Do you wash your fresh mushrooms before using them?
I asked about rice and got a lot of answers from rinsers and non-rinsers. Now I wonder about mushrooms. We use a lot of fresh mushrooms in cooking and salads. I used to buy the really white ones, they looked cleaner of course. But the brown, Crimini mushrooms have much more flavor. Yet, they are brown and kind of dirty looking, same with Shitakis which are delicious. "Real" mushroom people say you should use a little brush and gently brush the junk off. Also, if you wash mushrooms in water, they absorb much liquid and lose flavor. Soooo, what do you do? Wash, brush or nothing ?
Well I take them out of the bag, slice them up and cook them then eat them ! If they are a bit older I peel them . Never mentioned washing them in my hub about mushrooms either . Having some tonight with T Bone steak - yum !
With rice I now only rinse it as it is supposed to cook better says my husband -never did before !
Crimini are just a more mature white mushroom, left to grow for longer for more flavour. I never wash mine, just brush them and peel them if needed. Washing and peeling just takes some of the flavour away.
A quick rinse to remove dirt, peel if needed - hardly if it's nice and fresh, and straight to cooking. With white mushrooms I'm a little rough with them, all others, I handle with kid gloves as far as cleaning is concerned. Peace. Kawi.
Brush. My husband and I cook mushrooms in butter and bacon grease every Saturday morning as a little celebration that we have the day off together. We first cleaned them in water, which we do for everything because we both are OCD and germ/clean crazy, but they didn't taste so good. So we now brush them gently with only a little water to get the dirt off, then pat them with a paper towel to see if we missed any spots.
It's perfectly okay to wash mushrooms before you eat them (they don't really absorb that much liquid - you can weigh them before and after to see). The probably isn't loss of flavor through water absorption so much as it's a loss of flavor/aroma through the removal of spores, etc. When you wash (or rub too harshly), you scrape/rinse away the spores that reside on the outer part of the mushrooms, which can result in a loss of flavor/aroma. You can, instead, gently brush them with a damp paper towel - but the truth is that, for the most part, store-bought mushrooms aren't really that dirty anyway.
Washing vs brushing vs leaving them untouched will really only yield a minimal difference in flavor, etc. The worst you could do while washing/brushing would be to bruise or damage the mushroom itself, but that wouldn't mess with the flavor too much either. So it's really just a personal preference.
I'm no expert, by any means, xstatic, but in my "cooking" days, I washed them to remove any obvious grit under the running water and let them dry on a paper towel before tossing into a salad or cooking. I didn't scrub with a brush, but merely used my clean hands under running water to avoid abrading the tender exterior of the mushrooms.
It seems that fresh produce today is host to more bacteria (e-coli) than in the past, most likely due to less green space and the closer proximity of nearby farm animals to gardened areas. Many restaurants no longer offer scallions or sprouts due to bacterial contamination that infiltrates the plans through the root system. This, unfortunately, cannot be obliterated via any washing mechanism, including scrubbing. It is literally part of the produce. I haven't heard of anyone acquiring e-coli from mushrooms and the only danger seems to be with poisoning due to uninformed mushroom hunters.
I wash and peel them. I don't notice a big difference in the flavour by doing so as it's only a thin outer layer which I remove.
I always wash mine. Considering what a lot of them are grown in I just wouldn't feel comfortable not not washing them.
Yes I do wash mushrooms. As quickly as possible because they do absorb water. Looking at the water left behind from the mushrooms always makes me glad I have washed them.
I never wash my mushrooms, I gently wipe them off with a paper towel and make sure all the grit is off. I do this only because I heard many years ago that you should not wash mushrooms, ever. I do this with the white, the Crimini and the Shitakis.
Just recently I participated in a cooking school class and the chef told us to clean any kind of mushroom with a paper towel and do not rinse. I had always used a wet vegetable brush and now I don't.
Yes I do. I rinse the white and the crimini. However, because I like buying loose mushrooms, I'm less concerned with the grit and more concerned about rinsing off germs from others. Everything needs to be rinsed in this day and age of flus, viruses, staph, ecoli, and salmonella.
I only wash mushrooms if they look dirty or smell. Occasionally I peel all or part of them for the same reason. But I do sometimes think not washing is a bit foolhardy, because you don't know where they've been or who handled them last and whether they washed their hands after going to the toilet. Nonetheless, I have never been ill after eating them
I guess I must be a "real" mushrrom person. I gently brush them off with a paper towel or with my special little mushroom brush, never wash them, as they absorb water which makes them lose their flavor. I can't imagine why anyone would peel a mushroom.
Having said that, I would never eat a raw mushroom. I think it is important to cook them properly to make certain that any harmful bacteria is gone.
You're not supposed to wash them with water, you should wipe them off with a towel.
Never because mushrooms tend to absorb liquids and take on the flavor of whatever they do; and if it's water.. I feel it will keep them bland. I do however, peel the outer skin from them to get rid of the dirty parts.
I used some Criminis in the soup I made for lunch today, and as various chefs recommend only brushed them off and sliced them. These answers have really been interesting and varied.
Brushing will work just as good as peeling. I used to only brush them off my my mother in law recently showed me the peeling the outer skin method.. of course she gets rid of the stem too, but I think that's a waste.
sure! as I find a lot of dust there!
http://restaau.co.uk/ for UK restaurants searching!
by Beth Perry 5 years ago
Do you have your children wash their hands before eating?I was taught washing one's hands before eating is good sanitary practice, and likewise I still tell my kids to do this. But I've been told by a few that the practice is "old-fashioned" and worse, "anal". What do you think...
by H C Palting 7 years ago
Why do you think people don't wash their hands?I see people who use public restrooms and run out without washing their hands properly if they wash them at all. Many only use water, others get soap and immediately rinse it off, and other just immediately walk out without doing anything.
by Citrus000 10 years ago
If I am at someone's home I always check behind the shower curtain to make sure no one is in there. Any time I use an unfamiliar bathroom I make sure that there is toilet paper before I sit down, you don't need to make that mistake too many times before you figure it out.
by StrictlyQuotes 9 years ago
Does washing fruit in water before eating them sufficiently remove any traces of pesticides?
by Shasta Matova 7 years ago
How do you wash your clothes?I am interested in finding out how people from different parts of the world wash their clothes. Do you use a clothes washer for everything?Do you hand wash anything? What do you hand wash?Do you use a clothes dryer?Do you use a clothes line? How...
by Lovepocket 10 years ago
Mine is most likely a dragon*
Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|