With so many elements of Christmas being distinctly pagan:
Dec. 25 - Birthday of the Pagan Sun God, Mithra
Christmas Tree - Pagan Idol
Santa Clause - A lie and anti-christ in every sense of the word
Should Christians celebrate Christmas?
Santa Claus is the anti-christ? I think you got the letter order mixed up.
The term anti-christ applies to everyone that either is against Christ or takes the place of Christ in some way. The Bible speaks of many anti-christs. Santa Clause falls in that category.
Where is poor old Santa claiming to be Christ?
They're both eternal.
The're both all-knowing.
Their arrival is a mystery.
And it goes on. I include a more comprehensive list in a hub I wrote abot the topic, recently. And a cite a source at the bottom of my hub with a list of 25 points in which they're similar.
I would think that virtually everyone in the free world knows that Jesus wasn't born on December 25. That being said, He was born. That is what Christians celebrate on Christmas. If it would make things easier for you, perhaps we could celebrate it on June 16. Ultimately, one day, Jesus was born. We don't know what day that was precisely, but we choose to celebrate his birth on December 25.
Many Pagan symbols and traditions have been 'baptized' over time. Co-opted by Christians, if you will, to celebrate important events in the life of Christ.
Should we?? you ask?
We should, we do, we will, always celebrate Christmas. You should know that a tree and a specific date and etc. are not the basis for celebrating Christmas anyway. The birth of Jesus CHRIST is what we celebrate.
You can question whatever you want. But our answer remains the same always.
It's as if you're speaking for the whole of Christendom... But did you know that Jesus was not born on Dec. 25?
Good for you, Brenda. Early causes for a celebration on (or about) Dec. 25 varied from the winter solstice, the end of the harvest season, the birth of Mithra, the beginning of the sun's return and others. In terms of Christianity the date and celebration were created purely to encourage pagans to convert to Christianity.
Today the reason may be from a month of profits from rabid consumerism, a day of family togetherness, the birth of Christ, or just getting gifts if you are a small child. People celebrate by putting up decorations, sticking a tree in their living room, shopping, giving or by a day of prayer as well as other methods.
Why or how you celebrate doesn't matter. Dec. 25 is almost universally considered a day of love, of sharing and giving, and of family among all celebrants and is worthy of continuation simply because of that.
Santa CLAUS does not replace anyone. It is a harmless fiction that makes many children very happy.
Besides, he is based on St. Nicholas.
A church I went to in Georgia a few years ago shared the knowledge of history of December 25th and the christmas tree and it became a revelation and it changed my opinion of Christmas. I wondered if December 25th appropriate for celebrating the birth of Christ. I also stopped putting up a christmas tree, because I do believe it is an idol and santa clause has taken the place of christ. The only decorations I put up are the nativity sets and lights outside my home. I think some christians, ministers and churches are not knowledgeable about what took place on December 25th. If they fully were aware and embrace the history behind the date, maybe their opinions and views of celebrating Christ's birth on this date might change.
I think I will just stick to peace and goodwill to all persons.
I like this question. It's true. Santa is some what of a false idol. As a public figure, I think he works very nicely. but when you start breaking it down into proper Christianity, Santa is not Christ, and is thus taking away from his glory, and it is he who is to be celebrated.
That being said, yes, the Christmas date was set due to wanting to sway pagans to Christianity. Just like Easter is a mocking version of Oestera, the Spring celebration of fertility and the blossoming of the land for pagans.
I think that Christmas should be celebrated, and can be celebrated in the name of Jesus, just without focusing on his birth, and instead focusing on his messages: to love. The key to celebrating this message is not to do it just during this time, but year 'round. Love thy neighbor, love thy parents, love thy deity. Love is the way.
But as it stands, Christmas hardly seems to be about Love these days for many. It's about the consumerism. Selling products, buying expensive gifts, topping the gifts from last year, having the latest things, Black Friday - and so on. And don't get me started on the music.
Personally, I'm a bit of a Scruge. I'm not a fan of Christmas because it's gotten away from its true meaning. I get sucked into and forced to celebrate it every year. I just want to be around people, I don't want to feel pressured into buying things for every one.
I'm getting off topic.
I think that if Christians are going to keep love in their heart then they are celebrating it as Jesus would have wanted them to, regardless of the date. I think as long as every day is celebrated with love that Jesus's message will have been received unto the world.
And that does mean every one. Loving every one.
Everyone celebrates Christmas in their own way. You have no right to tell anyone they are celebrating "wrong". You don't have to buy into the crass commercialization of the holiday, which is a lot worse in the US than even Canada. Christmas really is what you make it for yourself.
As far as I know, it's possible to believe in Jesus and Santa Claus at the same time.
Actually, St. Nicholas did exist. There is more proof of his existence than of Jesus.
Even Scrooge believed in Christmas in the end...
Fist of all, I never told anyone they are celebrating Christmas "wrong". I just stated some facts about it. I'm sorry if they inconvenienced you. Second of all, even if I wanted to tell they people they are celebrating it "wrong", I do have that right; because I have a voice and I have every right to speak my opinions.
About Santa Clause being Saint Nicholas. If you do some more research, you will discover that everything we know about Saint Nicholas is derived from myth and legend. His name doesn't even appear in any documents from the era in which he supposedly lived. Here's a couple of links to help you:
I'm sorry that you have more faith in Santa Clause than in Jesus Christ. I don't! With that being said. Merry Christmas!
The catholic encyclopedia has mention of St. Nicholas, from the 4th century. Considering the time period, he is fairly well documented in church writings, and the encyclopedia even has small mention of the connection to Santa.
I just clicked the link you provided to see how well documented he was, and this is what it said: "...there is scarcely anything historically certain about him except that he was Bishop of Myra in the fourth century."
That is correct - he was mentioned in documents. Very little else is actually known, but he was mentioned.
That doesn't mean, however, that he is not the basis for the myth of Santa. Myths often have roots in fact even those roots are nothing like reality. The church made Nicholas into a saint, stories grew (true or not) and the myth began. Later additions include Rudolph, the north pole, toys and so on which had nothing to do with Nicholas's life, but that's what myths do.
I know this is petty but it is Santa Claus... there is no e... that is the title of a stupid movie.
by G. Diane Nelson Trotter 9 months ago
Why do non-Christians celebrate Christmas?Christmas is a celebration of the birthday of Christ. Why do non-Christians celebrate Christmas? Is this the reason people say the US government was founded based on Christian principles?
by Team Wiseman 5 months ago
Why do so many people choose to lie to their children about Santa?This is where "Christians" and the rest of the population are similar, they all lie to their children about Santa and that seems dangerous! Jesus Christ hates lies, so why do people do it on His so-called birthday?
by Renee' D. Campbell 5 years ago
Should Christians celebrate Halloween?I wonder if too much emphasis is put on the holiday to represent souls and spirits. I see it as a day for people to really enoy life, be something or someone else, and have fun. What do you think?
by Susan Keeping 5 years ago
Why are so many people critical of how others celebrate Christmas?Christmas is what you make it and you have every right to celebrate it the way you wish. It is not only for Christians anymore. It is a societal tradition that will not go away as religions decline. It is a time to be happy, to...
by cprice75 5 years ago
Is it wrong for Christians to celebrate Christmas?Some Christians argue against the celebration of Christmas because Jesus probably wasn't born on December 25 and many of the traditions are pagan.
by Paul Swendson 7 years ago
Personally, I think that these holidays, like all holidays, have taken on a life of their own. So the "secular" versions of the holidays are just as legitimate to celebrate. After all, how often to people ponder the historical roots and deeper meanings of our holidays?
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|