitarGear profile image81
    GuitarGearposted 4 years ago

    I think she might have made it through a few rounds. She's very pretty and doesn't have a bad voice although it lacks the power and range I've seen in some of the more successful competitors.  I don't think the judges give points for being able to play an instrument either.  I think she chose the right path for her career.

 
working